Open 706: C9++

[CheekyTeeky]

Also wasn't Chip's replace out towny? I don't get why AC still wants to lynch that slot. I'd prefer a lynch in one of the better info scum reads like schism or Jodaxq. If I did have to compromise I'd go with EtA because his ISO sucks hard. I see noone is interested in Cy, and he's pretty low info anyway so I'm happy to leave that for now.

@AC why do you think you're alive today?

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Also wasn't Chip's replace out towny? I don't get why AC still wants to lynch that slot. I'd prefer a lynch in one of the better info scum reads like schism or Jodaxq. If I did have to compromise I'd go with EtA because his ISO sucks hard. I see noone is interested in Cy, and he's pretty low info anyway so I'm happy to leave that for now.

I dont look at replace outs as saying one way or another.

I'm loving the buddying here though from 2 people on the reads of one player

[CheekyTeeky]

Also wasn't Chip's replace out towny? I don't get why AC still wants to lynch that slot. I'd prefer a lynch in one of the better info scum reads like schism or Jodaxq. If I did have to compromise I'd go with EtA because his ISO sucks hard. I see noone is interested in Cy, and he's pretty low info anyway so I'm happy to leave that for now.

I dont look at replace outs as saying one way or another.

I'm loving the buddying here though from 2 people on the reads of one player

Beetlejuicing much? Nothing else you have to contribute? Are you going to push me or are you just shading?

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Also wasn't Chip's replace out towny? I don't get why AC still wants to lynch that slot. I'd prefer a lynch in one of the better info scum reads like schism or Jodaxq. If I did have to compromise I'd go with EtA because his ISO sucks hard. I see noone is interested in Cy, and he's pretty low info anyway so I'm happy to leave that for now.

I dont look at replace outs as saying one way or another.

I'm loving the buddying here though from 2 people on the reads of one player

Beetlejuicing much? Nothing else you have to contribute? Are you going to push me or are you just shading?

I have 5 tabs of MS open and its the weekend. I check into things. Not allowed to?

[Almost Chara]

@AC why do you think you're alive today?

because we were the obvious NK last night, so if there is a Doc in the setup they would have been on us. Scum would not want to shoot the IC on N1 as there are no other "obvious" targets for protectives.

Also, Chip's replace out is totaly NAI to me. I t was done because he has no time to play. Period. RL las nothing to do with alignments.

~A50

[CheekyTeeky]

@AC why do you think you're alive today?

because we were the obvious NK last night, so if there is a Doc in the setup they would have been on us. Scum would not want to shoot the IC on N1 as there are no other "obvious" targets for protectives.

Also, Chip's replace out is totaly NAI to me. I t was done because he has no time to play. Period. RL las nothing to do with alignments.

~A50

That's a good point. I found Chip calling Schism a moron on his exit towny as it felt like genuine frustration to me.

[Almost Chara]

Btw, I've just ISO'd NSG (not a long ISO anyway). She was killed by Mafia. She TR'd Schism (so that's one reason against him being Scum, unless you think NSG was shot by the VIG).

P.S. I already explained why I think fitz (the SK) shot Tone. It could be argued that he actually shot NSG as she heavily SR'd him, which would make Tone the Vig shot instead.

So, either Mafia shot NSG (points to Town!Schism) or SK shot her (doesn't mean much regarding Scism's alignment). Actually,

not a single kill

implicates Schism.

~A50

[CheekyTeeky]

Also wasn't Chip's replace out towny? I don't get why AC still wants to lynch that slot. I'd prefer a lynch in one of the better info scum reads like schism or Jodaxq. If I did have to compromise I'd go with EtA because his ISO sucks hard. I see noone is interested in Cy, and he's pretty low info anyway so I'm happy to leave that for now.

I dont look at replace outs as saying one way or another.

I'm loving the buddying here though from 2 people on the reads of one player

Beetlejuicing much? Nothing else you have to contribute? Are you going to push me or are you just shading?

I have 5 tabs of MS open and its the weekend. I check into things. Not allowed to?

Readslist please?

