Open 560: Tit for Tat (Game Over, 4/12 alive)

[notscience]

Hi.

I am town.

[notscience]

Who is moonlight

Because I don't recognize that name

I'm reading tonight/tomorrow.

[notscience]

fucking lol the first two pages

[notscience]

Sorry

I got distracted

I'll read this when I get back from the MVA tomorrow

[notscience]

I'm going to post as I read up because walling is boring

[notscience]

Guys I think we should massclaim. Whoever got Role Cop should claim first and we can popcorn from there.

Rid's probtown, mostly because xfdagentx42 and Not_Mafia are scum together.

Vote: xfdagentx42.

the fuck is this

Fuck no

yay mala's town

Yo Rid what do you think of the people in this game who aren't yourself?
You're not allowed to say that Mala is town though cuz I'm saying that right now and you saying it would be stealing and stealing is wrong.

I SAID IT FIRST

SUCK IT

Here is the order of how I'm going to vote.

1. Riddleton
2. Krysrtal Bald
3. Not_Mafia
4. T S O

Official Vote: Riddleton

the fuck is this

1) To address the TSO post, we can talk about the "spirit of the game" nature of that play post-game. Null reaction to the question based on what we know of TSO, but happy we're out of RVS because of it.

Xfd, insanity, and Hgh came in post game-start and made no comments to the issue, infact appeared to wish to resurrect RVS. Why are you RVS'ing when stuff has happenned?

We also don't agree with the statement from KB that TSO's demeanor changed at all, or that a perceived change even matters, because he had his role when he made the accusation. It would be different if he didn't have his role, made this play pre-roles, and acted different once the game started. Trolls be trolling.

2) Flavor response

Our daughter is going to 3rd grade ACE classes next year, and the kids will have to vote on what subjects they are taught. This is a laughable exercise, because the choices are going to be like... Dinosaurs and Mythical Creatures, or Art and Music appreciation. The classes are inevitably chosen by how many boys and girls are in the class that year.

That said, We dissonantly

choose A

based on rock paper scissors (good ol' rock!).

3) Riddleton's newness: We thought the whole idea behind the Road to Rome wasn't to teach people how to play mafia, but to teach people how to play mafia

here

. His lack of MS experience will inevitably (and has already) waste time. We strongly encourage him to join a newbie game.

Right now, we see him newbtelling more than town/scumtelling (like #74), but of the votes on him, we appreciate the Not_Mafia vote as the only real attempt to pressure with reasoning. We don't like HGH's vote because he fingers everyone who is contributing to the conversation, no reasoning, no contribution of his own.

Tammy, does Riddleton's being a new player change your reaction to him not voting in RVS?

Malakittens, same question?

HGH, what are the reasons for your list in #114?

vote: HGH7193

Okay, you might be town. The pre-game was still fucking hilarious though

I made the list because I feel that there may be one mafia member in there or maybe two because if they post early they will not look suspicious....other than lurking which won't go unnoticed and get them lynched.

"Look at me, I'm predicting 1 mafia in a group of 4! I'm so protown!"

Why do you think Mala is town?

why don't you

Mala hasn't done anything alignment indicative yet, so I'm not sure why he thinks she's town.

I had Krystal Bald as probably town rather early.

she called bs at the right time call bs

its enough for a townlean at the very least

In other news, we should vote Tammy.

VOTE: Tammy

...

Really?

In other news, we should vote Tammy.

VOTE: Tammy

You're a funny girl.

That's not an answer for why I'm

practically an innocent child here

and of anyone you should have the answer to that.

I'm not practically an IC. I am an IC. Always am as town.

VOTE: MALALKITTENS

not omgus.

yes omgus

VOTE: MALALKITTENS

not omgus.

totes is.

^

Done reading for the moment still going tho

[notscience]

I'll read when I'm back from my cousin's birthday party.

[notscience]

Not it!

[notscience]

I'd read right now but I'm on tilt so it's probably not the best idea.

Sorry I keep putting it off.

[notscience]

No I just rolled lollazy

[notscience]

Today I'm just procrastinating

yesterday I was seriously on tilt

[notscience]

scum ns at least reads the game

[notscience]

what

[notscience]

why did oyu hammer nm

[notscience]

Scumclaim I see

kthanks

[notscience]

I'm town!

[notscience]

You hammered someone without a claim without everyone caught up because you were bored?

