Open 431 - Sword Swallowing - Game Over

[funkybike1]

And I shall. Hello everybody! Reading through, at least it's only 8 pages.

[funkybike1]

One thing I should say is that we shouldn't try to rush things.
I did notice something interesting, however.

If TheShadow is town, he would have had no reason to vote, and then simply follow it up with "the vote is on scum" rather than making a case.
There were nearly TWO DAYS between the vote and unvote, which is plenty of time for a quickhammer.
Scum did not quickhammer.
Therefore, TheShadow must be scum.

[funkybike1]

Ok, fine. "Shadow or I am scum."

[funkybike1]

A longer explanation:

UNVOTE RIGHT THE FUCK NOW UNLESS YOU ENJOY QUICKHAMMERS PLEASE

The vote is on scum. I will not be unvoting unless something changes the read.

After TheShadow voted, there was a quite predictable response from Xalxe. Shadow followed this up not by unvoting, but by simply stating that he believed that split was scum. Shadow certainly knows the risks of leaving a stray vote out in lylo, so why would he have ever done this as town?

Alright I"m going to

UNVOTE

for now.
A large part of my case on split was inactivity and lack of content. I'll wait and see what funky has to say.

In other words, Shadow, if he is town, was willing to risk the game with a meaningless lurker vote at lylo. He himself admitted that nearly his entire case was for lurking! He knew the risks - so why did he do that? The only possible answer is that he is scum.

I'll wait to give TheShadow a chance to respond before voting, but it will take a lot to make me think this was simply an honest mistake.

[funkybike1]

Well, would you care to give us these reasons?

[funkybike1]

If TheShadow was indeed planning a trap, he likely wouldn't have let it go 47 hours.

[funkybike1]

Quick notes: I have no idea who's scum besides TheShadow.

yes this is a prod dodge why are you asking

[funkybike1]

A real slow game, lack of posts and all. Waiting for IceGuy's read before I vote, just in case.

[funkybike1]

gg