[davesaz]

OK I can follow that, but by the same logic, mafia killed NSG which means Jodaxq is not implicated in having killed Fitz.

[davesaz]

Does Elmo, Chip, and cytheflyguy make sense a a scumteam?

(Yeah, I

don't

hunt scumteams, but other people do and this is who my scumreads would be if Schism is taken off the list)

[CheekyTeeky]

I'm going to agree with Cy and Elmo.

VOTE: Elmo the AzN L-2.

[CheekyTeeky]

The problem with AC's clearing of schism via NKA is that it doesn't take into account NSG as a likely PR which would override a TR on scum imo. I'll admit I'm probably somewhat confirmation bias on NSG being obv PR post flip though.

[Jodaxq]

Prod dodge. Today is the day I get caught up. I am so sorry

[Sleepless Assassin]

I agree with Dave's town case on Jod.

3. The "result" from SA she claimed she got, wasn't related to her self vote. SA said her first "hello" post triggered a meta read which came up with the fact Jodaxq has yet to roll scum on MS. The statment wasn't related to the self vote and so is actually a misrep of reaction evaluation.

At the time, Jod believed that to be my reaction to the self vote. When reading Jod, you have to look at Jod's intent. The point is that she used that self vote to develop a read on myself and others. It reads as genuine scum hunting even if she was mistaken about my post.

Also wasn't Chip's replace out towny?

Nothing in his replace out looked to be related to alignment. How do you think it would have gone differently from Chip-scum?

[CheekyTeeky]

That's a good point. I found Chip calling Schism a moron on his exit towny as it felt like genuine frustration to me.

@SA - scum Chip wouldn't bother insulting people on his replace out. Also Scum Chip is quite indecisive and is vocal about not being able to obtain SRs on anyone. He was a bit waffly around the holidays but he certainly had a scum target. I'm not feeling scum Chip at all.

[CheekyTeeky]

At the time, Jod believed that to be my reaction to the self vote. When reading Jod, you have to look at Jod's intent. The point is that she used that self vote to develop a read on myself and others. It reads as genuine scum hunting even if she was mistaken about my post.

[momo]

OhGodMyLife replaces Chip Butty

[Sleepless Assassin]

Oh so it's a meta thing.

[CheekyTeeky]

Oh so it's a meta thing.

Yeah I guess it is. I could be wrong, Chip has pulled the wool over my head before but I don't think I am.

I don't know what to make of my read on Jodaxq, I'm losing confidence there. Hopefully some interactions with that slot will help me solidify an opinion. I'm willing to lynch Elmo as a compromise (how is that slot town?) but would most like to lynch schism today as I believe that slot is scum for aforementioned reasons and because it will give town a lot to work with. AC is very good at TRing people though so I say bring on an Elmo or Cy flip today instead...I would like to hear from the less active players to get this game moving.

[CheekyTeeky]

OhGodMyLife replaces Chip Butty

Also welcome! I look forward to hearing your thoughts.

[Sleepless Assassin]

Don't get me wrong, meta is fine. Just I've never played with chip so I don't expect to understand.

[Almost Chara]

Still keeping an eye on this game, but really have nothing to add to the table at this point. I'll wait for OhGodMyLife to say something, and for more interactions between various lots to see if I get any revelations.

P.S. REALLY missing Chara I'm never good when I'm even globally TR'd, so much less when I'm confirmed. I can't play any tricks and playing tricks is sometimes the best way to catch scum off guard.

~A50

[CheekyTeeky]

@cytheflyguy what are your thoughts on Elmo?

@Elmo TeH AzN what are your thoughts on cytheflyguy?

[Jodaxq]

Catching up now

[Jodaxq]

My problem with the case on Chip that schism made is that it neglects assembles meta. Most people have experienced a game with assemble at some point and it's pretty obvious he's consistently lurksack mislynch bait. It's not AI to assume assemble is going to flip town off of 4 posts.

Heres my problem with that. Its the information in the posts. Its why hes obvious bait.

You do realize you're the leading wagon for this exact same thing, right? What information have you provided for this game other than being the first to "oh there's a vig and they probably shot Fitz"