Mini Normal 2035 : Duck Mafia Part 1 : GAME OVER

[profii]

Nice quick turn around
Let’s start with the R V S
Here is my vote now

VOTE: popopopo

[profii]

hey guys enough RVS let's Lynch someone

What's the hurry?

Is it really duck's birthday? Happy birthday!

1 week deadline here
We must agree a lynch soon
I think we vote you

VOTE: nonny

[profii]

Reundo seems like town
Carcalilly also seems Town
We should look elsewhere

[profii]

Nonny is too quiet
He should come to the party
We should hear his side

[profii]

Still many lurkers
They should all speak up right now
Revealing nonnys side?

[profii]

Does anyone else think people jumped on that nonny wagon way too opportunistically

I do not think so
It was the first wagon today
Next up, the counter!

[profii]

Probably...

Nonny wagon at 4 wasn't bad at this point in the game, we kinda need some vote movement for analysis later.
From just quick glances, I think they were mostly independent reasons, though that's not saying much with so few posts in the game.

I disagree here
There was a lack of focus
Which drew the votes there

VOTE: Profii
Coasting in the form of bleating about activity while adding basically nothing to the discussion.

Pedit: Eh, if you're suggesting a NL it doesn't sound right to me.

Interesting vote
Given the above reason
You pick me for vote


Activity wrong!
Lack of urgency concern
But nonny cleared up

UNVOTE: nonny[/vote]

So why vote me here
Over other votes for same reasons
I am not a fan

[profii]

UNVOTE: nonny

Damn phone post error
I was not concentrating
Mod please spare my blush!

[profii]

Yes, I do think people jumped on nonny opportunistically, and funnily enough the two people that bother me were on Nonny.....

Think! Page 2 wagon
Not much to go on back then
Now things are clearer!

Nonny lacks urgency
We need to lynch quite quickly
his post count was fine.

Davesaz pushed on post count
I think this was small mis rep
but I could be wrong.

If Dave sees my point
I will not vote him right now
otherwise maybe I will

[profii]

hey guys enough RVS let's Lynch someone

What's the hurry?

Is it really duck's birthday? Happy birthday!

1 week deadline here
We must agree a lynch soon
I think we vote you

VOTE: nonny

My point: Short deadlines!
we must work quickly to lynch
otherwise, scum survive!

[profii]

Carca and Profii: you should be voting

Where should I vote

[profii]

sure, some of his logic seems a bit manufactured, lets see where this goes

VOTE: TiphaineDeath

[profii]

hang on

Gamma what do you think about Carcalily

[profii]

asked for vt peeps
and suggested a no lnych
followed 2 wagons with pretty naked votes

it seems pretty bad to me but idk 6 pages in

[profii]

VOTE: Profii
Coasting in the form of bleating about activity while adding basically nothing to the discussion.

Pedit: Eh, if you're suggesting a NL it doesn't sound right to me.

So this is wrong as I pointed out earlier

Acceptable response from reundo, gonna but him and lily in my bother them more later category VOTE: Profii

naked vote

Tchill, why did you vote me, I don't think you've explained?

Something just feels off about profli to me. He initially came out of the gate trying to direct the town into voting Nonny and constantly gave advice as to what the town should do, then he just started asking others where his vote should be placed. Also, 69 seems very odd to me as well.

VOTE: profli

Dave is my greatest townread at this moment, his playstyle this game seems to match up with his towngame.
I also have a favorable opinion of Reundo now, I've liked his logic and thought process so far.

”something just feels off” - right ok

At this point I’m not even sure if it would be beneficial to lynch anyone today?

What's the benefit to a NL? It'd be better to flip someone, just currently hard to pick who. But really don't get why you'd jump to NL. I'm sure you know the % of it being helpful.

Uh this is an odd question but is anyone a vanilla townie

Trying to shrink the possible PR pool? Who would actually answer this, like what was the plan with this?

Reundo seems like town
Carcalilly also seems Town
We should look elsewhere

Do you always post in haikus? Can you give a little more please. Where should we be looking for example?

Considering profii mentioned you in the post right after this I don't see what your concern is. You expressed concern over three players in your post -- why didn't you vote any of them?

Did not see a need to quote all three just to ask about the weird posting style. He mentioned me but that was it. Otherwise he didn't mention much at all. It was feigning activity so trying to flesh out why.
Posts 135, 140-143 is just off and weird. Not sure what to make of profii at this stage but so far don't like it.

VOTE: Profii

just off and weird





I’m the leading wagon because “something just isn’t right” basically


If that doesn’t scream to town that scum is within one of you lot then I don’t know what will

We lynch any of you 4 today, probably Dave as priority 4 but the rest of you are diabolical

[profii]

Tchill, why did you vote me, I don't think you've explained?

