Open 222 - Vengeful Mafia - Game Over!

[Robocopter87]

Dude, I got no appendix! I just got home when I posted that. I can't really stay here and read threads at this moment.

Should we massclaim? Just asking...

Vote Count:

Phaen

(1) - semioldguy

semioldguy

(1) - Nobody Special

Chronopie

(1) - Phaen

Robocopter87

(1) - Chronopie

Nobody Special

(0)

Not Voting

(1) - Robocopter87

With 5 alive, 3 votes will achieve a lynch.

[Phaen]

Should we massclaim? Just asking...

^ Hasn't read the setup

[Chronopie]

Setup: 3x Vengeful Townie, 1x Goon, 1x GF

Predicted MC: 5x Vengeful.

ofc If you want to claim scum, feel free.

[Robocopter87]

facepalm
Sorry people.

What usually goes on in a vengeful? Massclaiming won't do anything sorry. I'm pretty sure this is just going to be plain scumhunting.

[semioldguy]

Plain scumhunting and looking for a connection between a goon and godfather, since the lynch of the godfather will end the game the goon isn't going to be on that lynch, which means if we do find the godfather it would take all three of us on the wagon to win.

@Robocopter87
Your thoughts on the game thus far? Reason for not random voting or who would you vote for right now if the choice had to be made?

[Phaen]

So how do we even get the ball rolling as far as scumhunting/actual content goes? Most of my games onsite have been replace-ins so I've never had any practice getting out of RVS.

[Robocopter87]

@Robocopter87
Your thoughts on the game thus far? Reason for not random voting or who would you vote for right now if the choice had to be made?

You can call me Robo, its much easier.
I don't think a five man RVS is the smartest thing in the world so I rather not vote randomly. I don't think I'll be voting anyone for a while till we have some more input.

[Phaen]

Myths

1. Mafia should be able to win by quicklynching;

However: Due to the lynched townie's vigilante kill, it's not likely that the mafia will be able to pull this off without losing a member. If it's obvious who the mafia are, one will be vigged, and the other lynched on Day 2.

MOD EDIT: Fixed quote tag.

[Robocopter87]

OBJECTION!
Sorry had to say that but just because the Mafia lost a member doesn't mean they lost. In this game type, if a Vengeful Townie is killed by a hypothetical quick lynch. Then if the Vengeful Townie kills another townie, its game over. But of course they would know exactly who is the Mafia due to quicklynch BUT if its an EARLY quicklynch in RVS it might be an accidental townie who thinks RVS's are cool and just voted without checking the vote count. Thus why I dislike the RVS in a five man Venge.

Also, Phaen you kinda need quotation marks around the name of your quote.

[Chronopie]

That much is obvious.

Right now I have 2 votes. If anyone decided to cast the hammer, on page two (i.e. quicklynch), I'd shoot them.

[Chronopie]

EBWOP: any townie should be checking the vote counts, so handily at the top of the page, therefore, if anyone quicklynch hammered, I would feel justified in retaliating.

[Chronopie]

EBEBWOP: I don't *have* two votes, I meant to say *if I had* two votes.

[semioldguy]

Every vengeful game I join there is always someone paranoid to vote or scared to put someone at L-1. A random voting stage isn't that big of a deal. L-1 on day one, even page one, isn't that big of a deal. It's going to happen, and it's probably going to happen several times. L-1 is only two people voting for the same person, if everyone is too scared to vote for someone that already has a vote, then nothing happens.

Unvote; Vote: Robocopter87

Refusing or holding out to vote is bad regardless of alignment. If you are scum, it lets you sit back and see where and how you can push or go along with the town to achieve the most likely mislynch. If you are town it gives scum the opportunity to take the lead in voting and leading with less or no opposition than they would otherwise have.

Also I intend to continue to call you Robocopter87. I don't use abbreviations for player names.

[Nobody Special]

Well, this is interesting.

While I agree with semioldguy that holding out a vote could be scummy (a form of lurking as it were), I'm not going to hammer until robocopter comes back (with or without appendix) and explains himself.

So, robocop, who do you find scummiest?

If you were hammered right now, who you you Kill Vengefully (assuming you are town)?

On that note,

are

you town?

[Phaen]

I'm interested to see what Robo will say.

Unlike Nobody Special, with the current information and early state of the game, I'm not comfortable hammering this.

[Nobody Special]

I'm interested to see what Robo will say.

Unlike Nobody Special, with the current information and early state of the game, I'm not comfortable hammering this.

Stop misrepping me. Nowhere did I say I was "comfortable" hammering him. On the contrary, I said I was NOT going to hammer, and that I was going to (again) NOT HAMMER pending robocop's answering of the questions.

[Robocopter87]

Every vengeful game I join there is always someone paranoid to vote or scared to put someone at L-1. A random voting stage isn't that big of a deal. L-1 on day one, even page one, isn't that big of a deal. It's going to happen, and it's probably going to happen several times. L-1 is only two people voting for the same person, if everyone is too scared to vote for someone that already has a vote, then nothing happens.

Unvote; Vote: Robocopter87

Refusing or holding out to vote is bad regardless of alignment. If you are scum, it lets you sit back and see where and how you can push or go along with the town to achieve the most likely mislynch. If you are town it gives scum the opportunity to take the lead in voting and leading with less or no opposition than they would otherwise have.

Also I intend to continue to call you Robocopter87. I don't use abbreviations for player names.

Watev.

So, robocop, who do you find scummiest?

No one.

If you were hammered right now, who you you Kill Vengefully (assuming you are town)?

On that note, are you town?

This question I will take seriously, I would randomly choose anybody due to the 50% chance of nailing scum and my judgement would most likely make it less.

Second question is just stupid. I refuse to answer.

[Robocopter87]

Hammering me is almost a good idea due to our odds.

[Nobody Special]

I refuse to answer.

Noted.

Hammering me is almost a good idea due to our odds.

And yet you still aren't voting.

[Robocopter87]

You want me to self vote?

[Nobody Special]

That's not what I said.

[Robocopter87]

I said that hammering me is a possible smart move.

You said that I'm being hypocritical and need to cast votes.

What i'm sayin is, I think we should kill me, maybe, im not so sure but you said that I need to vote. Your supposed to vote for who you want dead. I think I should be. So yes, technically, that is what you said.

[Chronopie]

How is asking to die (in a 5-man vengeful) a smart town move. especially on D2.

The wifom is inherent in this one.

[Nobody Special]

I'm still in D1. You shouldn't mess with DeLoreans. They get nasty when they overheat.


For game content:

No, robo, I was

not

suggesting you lynch yourself (or even vote yourself). That would be incredibly stupid, I think.

[Chronopie]

So... Umm...

Where do we go from here?