Or you were worried I'd catch up and swing things around

[notscience]

Wow. Not_Mafia is almost assuredly town.

But I'm just wondering whether you thought Moonlight's reaction was scummier than Neil's or because you didn't want to (actually) vote for Neil due to L-1?

This.

N_M is deff town or really good scum move for this.

Idk I still don't like Neil. I can see moonlights argument, but who knows. Some people don't like fake claiming.

but now I really like ns and I realize he was just being lazy yesterday and doesn't have a scum role pm

@neil: have you ever fake claimed as scum..?

ftfy

[notscience]

I've read all of 10 pages and know that's a bad wagon

[notscience]

son of a

[notscience]

I'm still town

[notscience]

Oh right

this game is a thing

[notscience]

Hey NM

I have a present for you

[notscience]

I should probably finish reading this game.

btw, Insanity is town

and this is totally me trying to abate the person voting me and not me making ap oint that scum have no reason to vote anyone outside of 2 already voting in lylo

[notscience]

Heph what was your claim again

[notscience]

Well, I guess I must be scum then!

[notscience]

The lack of a hammer on me is disconcerting.

[notscience]

Sure.

Let's go with that.

[notscience]

I feel like you're scum

not sure which of moon/insan is.

Because I feel like scum-you would decide that moon is an easier fight than me.

[notscience]

I could see either alignment doing it.

[notscience]

I actually might just OMGUS insanity because mala was scumreading her

[notscience]

The above definitely makes it easier to townread moonlight.

The above definitely isn't sarcasm.

[notscience]

Yep I'm totally scum

Want me to selfvote so you can hammer and

lose

win game for town?

[notscience]

I mean, if we're trying to call me scum we can highlight how mala started freaking out because I'm playing to my scum meta

Hell, I was still plying it even into today

And I mean, look at my lylo play- I'm keeping all options open because that's just how scum-ns operates

[notscience]

Yep

I'm 100% of my own meta

And 100% aware that this has been to my scum meta (hence mala's suspicion)

You know the best part?

I'm not actually scum

lol

[notscience]

Obviously

Stop trying to get other people to take your stances for you

[notscience]

Because I can?

[notscience]

VOTE: insanity

[notscience]

But really? You lynched my slot? You know, the one who got Elmo lynched in the most non-bus-like push ever?

ns wasn't even particularly scummy.

sarcasm=scum apparently

[notscience]

@notscience: You managed to replace into a slot that looked Town as fuck and turn it into a huge question mark with your laziness. There is a reason I limit myself to 1 game at a time; if I did too many, I would become as dispassionate as you. Your naked vote on insanity disgusted me despite it being right. It was as if you had nothing to comment on, and I believe I gave you plenty of room to interact with me. What a waste of potential. The silver lining in this is that now I know I can be a good IC, because I cannot imagine doing worse than you.

1) I thought I'd have the patience to finish reading and didn't

2) I'm not dispassionate, I just never finished reading so I didn't particularly care

3) So a right vote in lylo disgusts you? undeserved reachouts disgust me too!

4) What did you want me to comment on? The weather?

5) Yes, because a lylo reachout leaves great room for reachout and definitely doesn't make me think buddy!

6) That's fine, I was a shit IC anyways because I drew scum

[notscience]

I was going to question insanity early day one when I finished catching up but got distracted.

Seriously, if you don't know how to read me in the first place don't pull dumb as shit reaction tests. You don't know what you're doing or looking for so all you end up doing is causing a distraction and pissing me off. And it especially doesn't help if I'm already suspicious of you. Also telling me you don't know what I'm catching up on when I haven't read the damn game is annoying.

yeah tammy was really town lol

[notscience]

ikr

although tbh I voted insanity because she was mala's top scumread

But I knew something felt off about nm

[notscience]

His last game was too

[notscience]

I'm not the one who voted town in lylo lol

[notscience]

And there are too many people stealing Rach's pet name for me

I don't like it

[notscience]

I'm sorry ns Moon has every right to be a dick to me but you can shut your mouth like you did for the majority of the game anyway

lol

[notscience]

When notscience said that insanity must be town because she's voting him, I'm thinking that sealed notscience's fate and he would have been pegged as scum. If in a LyLo situation, if you are a townie, and someone votes you, and you don't get quickhammered, that means the person voting you is scum. I have no idea why notscience said insanity would be town.

me neither

lol