Open 619: We're back in business (Game Over)

[Firebringer]

Hey FB

gonna do anything?

:3

Of course I am.
First going to ISO you.
Then Kelbris.

Its one of you two.
Bullet has proved he is town, which I am kind of shocked at tbh.

[Firebringer]

Malakittens ISO:

19 Standard RVS
24 I don’t think Mala knows who I was here lol. Null
27 Yep, Confirmed Mala didn’t know. Null
49 Prod dodge.
63 What you talking about? Null
76 Huh? Null
79 Bitching about mod and not scum hunting. Scum Lean.
129 Prod Dodge
222 Prod Dodge
223 Yes, you do seem disinterested. This is first time you have a read all game.
224 Null
225 How is “First” a breadcrumb to role? Also the apathy is horrible in this post.
231 3 town reads here, no reasons stated. No strong stances on these tbh. Null to Scum
234 Null
243 Okay this post is great. I don’t know why Mala claimed, but goes into played the setup other times. I don’t see how “first” was a breadcrumb to this though. Townish?
246 Alright….
249 AtE here, I still don’t get your crumb.
250 Wait did we really have to roleplay to get VCs? LOL, I didn’t notice at all. The Apathy is hard to read either way.
279 Null
280Why do you just unvote soren now? You read soren as town a dozen or so posts ago.
281 Weird posts are weird.
284 Talking about other games again, Null.
356 Votes Persivul with nothing to add to it. Unlikely bussing?
358 Null
361 How is this a town tell?
362 What? Cigs? Huh?
364This post looks bad in retrospect.
413 Okay now I am leaning on mala being scum and buddying Kelbris. Why does this disappear later?
420 Hmm, not sure about this.
424 Yeah GALE!!! Let him answer.
425 I like Mala.
426 Bad vote.
506 Hints at Bullet
507 Hinting at me. Then later drops me. Would love some reasons.
514 So lynching my slot because I haven’t been active or something?
515 In retrospect why were you going here?
552 No reasons again.
557 Wait for it….
558 Welcome to the party Mala
563 Why is your ISO filled with stuff like this?
565 You have been saying Kelbris is town for two days. How is he now pretty bad?
567 Meta tell, could be something could be easy excuse, not sure.
569 Good thing you claimed days ago, right?
574 Implying I am not going to?

Okay I am leaning towards Mala being scum, but I kind of want her to answer some questions I had during my ISO of her.'
Problem with Mala is most of her posts are null and you can't read anything from it. She gets better towards the end, but beginning not so much content.

I have yet to do ISO of Kelbris but will do ISO of him soon.

[kelbris]

I highly doubt that Mala is scum, like I said earlier scum would have no reason to want to bus day 1. ESPECIALLY since they know there is a chance that the Jailkeeper would be NKed or lynched, meaning it would be a waste to bus day 1 (speaking from past games, have NEVER from my memory seen scum bus day 1).

[BNL]

I'll wait for Firebringer to post his ISO on kelbris

[BNL]

Based on this game I'm reconsidering my read on Mala.

[Firebringer]

Can't get to game right now will try to post ISO tonight

[kelbris]

What about that game makes you change your mala read? Mala was not in the game that the link took me to.

[Malakittens]

Based on this game I'm reconsidering my read on Mala.

I wasn't in that game....?

[BNL]

1. Titus (scum) was townreading LQ for "playing very differently from his town game", and Mala also used a similar reason to townread Soren.

2. I townread Mala for her Soren unvote, I also townread Posite for her Pie unvote. (both were from RVS) Postie turned out to be scum, however.

[Firebringer]

1. Titus (scum) was townreading LQ for "playing very differently from his town game", and Mala also used a similar reason to townread Soren.

2. I townread Mala for her Soren unvote, I also townread Posite for her Pie unvote. (both were from RVS) Postie turned out to be scum, however.

I am not following this logic at all....

[Malakittens]

1. Titus (scum) was townreading LQ for "playing very differently from his town game", and Mala also used a similar reason to townread Soren.

2. I townread Mala for her Soren unvote, I also townread Posite for her Pie unvote. (both were from RVS) Postie turned out to be scum, however.

