Open 634: Sharing is Caring (Game Over)

[Persivul]

And speaking of BW...what was with that? The guy had some knowledge of the game. Just couldn't control himself.

[SirCakez]

Yeah Blacle's play was cringeworthy. Would have been amazing for scum if he wasn't a PR T-T

[Persivul]

I'm not sure that he would have played like that if he weren't a PR. He seemed to understand theory. If he had just chilled out a little he might have been a good player.

[drmyshottyizsik]

bussed so hard!

[Persivul]

Yeah you should put some tire tracks across that avatar.

[drmyshottyizsik]

good game town, cakez you tried

[SirCakez]

It got me really far Shotty :p
My experiments in bussing have not panned out well though

[drmyshottyizsik]

i mean right of the boat and under a bus

[Alexcellent]

Good game everyone!

Really thought scum had it in the bag with the massive bus, quicklynch on Wguerts and the horrible Blacle play. Cakez also played very, very well.
Kudos to Anen & Chilled, did an awesome job at the end there.

Really cool setup too
Thanks for modding davesaz!

[drmyshottyizsik]

I tried.so hard to set pers up as scum too!

[davesaz]

Official Vote Count

SirCakez

(3): Persivul, chilledtea, Aneninen

Persivul

(1): SirCakez

Not Voting

(0):

None.

With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

SirCakez,

Mafia Y-shot Rolecop

has been lynched day 5.

Persivul, chilledtea, and Aneninen, a trio of ordinary townfolk celebrated having rid their town of the mafia at last.

Town wins!

[davesaz]

Wow, balanced on the edge like that for so long!

[chilledtea]

Pretty happy about this.

[Persivul]

davesaz, can you open the dead thread? Thanks!

[SirCakez]

You can release scum chat, not much in there.

[davesaz]

Mod PT
Scum PT
Dead PT

[davesaz]

It was a pleasure modding, thanks for a pretty darn good game by all. Except for a bit of derp in the vig slot which almost cost the game.

Words to the wise, if you're unsure about a mechanic it's better to ask the mod than to argue about it. I decided to take the position of neutral observer unless specifically asked a question. Though "how many shots are left" would be off the table... I really liked the setup, must remember to thank the author! At first I thought mafia would have a huge advantage knowing how many shots, and that did come true to an extent, but town did have the ability to direct shots if the PRs listen.

[texcat]

I liked the setup too. Thanks for modding.

And well-played particularly at the end. I loved the "Argh" tell.

I copped ChilledTea, not because he was scummy, but because he replaced into the KainT slot which no one was able to get a read on. I don't think Chilled had even posted yet when I copped him. At least my crumb was pretty clear.

[texcat]

I'm not sure that he would have played like that if he weren't a PR. He seemed to understand theory. If he had just chilled out a little he might have been a good player.

I think you need to be a team player to be a good player. It sometimes feels like you are playing for yourself, but this is a team game.

[chilledtea]

KT's vote on you on day 1 was bad and I was not surprised you copped me.

[Alexcellent]

I'm not sure that he would have played like that if he weren't a PR. He seemed to understand theory. If he had just chilled out a little he might have been a good player.

He more or less threw a recent newbie game I was in with his poor PR play there too. It just seems to be his MO.

[chilledtea]

So did blacle not understand the mechanics? I just thought he was lying about shooting masq when he said he understands it better.

[Aneninen]

Awesome gameplay at MyLo from everyone!

ChilledTea examined the game enough to find the scum and to make me rethink everything.
Persivul was fighting incredibly hard and managed to turn the tide.
And SirCakez, you were great, too! Just check out the dead thread! Almost everyone said they'd never lynch you...

Thanks for modding, Davesaz!
This Setup seems to be both well-balanced and fun, it should join the well-known Open Setups as soon as it can.

[Persivul]

Obviously I'm not complaining about this game as town won, but I have a general question/comment on this from the dead thread:

@mod

: is the rolecop result announced in this thread?

No, because doing so would defeat one of the purposes of not having daytalk.

oh ok.

Sc, we need a coding system for your result.
Just add something in post that indicates wheter clumsy is a PR or not.

Simple as: use a particular word in a post if he has a PR and use a different word if he doesn't have a PR

just so I know wheter or not we can potentially push him as scum - ( if he's a PR, we need to town-read him)

Isn't the coding system also defeating the purposes of not having daytalk?

Some rules sets prohibit coded messages. This one doesn't - it just prohibits tricky use of text. But if it did prohibit coded messages, would this be a violation?

[Aneninen]

I think the biggest problem for scum was three easy mislynches (Tex, Blacle, Masq) all drew the PRs. So we were stuck killing players with, let's say, not the strongest of day play. Which left me stuck in LyLo with you three very strong town players and forced me to 1v1 Persivul which was brutal.

Indeed, you had to Nightkill players who'd have been useful mislynches at any phase.
Although I'd have never lynched TexCat, for example. I'd seen this kind of gameplay from her before this one and I was pretty sure she was town again.

We won....omg that was the hardest game ever and we won....

Definitely the hardest late-game as town ever, for me.
And indeed it was fun!

Yeah I know cakes. You played real well btw. More than the bussing it was the way you played - if it wasn't for anen playing really well as town, me getting cleared by cop and persivul trying his hardest on day 5 which he deserves the credit for, you would have won.

Yeah, the fact you'd been cleared earlier was greatly against the scumteam at MyLo.
It was lucky that I was able to conf-town myself, too.

And speaking of BW...what was with that? The guy had some knowledge of the game. Just couldn't control himself.

I don't know what sort of play he wanted to do...

Really thought scum had it in the bag with the massive bus, quicklynch on Wguerts and the horrible Blacle play.

Urgh. (Lololol!)
But seriously, I shouldn't have tunnelled Wgeurts.
Sorry again, Wgeurts, I indeed thought you were scum.
Now I've learnt even direct meta can be worth pigeon poop if it's not up-to-date at all.

At least my crumb was pretty clear.

Pretty clear.

I think you need to be a team player to be a good player. It sometimes feels like you are playing for yourself, but this is a team game.

Parrotting that!