Open 646 - Semi Nightless - Game Over (D6)

[mhsmith0]

@giga: take a look at example #1 wrt what a scum slip actually can be (although amusingly in that example bk was a wolf making a solid d1 case on townie IH)

[Io]

Now I just gotta decide who gets HM I'm probably gonna give it to mhsmith here since he took an absolute shit on me, but Giga making the correct decision in the end was also pretty sweet along with his pouncing of karnosd d1.

The correct answer here is Io btw. She did probably the most work to get karnos lynched (really started the hard push on him), and every single person she cleared was actually a townie. If she'd lived, she might have won it sooner by PoE alone. Meanwhile everyone else had multiple wrong wagons they were on for various reasons. I did well D1 and redeemed myself D6, and had a very good D2 tbh, but my D3-D5 kinda sucked.

Maybe, but I would have pushed a smith lynch day 4.
After that it would have been between you and Tenshii for scum because everyone else was pretty good looking.
Though that last day I was thinking it was going to be Smith that was scum.

[mhsmith0]

Wow that's interesting. I thought I'd made it really obvious that it was trans, guess not. I take it from this comment there was no actual dead thread as well?

[Io]

Not that I knew of.

[mhsmith0]

Btw why did you think it was me? I'd been substantively engaging every reasonable point against me, and made a number of points trans basically was forced to dodge since he couldn't really answer them. What swung your read over that?

[Io]

Btw why did you think it was me? I'd been substantively engaging every reasonable point against me, and made a number of points trans basically was forced to dodge since he couldn't really answer them. What swung your read over that?

I was doing my own little night kill analysis and I just figured that me and Thor being killed were not anything indicative, but that you would have had more reason to kill iraonavp than Trans did due to them putting you higher than Trans on the scum reads. Plus it was clear that you and Trans were going to be the last 2 with either thor or giga with you.
I almost think it was a mistake to have killed iraonavp over Giga because I'm pretty sure they would have voted you over Trans in the end.

[Transcend]

;-;

I thought i had giga pocketed tho

[MariaR]

Welp! I suck

[gigabyteTroubadour]

;-;

I thought i had giga pocketed tho

the one time waffling helps town is when scum thinks they've pocketed a waffle

conventional wisdom says that you should never trust strong townreads that make it to lylo anyway. conventional wisdom can be wrong tho

[Transcend]

Even if i was town i doubt I'd be nked there

[Transcend]

Gave the HM to Giga as he started the game pouncing scum and then ended the game pouncing scum. I think I'm an incredibly hard scum to lynch sometimes combined with my death AtE and ability to towntell. Mhsmith and Io and Thor all did really well this game though.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

I'm flattered !!!

[Transcend]

YOU DESERVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[mhsmith0]

I have a new signature that's way less embarrassing WHOOOOOOOOOOO

My standard, btw, is it needs to come from a win. Part of my mini normal 1775 salt was I couldn't use the nice things said about me because lol town blew it after I died at night (having literally outed the last wolf w a clear case on her too)

[Transcend]

Honored to be in there.

[Luna Fox]

lol okay
Well thing is that when the mod posted that one night kill, the timestamp of that night kill was the same time stamp as Transcend's last login.

[Luna Fox]

Here's the reason i rep'd out btw:

[gigabyteTroubadour]

oh damn

i almost forgot to ask why :O

[Transcend]

Admirable i guess.

[Killthestory]

damn sad was lynched.

[mhsmith0]

A win is a win though

[Killthestory]

nah this is a loss

[gigabyteTroubadour]

nah this is a loss

transcend did a good job fooling all of us i think but it's the sheer number of mislynches that helped me realized i was on the wrong track with that read

so... you helped us win in a way

plus you got the first scum lynched, it probably could have been avoided if you didn't quickhammer

a win is a win

[Thor665]

plus you got the first scum lynched, it probably could have been avoided if you didn't quickhammer

I'm not sure about that - we were always going to peel off the les towny looking players, and I think KTS would have floated in that area regardless of the hammer. His lynch might have happened at a different time, but it probably was always going to happen.

[Transcend]

Fun game, met some fun people, played with some fun old people. Even if I'm fairly sure some people I met don't like me. I won't mention names. Not happy with the result, but who is ever happy about a loss?