Open 690: Kill All Townies - Game Over

[Gamma Emerald]

But apparently you weren't perturbed by my vote until i said you were so \_O_/

~T

Thinking SPD is town rn

[Gamma Emerald]

My post was joke analysis to a joke post haha

Balki seems to be taking this pressure quite defensively, which could either mean scum/ PR. I don't see him being vanilla. Personally I can't say either, as in the game I played with him, he was rarely questioned.

Seems like we're still in the gradual stages of switching from Joking random voting to proper discussion, so I'd like to see some opinions on some of the other people not being discussed heavily

VOTE: Kawso
This can die. You don't nonchalantly point out possible PRs like that. Last person to point one out in a game I was in (Alisae) was right and got the Doctor dead.

[Gamma Emerald]

Post 19 looks like Scum Kawso to me. Kawso expresses an over-eagerness to appear townie by taking an obvious joke post too seriously and responding with a townie-looking question:

Why is someone like Balki & someone like Flubber in different tiers, considering neither have posted?

This question screams:

"I read your post in full, I analyzed it, and I've observed an inconsistency! I am town!"

Kawso appears to be looking for opportunities to blend in.

Scum!

A much more natural town response, I'd wager, is this one:

What the fuck is this shit

Alright then
Tryhard
Probably Town tbh

dope. what makes this town tryhard and not scum tryhard??

1) the level of analysis
2) the fact he basically pulled what Kawso did: suggests not giving a f about that

[Tenshii]

I don't see any hypocrisy from Balki B considering that his push is based off of Kawso questioning inconsistency from a joke post. I think his push is genuine but I don't see it being AI atm.

[Tenshii]

Balki seems to be taking this pressure quite defensively, which could either mean scum/ PR. I don't see him being vanilla. Personally I can't say either, as in the game I played with him, he was rarely questioned.

Why did you say this?

[Balki B]

This can die. You don't nonchalantly point out possible PRs like that. Last person to point one out in a game I was in (Alisae) was right and got the Doctor dead.

Are you voting Kawso because you think he's bad town or because you think he's scum? Do you think scum would be so cavalier?

When Alisae pointed out a PR tell, was Alisae town or scum?

[Gamma Emerald]

This can die. You don't nonchalantly point out possible PRs like that. Last person to point one out in a game I was in (Alisae) was right and got the Doctor dead.

Are you voting Kawso because you think he's bad town or because you think he's scum? Do you think scum would be so cavalier?

When Alisae pointed out a PR tell, was Alisae town or scum?

Alisae just said "this guy is PR". He was Town, but was acting like hammered scum. For here, I feel Town would actually care about keeping PRs hidden.

[Siblings Pet Doggo]

hahaha that was ages ago and we don't talk about that game because MY GOD IS THAT EMBERASSING.
-Ali

[Gamma Emerald]

I mean that was the I became PROD KING

[podoboq]

Official Vote Count 1.04

Lynching

With 17 votes in play, it takes 9 to lynch.

Siblings Pet Doggo

(3): Kawso, EchoVision, Hawk

Bellaphant

(3): Sesq, DeltaW, Flubbernugget

Kawso

(3): Gamma Emerald, Balki B, MarioManiac4

Balki B

(2): Siblings Pet Doggo, GameNBurger

EchoVision

(1): havingfitz

beeboy

(1): Almost50

havingfitz

(1): Tenshii

GameNBurger

(1): Bellaphant

Nobody

(2): beeboy, CommKnight,

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-13 01:40:00)

[Sesq]

VOTE: Balki

this is scum

[Balki B]

This can die. You don't nonchalantly point out possible PRs like that. Last person to point one out in a game I was in (Alisae) was right and got the Doctor dead.

Are you voting Kawso because you think he's bad town or because you think he's scum? Do you think scum would be so cavalier?

When Alisae pointed out a PR tell, was Alisae town or scum?

Alisae just said "this guy is PR". He was Town, but was acting like hammered scum. For here, I feel Town would actually care about keeping PRs hidden.

Yeah, of course town must be more careful about PRs. But I'm not surprised Alisae was Town. Pretty odd that you use an example of something that bad town did as an example to prove your scum case.

