Open 458: Carbon-14 (Over!)

2birds1stone · Post Post #284 (isolation #0) » Mon Nov 12, 2012 12:29 pm

Reading now.

Page one makes me think Electric is scum though.

Will vote when I've finished reading.

2birds1stone · Post Post #285 (isolation #1) » Mon Nov 12, 2012 12:47 pm

Fuck rereading.

Read last page.

Says everything.

Empking is bordering on obvtown as of page three, and Mhork could easily be Electric's partner as of page two. Batt inno on Empking is way more plausible than Mhork guilty on Batt. Also, fakeclaiming inno in LyLo.

Vote: Lord Mhork

2birds1stone · Post Post #286 (isolation #2) » Mon Nov 12, 2012 12:51 pm

...

unvote

Eh, read page eleven. It's not as clean-cut a situation as I'd hoped.

Will still probably be voting Mhork, but it looks like I'll be reading after all.

2birds1stone · Post Post #287 (isolation #3) » Mon Nov 12, 2012 1:36 pm

Apologies for quad-posting.

In post 264, Battousai wrote:Oh, and while I'm here and remember. My initial list, I kinda did lie about what it meant. Initially, when I had the town read on Emp and from that CE, I created it so I could narrow down my investigation targets as the game progressed. It wasn't too much of a lie, since it also was pretty much a list of people I don't find town. But obviously, I couldn't say it was my target list.

I do this. I mean, my philosophy behind investigation targets is different, but I do make lists of viable targets.

As far as I'm concerned is a reasonable towntell. It's just a freaking weird thing to make up, and not only that, it's weird to make something up and then go back and reference it six pages later without inconsistency. Sure, it's not a foolproof tell, but look what he's up against.

Mhork has been null-scum all day. His first content post was, as someone pointed out, a "Why'd you

move the game along

take somene to L-1?" Since then, he's posted the bare minimum, genereally contentless sarcasm.

Vote: Mhork

2birds1stone · Post Post #298 (isolation #4) » Mon Nov 12, 2012 2:57 pm

shos wrote:well this game is not being talked too much now, so I'm going to
Vote: Lord Mhork
and wait for others to lynch.

2b1s, this game really isn't that long or elaborate, you should reread and comment.

I did. My first post and my fourth post. The game is unelaborate enough to be summed up in those two posts.

FTR, last time I played with Mhork, he didn't give up this easily. I was scum with Kondi, and we had the town totally confused and clueless in LyLo, but Mhork didn't go throwing "I give up I hate you all" sentiments.

Honestly, Mhork's pretty obvious scum IMO.

2birds1stone · Post Post #299 (isolation #5) » Mon Nov 12, 2012 2:58 pm

The only thing that bugs (and it's a pretty small thing) is that Batts didn't vote Mhork on being CC'd.

2birds1stone · Post Post #301 (isolation #6) » Mon Nov 12, 2012 3:01 pm

In post 295, Empking wrote:
In post 293, Lord Mhork wrote:Empking, whose claim do you believe?

Yours. I'm not 100%, and I'm not going to join in with this speedy circus.

I actually think more LyLos should be quick lynches. Ideally, decide on who's hammering, popcorn claim if applicable, post meta if requested, then quicklynch. Non-LyLo days are for scumhunting.

2birds1stone · Post Post #317 (isolation #7) » Wed Nov 14, 2012 6:53 pm

/not hammer

Ugh. This sucks. Tempted to sheep Batts and be done with it.

I'll be back to rereread hammer tomorrow. You two behave yourself while I'm gone.

2birds1stone · Post Post #338 (isolation #8) » Thu Nov 15, 2012 3:27 pm

I started skimming shos' walls

then I went "Why am I reading this stuff? There's a gamethread to read."

Save your breath, shos. Same goes to Empking (though he's been pretty good about it). Reading now. Hammer should come within about an hour, maybe less, maybe more.

2birds1stone · Post Post #341 (isolation #9) » Thu Nov 15, 2012 4:36 pm

Fuck.

I see nothing scummy in either of you.

The only thing I've got, and literally the only thing I've got, to the point where I'm hammering over it, is some obvious distancing on Mhork's part near the end of the day, along with some odd interactions between him and Empking.

I'm really sorry guys, even if I hammer correctly, this is a shitty hammer, but after the obvscum that was Mhork, there simply isn't anything else I can glean from reading.

Vote: Empking

Sorry for the late hammer shos, I got a phone call during my reread.

2birds1stone · Post Post #345 (isolation #10) » Thu Nov 15, 2012 4:44 pm

2birds1stone · Post Post #347 (isolation #11) » Thu Nov 15, 2012 5:06 pm

Counterclaiming isn't necessarily bad in 5-way, but Batts' claim was really strong, and Mhork simply wasn't townie enough prior to his claim for it to be workable. Also, I was available for mislynch based solely on my predecessor's play; the counterclaim essentially moved me from probscum to conftown.

Will be interested to see scum QT.