In post 1270, Shadowmod wrote:It was terrible - theoretically it cost you any chance to win...
First off - don't get me wrong, you can see in the Mafia QT the plan I thought should have been done - but I don't think the double claim was total fail.
It did force fitz's hand - and other than me and the dead QT after you announced it - no one was really pegging him as scum.
If we hadn't claimed than we might have had Sky as Seer clear DK and I and then would have had a three way choice with fitz/sage/DonJosh as the lynch possibilities.
You sure we would have pegged a wolf out of those three?
Also, I will admit my "revelation" about the Kingmaker in the Mafia QT was less of a revelation and more of a decision to gamble that I didn't need to lie to my scumbuddy. I was intentionally selling that we should go to Kingmaker so everyone could debate their choice - note that even after my 'revelation' my intended words from beyond the grave kept lying to town about it. I had mentioned it in thread and no one had called me on it, so I was gambling that people didn't know their wincons a bit
I am glad with sage's choice though - I do think of any of the factions mafia deserved to...lose least