Titus and I might be close, but our games as both alignment varies a lot. I kinda tend to read players better after hydra'ing. IDK if that makes sense, but I saw Soren's scum-game first hand and it's different than here. In the scum-game he felt a lot more logical and a bit more engaged with the thread and here he didn;t have a forced feeling to his play as I was seeing there. It was more relaxed etc.

The sad part is your town, but the fact you're getting paranoid on me is kinda BS. Sorry, but if you vote me and I get hammered over Kelbris who had the most shitty hammer ever. I also want you to take a look at FB and his slot because that slot has also been not-so great either.

Granted I am aware I was a lurksack, but this just me being a lurksack. I play differently and what not and I hate being a VT because it just sucks so my play is terrible when I'm not a PR of some sort =\

[BNL]

1. Titus (scum) was townreading LQ for "playing very differently from his town game", and Mala also used a similar reason to townread Soren.

How did I mess that up? I mean LQ was playing very differently from his scum game.

[Jackal711]

Official VC

BulletNLynchproof (0) -
kelbris (0) -

Independent Synergy

Firebringer (2) - Malakittens, kelbris
Malakittens (0) -

Not Voting: BulletNLynchproof,

Independent Synergy

Firebringer

With 4 alive, it's 3 votes to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2016-01-10 20:15:00)

Happy New Year, everyone.

With no votes or unvotes since, this is still the current VC

[BNL]

Persivul, lane0168, Malakittens
Persivul, lane0168, kelbris
Persivul, lane0168, Independent Synergy

Hmm

Which looks most like the scumteam?

[BNL]

OK, Malakittens may be town as her play was *extremely* asynchronous with lane's and Persivul's play. They didn't even try pushing Soren while Mala voteparked there.

[kelbris]

I made a list of where we all stood during the various VCs throughout the game and my reads on each one. The first name is the player, second is where they had their vote. These VCs do not include the start of day ones where everyone is not voting.
VC 1
me: Willowmeadow
Mala: Soren
BNL: me
IS: lane0168
RVS phase, nothing much to say about these votes

VC2
IS: same as VC 1
me: Not_Mafia
BNL: Malakittens
Mala: Soren
IS sticks to his lane0168 vote, we were all voting for different people

VC3
Mala: same as VC2
me, IS and BNL: Mala
mala was only 2 votes away from being lynched, this is where she claimed VT, Albert and AI were also on the mala wagon and both were town

VC4 (end of day 1)
IS: lane0168
me, BNL and mala: persivul
Persivul made a post saying he was tired of how Mala was "lurking" at the time, this was because Mala was not invested in the game because of the "RP for VC" rule, which is why some of my posts seemed like they were done by a wizard or medieval individual. (Backup jailkeeper lynched, end of D1)

VC4
Mala and BNL: AlwaysInnocent
me: Albert
IS: not voting (as of this VC, AI was lynched and was VT)
nothing really telling here, sure Mala and BNL were on the AI wagon but they were just scumhunting as normal. Meanwhile I was sure Albert was scum because of his day 1 play and IS sat back and watched the whole thing go on.

VC5
mala: BNL
BNL, IS and myself: Soren (town vigilante got lynched, my stupid hammer based on Gale's read)
going over the posts from day 3 prior to my lynch of Soren, BNL said Soren was scum because he lynched AI on day 2, IS voted for Soren because "Wow, this game is in the bag.

Do I even need to catch up to the stuff I have been missing?
Looks like Soren is last scum.

Looking at his ISO its pretty null, and judging from everyone else and Gale analysis. Easy choice" and I voted for Soren because of Gale's readings and the fact that Soren seemed to be grasping at straws (to me before I realized all too late what Soren was referring to by IS's "scumslip" in the above message, that and Gale's reading.

VC6
mala and myself: IS
BNL and IS (now firebringer): not voting
the current VC. Not much to go on here.

[kelbris]

Well, on day 1 IS voteparked on lane0168 (for the whole day). I know I read him as town before, but what Soren said in response to my lnyching of him made me re-consider that. He is right when he said "what kind of town player does not read over the game." At the time I thought it was his "I am sure my PARTNER would agree" that Soren was referring to (2 scum left at that point), I realized only too late (after he revealed what he meant) that he was right. What kind of town player WOULD forgo reading through the game? A cocky one? Or SCUM.

