Open 517: Faith(PLUS)One - GAME OVER!

[NSin]

'sup.

[NSin]

yessiree is town.
VOTE: kibbles0515

[NSin]

Kibble's fluff as well as his attempt at being cute(?) sounds extremely forced.

[NSin]

Looking at his ISO a lot of things rubbed me the wrong way.

But to answer your question, I'm doing great!

Newbies that replaced in mislynched me in my previous game, so I'm looking forward to actually playing this time around.

A weird stab at sympathetic AtE so early in the game.

Kibbles

this isn't the newbie section

what are you doing?

What are you doing?
UNVOTE:

This is what really rubbed me in the wrong way. His reaction was to shoot back the question

and

unvote. I see agressive town motivation behind shooting back the question but the unvote smelled like scum backing out, thinking 'oh no, I'm caught.'

Cute

though RVS is over

My vote on yessiree is serious and it would be nice if you would follow it

Are you gonna make your case or just vote and hope we figure it out?

A case? Asking for a case off a blatant joke post that was fishing for reactions?

Pretty sure yessiree was joking...it is weird that SoundsofMusic is so sure he isn't. Hmm...

You can see through jokes, of course. Not the one above, I'm sure.

>_< just realized I nearly copied uncle's post verbatim. Also, good read on bubbajack, yessiree; why would you claim fencesitting and then still vote? Seems scummy to me.
VOTE: bubbajack

Opportunistic jump onto a potential wagon with no reasons or reads of his own.

Not really. We would be the worst scumteam in the world if we both voted for the same guy twice within two pages. I mean...that's just terrible play. You can't seriously think we'd be that terribly bad at being scum, can you?

"Too scummy to be scum" lol.

[WIFOM]This isn't a newbie game. It stands to reason that all players, scum or not, have a reasonable amount of experience being both town and scum. Therefore, why would scum so obviously vote together multiple times? Unless they weren't scum? That would make it way too easy for anyone in the coming days to do a simple reread and see the connection...that's really poor scum play, and i would be shocked if a) scum was dumb enough to try it, and b) town was dumb enough to let scum get away with it. Would scum-kibbles write this long explanation to avoid suspicion? You tell me.[/WIFOM]

He follows up with blatant WIFOM? What? Why would you ever try to use WIFOM as a defense when you're town.

OMG I LOVE SMILEYS.

B A

=

What the fuck?

My apologies.

@bubba:

Do you have any actual response to my rather thorough explanation? Am I right or wrong? Am I town or scum?

Oh look he hasn't given any reads yet, but he's asking for people to read him. Who would care about their own appearance over finding scum? Scum.
TL: "Is the 'Too Dumb To Be Scum' working?"

Oh I'm not saying

I'm

2D2BS. I'm soopersmart at scum. But for two scum to sheep each other's votes right after each other

twice

so soon in the game seems too...too...unlikely? I just see that as so anti-scum (anti-scum here means doing the opposite of scum's goals: to lay low and pick off town one by one), that it would be an utter failure. In conclusion, at least one of us (me or yessir) is town.

Nice. You refute why you and yessiree can't be scum together but not why you yourself can be scum.
Subtle dodge but it ain't getting past me.

Why do you bring this point up?

Because I don't see how I am scum with Yessir. It makes no sense.

Yessiree is town and you're scum. That makes perfect sense.

[NSin]

Y'all should vote kibbles or give me a good reason for not wanting to.

[NSin]

@NSin, a question about this post: why do you call SoundofMusic a "blatant joke post that was fishing for reactions" #29, when SoM later defended her vote?

I found SoM's vote in 29 specifically, to be a discussion generator more than an actual read. SoM found reasons to keep the vote there since then, probably.

[NSin]

I won't bother with the quote wall, it's getting too long. And some of it was all fluff to (hopefully) get newbies to sheep me.

TL;DR
The way you've been playing, Kibbles, doesn't show that you aren't dense enough to not see that SoM's 29 AND yesiree's playstyle is pot-stirring/discussion-generating more than actual serious play whether they themselves are aware of it or not.

And yes, you are using 2D2BS wifom as a defense. Don't deny that.


Also, I honestly do not give a damn about if anyone agrees with my scumreads.

I'd rather read a person based on their reactions rather than whether they agree with me or not.

[NSin]

>_>
I promise to delve into this game soon

[NSin]

Hi.
Not much I can say here, except that you guys look like townies who had a visit from the hash monster.

Vote Kibbles. Where'd he go?

[NSin]

If my wagon isn't scummy as fuck, I don't know what is.

*cough* my wagon *cough.

You're implying what?

[NSin]

If my wagon isn't scummy as fuck, I don't know what is.

There are two ways of interpreting this.

1) My wagon as the wagon on daphne. This would mean this is an attempt at outrage rather than providing real analysis.

2) My wagon being the wagon he feels responsible for starting. This would then be a scum slip.

Why would you even consider #2?

[NSin]

Sorry bowser, replace me out

[NSin]

e.e
nvm I'll stay in.

[NSin]

Okay, quick run-down of how I see the game.

From experience on my main it tells me not to listen to Titus, bubbajack, Noctan, and kibbles regardless of alignment since they tend to be derpy.

UNVOTE:
I don't feel very comfortable voting kibbles anymore since I can't read him worth jack shit now, along with everyone on the list above.

[NSin]

Okay, quick run-down of how I see the game.

From experience on my main it tells me not to listen to Titus, bubbajack, Noctan, and kibbles regardless of alignment since they tend to be derpy.

UNVOTE:
I don't feel very comfortable voting kibbles anymore since I can't read him worth jack shit now, along with everyone on the list above.

... Your run down of how you see the game is not to listen to four people?

Seriously?

Ayup. Now that you mention it y'all probably shouldn't listen to yessiree, sal, or toxic, either.

[NSin]

--reasons--

[NSin]

Obviously, I don't have a scumread on kibbles.
VOTE: kibbles

[NSin]

I agree with TunnelVision, so I reread drmshake (fuzzy's replacement).
What stood out was Post 215.
After laying low and playing quiet, drm finally offers some content, calling the interaction between Sundy and uncledaphne (later, SalmonellaDreams) "scum theater," but doesn't lay down a vote or even a FOS.
VOTE: fuzzy

Hey, Kibbles, wanna know a secret?
I'm not Drm, nor will I ever be Drm. Voting me for something Drm did is like blowing up the moon because you don't like the Night. It just doesn't make sense. Find a better reason to vote me or gtfo.

Hey fuzzy if you dont like kibbles vote him

[NSin]

You don't blow up the moon, you steal the moon. and the Declaration of Independence while yer at it.

[NSin]

kill kibbles

[NSin]

kibbles

[NSin]

^ lies

[NSin]

VOTE: fuzzybutternut

[NSin]

@SoundsofMusic: who did you investigate last night and what was the result.

[NSin]

I'm conftown?
cool

[NSin]

cool I'm conftown

[NSin]

It's hohum or you

[NSin]

I'm conftown, durr

[NSin]

conftownitis kills

[NSin]

Ugh.
Too late to find a different replacement, Bowser?

If so, replace me out. I refuse to play with Keybladewielder.

[NSin]

Scratch that the game has gone long enough and my death is imminent
VOTE: hohum