In post 608, Shinobi wrote:I still think the Aero slot is scum, btw.
Well I think your slot is scum!
So that!
In post 608, Shinobi wrote:I still think the Aero slot is scum, btw.
In post 589, ika wrote:btw aro is prob sucm too
In post 626, Something_Smart wrote:His reasoning feels weak and forced, his voting patterns are opportunistic (especially the Shadow vote), his whole "has/hasn't mentioned" thing pings me wrong, and his case on ika for hammering after he himself put Shadow at L-1 is hypocritical.
In post 632, SilverWolf wrote:ika-if you hammer for no reason I will be pissed
In post 634, SilverWolf wrote:Not really? Like, what said should do the opposite of that unless he's scum. If he wants to declare intent that's fine. I also think SO should just go ahead and claim at this point.
In post 637, ika wrote:fire is a trolll and form my homesite, i know he prob didnt knwo about me/silver so im giving him a by FTM.
In post 637, ika wrote:hi fire, im goign to ignore the fact right now that you amde that comment to my GF and hope you didt mean anythign by that
In post 647, ika wrote:vote her then?
In post 653, SilverWolf wrote:Also, firebringer until recently, I've always been tryhard in games. I've decided recently it isn't work the effort. Again, though which posts look scummy to you?
In post 674, Something_Smart wrote:Firebringer: Likely Unlikely
In post 679, Viva La Gloria wrote:Why do you think that Fire (who replaced Aero btw) is not likely to be fire mafia?
I don't understand how you can possibly put firebringer in the same category as Shinobi here.
You need to do some heavy explaining of these reads.
In post 685, Something_Smart wrote:VOTE: Firebringer
Probably ice, not sure what Viva was thinking, interactions with SO are terrible.
I'd also probably be ok lynching masq or snarky.
In post 688, Aristophanes wrote:That's okay. They're probably the last Fire goon anyway.
In post 694, Viva La Gloria wrote:I think SW/Aeronaut's interactions were awful and that's the main reason I'm on FB.
In post 697, Something_Smart wrote:@Viva: I kind of see what you mean, but after Fire replaced in he did scumread and interact with SW, whereas he soft defended SO and dropped it when his wagon became serious.
In post 715, Viva La Gloria wrote:So the Silverwolf kill was likely a deliberate attempt to cross kill, since she didn't have any clear scumreads besides Shinobi / Fire, which means that last Ice is probably someone who was scumreading her.
(And Shinobi/Fire fit in that category as well.)
I'm going to go through some ISOs.
In post 719, Something_Smart wrote:Hi, I'm back.
Aristo and Viva are likely town. Both are honestly scumhunting and are not just hunting one scum, either.
Shinobi I still don't like but his interactions with SO and SW were very likely not scum-scum, so I do think he's town.
Snarky's near impossible to read, on purpose I think, so he very well could be scum. (Fire, given his stance on SO.)
Masq is mild town, as he is doing some real scumhunting, but I could see him being Fire, as he is only hunting Ice.
Firebringer is probably Ice, given his lack of good interaction with SO and his general defensiveness.
In post 802, Viva La Gloria wrote:Oh, and that 'new' most-least ice list is basically {3 people who didn't vote SO}{3 people who did, with me as most scummy of them}
So extremely fabricated.
In post 800, SnarkySnowman wrote:~Most Ice~
Masq
Shinobi
Firebringer
VLG
Aristo
Something Smart
~Least Ice~
Was what I meant - my b.
VLG is still definitely scum though.
In post 804, SnarkySnowman wrote:You're 110% scum though.
In post 812, Viva La Gloria wrote:Why do you believe that any more thought when into Snarky's reads than he's posted?
His reads don't jive whatsoever and the Ice list is indeed the 3 people who didn't vote -> 3 who did.
Do you think having me as most likely of the SO voters to be scum makes any sense whatsoever?
I don't think I make a ton of sense as Fire either but given that it's not as smoking gun obvious I'm not even going to address that.
In post 870, Something_Smart wrote:
Kill this with fire, which will be particularly effective in this case
In post 874, Masquerade wrote:Firebringer, you never trust me. What is it exactly that you're scumreading me forthisgame?
In post 872, SnarkySnowman wrote:Okay I kinda like Firebringer as scum now.
In post 904, Shinobi wrote:Just an FYI that I'm never joining you in your crusade to do the strangest thing ever and will continue to vote firebringer.
In post 896, Masquerade wrote:but I have more evidence that points to Firebringer being ice over fire.
Oh well, I guess he's scum either way does it really matter?
In post 879, Masquerade wrote:
Ok so you not trusting me means we're both town then, right?
Anyway, you didn't answer my question there. What are you scumreading me for? What did I do here that makes you not trust me? If it's just because I can fool you as scum you should try harder to sort me.
In post 910, Shinobi wrote:Nah I'm voting you because your slot is scummy outside of interactions.
In post 917, Shinobi wrote:So...It's okay that I'm voting you or something?
In post 921, Aristophanes wrote:That's very FB.
In post 926, Masquerade wrote:Bah I can't make my mind up on Firebringer. Starting to lean town on him again. I retract my intent to hammer for now. Will look into things again tonight when I get home.
In post 937, Something_Smart wrote:Viva, if I were Fire why would I be trying to lynch Ice, when it would then be 4:1, rather than trying to nightkill them, leading to 3:1? Compare my push on Firebringer to Masquerade, who appears to be scumreading him but won't admit it, because they don't want to lynch Ice, and tell me how Masq is town here.
In post 958, Shinobi wrote:What was towny about fire's posting?
In post 966, Aristophanes wrote:Just noticed our timeline. We have intent, right?
In post 967, Something_Smart wrote:Masq retracted intent. Masq, if you don't hammer, you're almost confirmed Fire.
Aristo, I agree with you being towny and this feels like a town mindset. I think Masq is scumreading you to avoid lynching Firebringer.
In post 970, Something_Smart wrote:Or you could be nice and protown and hammer yourself
Pedit: No, I think Masq's Aristo scumread is phony.
In post 972, Something_Smart wrote:I'm insulted
You're not town so self-hammering is protown. Of course it's also against your wincon but whatever.