[BNL]

Looking at the other teams, both kelbris and IS seem plausible as the last scum. I'm kinda leaning kelbris atm.

[Firebringer]

I am not done with Kelbris ISO but I doubt its him.

I still think its Malakittens.
Will finish Kelbris ISO todya.

[BNL]

Just as a word of warning, we are 2 votes away from lynching malakittens, so the next 2 voters have to be REALLY sure they want to lynch mala.

Yeah, we've played the game before, a simple "FYI mala's at L-2" would have been fine. This feels like scum trying to look townie.

Yes, that's exactly how it feels

Lane sheeps his partner. Idk if this is more likely to be done against town or scum.

[kelbris]

I ask you this, if I were scum, WHY would they sheep against me. The scum knows what PR (if any) each Scum member has, meaning they would not want to see one of their own lynched day 1, as that would prevent the scum from using said ability or at the very least meaning they are one member down, which in a game with 3 kills per day (assuming all 3 kills work), means they have a 1/3 chance of one of them being killed, sheeping a scum as a fellow scum would only improve town's chances of winning by reducing the amount of correct kills they need to make.

[Firebringer]

I think Mala is due for a prod by now mod.
And yeah, going to post this ISO tomorrow unfortunately. I am dead beat.

Also @Kelbris a soft bus probably.

[BNL]

Firebringer, we have 2 days left to deadline. I need it ASAP.

[Firebringer]

Firebringer, we have 2 days left to deadline. I need it ASAP.

Fine, Ill do it tonight. Give me a hour.

[Firebringer]

Kelbris ISO

17 Standard RVs. NUll
18 Fixing Vote. Null
29 Clarifications on something. Its Null
31 He says he is eager with this post? Or just that eagerness is Null.
36 Fixing Vote
41 I don’t know what my head was going on about with you being agreeable.
43 Confirms I am hydra, hunting for info. Could be either really.
47 Role playing for VC. Town.
48 Role playing
60 The role playing is old. Votes Willow, on weird reasons, the RP makes it hard to understand.
72 These role playing posts are odd in retrospect. Scummish?
84 Yeah just going to say that reasons might have been town but 72 before was scum feel.
85 Lol I am hoping this isn’t your whole ISO. Its hard to read. Scum.
97 how would this reveal role pms? Your posts seem motivated on scum, but they do so in such a weird fashion it could easily be fake cloud cuckoo stuff. I might be lost in this rp shit though.
99 Asking IaI why he is voting him. Survivalist or just trying to get inside his mind. Ehh Townish?
101 It’s hard to read though Kelbris!
118 Town contribution by making a VC
140 Prod Dodge
163 Says my reads are good, but not specifics. Null-lean scum.
178 Yeah…thank god.
179 Good reads list. He says Pers is town and Lane is Null. Hmm weird for his later vote. Scummish
202 Warns everyone about L-2. Town.
209 This interaction with lane makes me think they are not aligned actually. Town.
238 This role hunting is bad in retrospect. If you think someone is a power role you should keep it to yourself. Scummish but probably from Town.
248 Votes mala for earlier posts. Seems like just jumping on bandwagon though. Null
291 Points out L-2. Null
312 Welcomes player. Null
315 Sees Pers as town and unvotes. Yeah, weird interactions with Pers.
317 says won’t vote Pers at all. After analyzing the wagons.
324 This vote is odd. Not going to lie, you were reading Pers as town all day, then you don’t here.
331 has ‘reason’ what? I don’t know what to think of this. Null
344 Comments Pers is at L-1. Town
352 This is so scummy it has to be from Town. Ultra Town
354 Yep. Town.
401 Null.
409 At this point I have come to the conclusion that Kelbris is town. I don’t know if any posts will change my mind.

Ending my ISO early. I have come to conclusion that, Kelbris is town. Theres just too many posts of him doing too much scummy shit that means he can’t possibly be scum.
I am now 99% it is Mala.