Open 578: Fire and Ice Mafia [Game Over]

[tn5421]

CooLDoG,

Town Doctor

, was strung up and left to rot.

Luca Blight was killed shortly after.

Egg and Cheetory6,

Ice Mafia Goons

, have won the game.

House and Pine have been endgamed.

[Luca Blight]

Oh my God.

I knew Cheets was scum, at least I got that.

Egg...well I never.

[Cheetory6]

I am cry.
I love you Egg. You were all that I could hope for as a scummate.
GG firescum and town. I'll probably write a bunch of stuff when I have more free time tonight.
TN was a great mod. Would definitely be down to play this setup again.

Ice>Fire

Discuss

You were right.

[Cheetory6]

Oh, first and foremost, all the Luca stuff was entirely strategic on my part.
I thought he was more likely to be firescum than Victor, but he was never an actual strong scumread of mine.
Wanted flum off my case on D1 and firescum off my case on D3 after we both tried to shoot Luca.
On D5 I hardpushed him because I felt it'd be easier to fake incriminate people as my scummates/he might actually get lynched, so shrugs.
I was a bit of a dick this game and I'm kind of sorry about that, most of it was solely for the purpose of winning down the line and not getting nightkilled.

[tn5421]

All scum, in your PTs vote on whether or not you want your PTs released to the public. A unanimous vote is required for release.

[Luca Blight]

Town's downfall was Flum's replace out, making this slot instable, and CoolDog being inexplicably scummy on the last day - it really did make no sense.

Ice scum did well though, to be fair. Even Cheets looked Town until the last day, where he became pretty much obvscum to me, but I switched my vote because CoolDog's vote didn't make sense.

Ah well. Good game, guys - I enjoyed this one.

[Luca Blight]

*unstable

[Pine]

Pfft. Never had a chance to catch up. The Christmas season is hell on the healthcare system (full time) and retail (part time), plus family and other games

Oh well, it looks like Ice scum deserved this

[Cheetory6]

I hope it makes sense now, that I tunnelled as hard as I did in the last cycle because I knew it would make the counterwagons look like my scummates.
Even if things turned on me, it would eventually turn back on House/CoolDog in the short run and Egg would have had the game in the bag.

[Fluminator]

Good game Cheetory and Egg.
I still followed the game throughout when I could. Wake flipping scum was the biggest surprise for me mainly because it made me think House would have to be town.
I am very sorry about replacing out. I bit off more than I could chew at the time and I'll be more careful joining games in the future.

[Cheetory6]

Yoh Flum, why did you think I might be scum on D1?
Was really curious haha.

[CooLDoG]

I tried to play a bit scummy this game to avoid the nk... came back to haunt me. I got cheety and luca swaped. Early in the game luca budded me a bit too hard and that left me a little off with him. But I liked having a buddy early so I let it slide.

[Om of the Nom]

cooldog please dont play scummy ever again even after i found out you were town when i died i still would have gladly lynched you
luca's reads in the last day were half great the only issue im having with that is that if cheety was always the scum in his reads why did he always go after his potential partner??
house fucked up when he hammered caled despite townreading her due to scumreading me and he cut the day short and he cut everything short and that was bad bad bad bad, otherwise he was fine except maybe a little too paranoid
shea/tsq set himself up for a mislynch so easily by being useless and combative for no reason
cheety and egg played really well, congrats to them they deserve it

[Alchemist21]

Good game Cheetory and Egg.
I still followed the game throughout when I could. Wake flipping scum was the biggest surprise for me mainly because it made me think House would have to be town.
I am very sorry about replacing out. I bit off more than I could chew at the time and I'll be more careful joining games in the future.

I started spectating this game because I saw a post by you and thought you were scum.

Spoiler:

in b4 stalker accusations

[Luca Blight]

@Om - I was voting Cheets and would have happily lynched him at any point on the final day, but it was difficult to get support for it. I was very busy with work and stuff as well, and CoolDog looked like he had obvscumed with his vote on me then switch to House, so I thought that was a pretty safe bet.

@ CoolDog - I wasn't intentionally trying to buddy you, I just didn't think the early wagon on you was particularly justified, and if I hadn't defended you you probably would have been forced to claim on day 1. I couldn't get my head around your vote of me today though - it looked obvscum, particularly as it put me at L-1, with your reasoning being weak as anything.

[Cheetory6]

I'm gonna be a dick one last time:

I can read you like a book, Cheets.

c:

Was also really surprised that TSQ wasn't doctor. Him saying there was no way he was going to be lynched today felt like a softclaim. Probably would have hardpushed that if CoolDog hadn't been at L-1.

[tn5421]

This was me all game.

[Egg]

I'm gonna be a dick one last time:

I can read you like a book, Cheets.

c:

Was also really surprised that TSQ wasn't doctor. Him saying there was no way he was going to be lynched today felt like a softclaim. Probably would have hardpushed that if CoolDog hadn't been at L-1.

Lol you noticed that too? I was gonna say he was obv NK.

[tn5421]

Fire Scum: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 3#p6372623
Ice Scum: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 2#p6372622
Spectator\Dead: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=59854
Mod QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/JMuuf8vKaYbB

[Wake1]

GG, guys. Would be interested in playing again. Just don't NK me Night 1, alright?

[Cheetory6]

<3
Arguably I thought you and Victor would have outplayed us hard in a traditional mafia game in which scum couldn't be shot. Both of you were townreads for me when we killed you.

[Wake1]

If I weren't NK'd, I would have been a problem for the enemy.

Iirc, I wanted to shoot you, but I left it to Victor, who wanted Varsoon dead. I would've kept him alive because he Townread me, and he's fun to play with, too. You as well. Seems I should have made the decision Night 1, though it's doubtful that would have changed my fate that Night.

TN, thanks for running this game. Though my time here was brief... *COUGH,

darn you

, COUGH* ...I enjoyed it.

[tn5421]

Not a problem Wake.

[Om of the Nom]

man i am impulsive as heck but i am the very last person who would ever quickhammer because i get so paranoid about hammering

[Luca Blight]

CoolDog protected Cheets every night - lol.