I'm not surprised that Alisae was Town in your anecdote because it seems like the kind of thing that bad town would do as a mistake more frequently than bad scum would do as a mistake. It makes sense that Town is trying to sort PRs from VTs from scum, but you'd think bad scum would be more careful to avoid being explicit about that. I believe the only thing Kawso's PR comment revealed is that he is not being very careful.

UNVOTE: Kawso

[Balki B]

VOTE: Balki

this is scum

We really only have room for one tryhard.

[EchoVision]

VOTE: Balki

this is scum

How's fancy sock puppet dude scum? or is this still RVS vote

[EchoVision]

also just to clarify, I'm not using what I said before about Balki about his "hypocrisy" as scum indicative. tbh I'm slightly town leaning sock puppet cool guy but I'm being weary of my reads because people in this game are actually fucking good and im not

soooooo

[Sesq]

read

[CommKnight]

VOTE: GameNBurger - Because he's scum.

[DeltaW]

Post 19 looks like Scum Kawso to me. Kawso expresses an over-eagerness to appear townie by taking an obvious joke post too seriously and responding with a townie-looking question:

Why is someone like Balki & someone like Flubber in different tiers, considering neither have posted?

This question screams:

"I read your post in full, I analyzed it, and I've observed an inconsistency! I am town!"

Kawso appears to be looking for opportunities to blend in.

Scum!

A much more natural town response, I'd wager, is this one:

What the fuck is this shit

with this post aren't you doing the same exact thing that you accused Kawso of doing?

also I'm seeing a lot of familiar avatars! this is going to be wonderful

also what's scary about my avatar, have you never seen rick and Morty?

Cats are still fucking better

Thing is, if nobody makes a post like this we don't get anywhere.

[DeltaW]

If you're gonna put words in my mouth at least tell me what it is I truly believe, clarity goes a long way in conversation

Sure. It's quite clear:

If you wanna look town by making the first accusation, at least don't crumble as soon as someone half observes you making the move you're accusing someone else of making

Here's a protip next time you get anything non townie, or even if you do get townie, Less is more.

You have suggested, with much more certainty than SPD, that I am scum.

Ah I see, lovely you can detect my hint of dry sarcasm with those sentences to call me a condescending asshole, but cant seem to read the conclusion of my post, ya know, the most important part that states the point:

(3)Its not, if you're referring to question 2, and if you're not, it helps to use direct subjects in questions, not pronouns. Nice bait by the way,

I don't personally think Echo's claim holds water but I do think the fact that you seem to be in panic mode makes it worth the vote for pressure. I honestly cant say if you're 100% scum, but i think some pressure will help me decide in the end.

Thank you for atleast being clear with what you're saying, I'm gonna have a lot of fun having pull teeth everytime I want to know what you're saying.

Also, will you be playing the entire game as a condescending asshole? Is it some sort of role play?

Nah, I just happen to be a condescending asshole to everyone, or atleast I am when deciphering what you're trying to say takes so much time (with the exception of your post before you panic, could we get your posts to resemble that atleast?). Please be clear and direct when saying things, and I cant seriously remember the last time direct anger baiting (The calling me a condescending asshole bit so i'm clear) ever worked.

POST AUTHORSHIP Since you posted with a more thoughtful post since i started writing: Thats what i'm looking for as far as clarity goes, and to itterate more on why I think you were in panic mode: Shortfire posts, the lack of clarity, the primary use of ethos rather logos in arguments. I repeat this since i'm demanding a sense of quality from your posts, I might as well hold myself to the same standard.

Can you two stop this, separate arguments is anti-town, all I see is 2 fuckwits arguing over a point made several pages ago and escalating it so which ever of you is scum can use it as material for your wagon later.

[MarioManiac4]

VOTE: DeltaW

[EchoVision]

Delta, you said, "which ever of you is scum," implying that you find one of them to be scum. who of balki/gamenburger is scum/scummier?

[Flubbernugget]

VOTE: game and burger

feels super forced.

Nah

[Flubbernugget]

VOTE: Balki

this is scum

Nah

[Flubbernugget]

VOTE: Balki

this is scum

We really only have room for one tryhard.

Nah

[Flubbernugget]

VOTE: GameNBurger - Because he's scum.

Nah