Open 642 - The Woodshed - Game Over

[mhsmith0]

My guess is Panther-Titus or Panther-alpaca. Idk why but I don't think Panther-btd fits. Lol me if that's what it was and we came THAT close to a d3 turnaround tho *shrugs*

Ps my personal low point was a six-game losing streak across alignments. I also remain utterly baffled why my scum game (non-turbo) record is near .500 but my town game record (non-turbo) has been horrific. Some of the games have been bad luck, but I honestly think my town game is overall pretty decent so idk.

[Titus]

Considering those reads are pretty horrific, I can see why your record is the way it is.

[mhsmith0]

Considering those reads are pretty horrific, I can see why your record is the way it is.

Presuming ranger is town, your major pushes this game were her and me. If you're town this wasn't much of one to remember for you either.

[Titus]

Considering those reads are pretty horrific, I can see why your record is the way it is.

Presuming ranger is town, your major pushes this game were her and me. If you're town this wasn't much of one to remember for you either.

Yeah, I am not presuming that.

[mhsmith0]

You think ranger bothers to post this way post hammer as scum? I mean I guess it's possible but town fake-claiming scum post hammer (ala IV) I can see, while scum fake-claiming town in twilight achieves... what exactly? Like, why would she bother to do that and risk creating genuine-looking townreactions to what seems like a game over moment to the naked eye?

[BTD6_maker]

Panther has a lot to answer for. Unless he was just fed up with the No Lynches (I was, but I didn't want to hammer just yet after Mhsmith's posts) it seems very scummy. I think he is almost certainly the opposite alignment to Ranger. If Ranger flips Town we should lynch him if we survive the night.

As for Ranger claiming Town, I always do that myself as either alignment (I did in Whispers) so I find it NAI. Unless you have to tell your scum partner something important, there is no need to claim scum as scum.

PantherPunt-Titus is a possibility with PantherPunt bussing. Another possibility is PantherPunt-Mhsmith.

[Quaroath]

Vote count 4.lynch

Ranger – (5) titus, BTD6_maker, DrippingGoofball, AlpacaAlpaca, PantherPunt
Titus – (2) Xkfyu, Ranger

Not Voting - (8), mhsmith

Ranger has been lynch. He was a

tree

.
Night beings, and ends in 48 hours.

Sorry for the flip delay.

Flew from Portland, Oregon to Tampa, Florida and was in the air when I saw the lynch.

[Quaroath]

During the night, there was a bit of a thing
You see, someone forgot to put out the fire
And as Smokey says, only YOU can prevent Forest Fires!

During the night,

DrippingGoofBall

was burnt to a crisp after being ignited - they were the

Firefighter!

During the night,

AlpacaAlpaca

was burnt to a crisp after being ignited - they were a

Tree!

During the night,

Xkfyu

was burnt to a crisp after being ignited - they were a

Tree!

Those of you remaining gather around the ashes, and reflect on what was lost.

Panterpunt pulls out a cigarette and takes a slow draw...
"Well, he says, looks like this is the end..."
With that, he flicks the lit cigarette away...
and with a sudden *WHOOSH* flames ignite around the two reamining trees.

Titus

- incinerated in endgame - is dead - they were a

Tree.

mhsmith0

- incinerated in endgame - is dead - they were a

Tree.

BTD6_,maker and PantherPunt - Arsonists, win!

[mhsmith0]

Figured it was a loss there. Oh well I tried. Gg all.

Ps Panther, were you role fishing on dgb there? At the time I thought yes but literally everyone else was saying they had no clue on it.

[mhsmith0]

Also to mod for posting day start and giving me false hope. Also lol me for thinking not Panther/btd at the last minute.

[Quaroath]

This game was... interesting.

I have thoughts, but for now I'll leave the talking to the players.

Still on a business trip, so I won't be checkign thr thread often the next day or so.

This game was very frustrating to MOD though crazy replacment counts.

[Quaroath]

Also to mod for posting day start and giving me false hope. Also lol me for thinking not Panther/btd at the last minute.

[mhsmith0]

If you want to vote Ranger I can unvote and switch to Titus.

This is a flagrant "wolf or VI" claim given the context. Unfortunately vi was possible.

VOTE: Ranger

YOLO

This was the epitome of a gg hammer. To paraphrase benneh in star fox, Panther you were still wolfing after lol hammering in LYLO. Just start posting lolcats at that point like a decent human being

Ps sorry to ranger for being wrong on you. At least I can feel good about my m&m->xk read so I wasn't totally wrong on everything. Then again lol me for town reading kappys eod1. Panther felt plausibly wolfy but that read persisted. Alas. Definitely not one of my better town games.

[AlpacaAlpaca]

Well at least I tunnelled scum but not hard enough cause nobody lynched him rip though I was convinced panther was town

[mhsmith0]

Yeah sorry I should have stepped away from my ranger read to go to btd. Btd was basically scum-claiming all game but they kinda do that as town too (though not quite as blatantly) so they're super hard to read.

[mhsmith0]

Still, Panther played very well, solid congrats to him. Well done.

[BTD6_maker]

I guess in hindsight I seem scummier. It's obvious when you know who the scum are. I thought PantherPunt was very Town, though.

[innocentvillager]

holy shit I was completely off on Panther/Kappy. Nice job

[innocentvillager]

Can we see the QTs?

[mhsmith0]

Panther usually has more drive/aggression as town. He pinged me a bit, but in a game where town reads were insanely hard to find, I couldn't lynch everybody. Of course, it turned out that I couldn't lynch ANYBODY.

Wrt you, my case on you from the start was valid. Your IV hammer was basically a scum claim, and your play was more inward and defensive than your normal town game. I got sidetracked on ranger and her seemingly super-scummy day one and her seemingly bizarre town read on you and her unwillingness to explain it or really own it. I figured it was because she made the whole thing up. In retrospect I was wrong. And of course, once you have a raging scum read on someone, it's incredibly hard to see your way out of it. I maintain I tried... but clearly I didn't try hard enough.

[innocentvillager]

{BTD6, Kappy, Sickofit}

Let's lynch in here.

Wow beeboy's first readslist was spot fucking on (scumteam and a completely null no-posting slot)

Second readslist was worse

[mhsmith0]

Ok at this point we just need a lynch. I am pretty sure titus is town and I am also pretty sure BTD is scum but at least this will put an end to the Ranger debate
VOTE: Range

By the way in LYLO this was also a scum claim (just by a town).

[BTD6_maker]

Panther looked much more Town than me. Just in case Town survives, I thought it is better that I scum claim by hammering instead, hence trying to get you to vote Ranger. It was worth a try.

[mhsmith0]

Only if you thought I was an idiot though. I still don't get why town decided to quick-wagon in LYLO but idgi about a lot of stuff this game.

[Xkfyu]

I had this nagging feeling in the back of my head that I was being played by Panther, but I thought I was just being paranoid. Well played scum.