Something just feels off about profli to me. He initially came out of the gate trying to direct the town into voting Nonny and constantly gave advice as to what the town should do, then he just started asking others where his vote should be placed. Also, 69 seems very odd to me as well.

VOTE: profli

Dave is my greatest townread at this moment, his playstyle this game seems to match up with his towngame.
I also have a favorable opinion of Reundo now, I've liked his logic and thought process so far.

Ok I’ve looked back at what you’re saying and this is the reason I do a post shtick because I don’t expect people to assume the worst in my posts but I figured scum would

What you have called “directing the town” is what I would call a reminder that we have a 7 day deadline so given the early lack of activity we needed to resolve that otherwise we get to day 5 or so and start to panic wagon

I voted nonny on the principle that he said what’s the rush - this goes against my last point which was anti town - given the lack of activity by the time I placed the vote, that was the best move we had imo - it _was_ page 2 so we needed something to realistically transition people out of RVS and I think that achieved it.

Again - 69 - we still lacked activity - if more people got involved in the nonny wagon- even just to say “not voting here, I like him because _____” it moves the game out of RVS


So yeah, you are the way to go because as I’ve pointed out you’ve come to the wrong conclusion about me at every turn which can be a sign of Scum manufacturing a reason to vote town

That is especially likely to be the case when you have 3 votes rn and could do with a counter wagon


VOTE: Completely trustworthy

[profii]

I'm not telling lol

you're doing this on purpose lol

[profii]

Makes sense - I can’t be bothered to go through everything you said about me but seems like you are interpreting things in a logical / fair way

VOTE: Tiphaine/v]

[profii]

Doh

VOTE: Tiphaine

[profii]

As per prior vote when you said I should vote there I read the ISO and I felt some reasoning was manufactured, didnt get that vibe from Trustworthy

And I think my wagon coming out of nowhere was bad so I’ll go for one of those

[profii]

VOTE: ptofii

L-2. What you gonna do?

Not a lot

[profii]

I'm going to be pretty limited access through this weekend, which is unfortunate timing let's do this now. Profii Iso


Post#10 RVS Null

Post#39 Deadline pushing super early, making a vote on the guy whose crime is to not be worried about the deadline, slightly scummy here.

Post#67 Calling my other scum-reads town, null/townish? No particular objections.

Post#68/69 Lurker callouts, asking for Nonny's side. What side is Nonny supposed to have here? You are voting him for being chill about the deadline last I checked. Wat?

Post#111 Oh HELL yes was that wagon opportunistic, this is why I hate it, and everyone who was on it.

Post#112/113 The defending of the wagon and then the unvote on it, this is the sequencing that really wierded me out I think. Wagon comes under scrutiny, someone talks about vote analysis, suddenly off wagon.

Post#117 Random Dave Poking, never followed up one, BLEGH.

Post#120, harping on short deadlines. A week is plenty my man, you need to chill we STILL have 3 days.

Post#135 Tell me what to do Mr. Obv-Town, let me sit in your pocket!

Post#140 Oh look, I got told to vote the guy that doesn't like me, that seems good, sure, let's do that, yay pockets!

Post#141 Veeery distractible, look a lily! Kinda of townish actually tbh.

Post#143 lily-shade, unimpressive.

Post#153, self defense, reasonable, the wagon formed kinda wierd and quickly, but like, I felt what everyone else is feeling so I can't really talk. Making it real now though .

Post#154 VOTE THE BIGGEST COUNTERWAGON TO ME AND DROP THE SHTICK BECAUSE IT IS TIME TO GET SERIOUS CAUSE I MIGHT BE LYNCHED!

Post#160 more distracting-ness, feeling scummy now

Post#162/163 Omfg you are such a waffle, just jump on whoever is the most likely to get lynched who isn't you why don't you?

Post#167 attempting to explain the waffle, no sir, it is still a waffle, no matter how much syrup you put on it.

So yeah, profii should be todays lynch I may not be around past today, will try to check in more later today though, hope ya'll do the thing, Peace!

We had 7 days

We now have 3

2 of which are the weekend

This is not good.

Anyway

Wagons are good because people have to make a decision on if they want to push it through or not - if we just talk about people and don’t really push anything it let’s scum say what they like in a total non commital way

So I am absolutely going to move around quickly and be totally unapologetic for it

Saying “most likely to be lynched” is a really shady way of phrasing “getting it done” imo

My vote is in a good place rn

[profii]

@tchill, gonna want to know later what your motivation is for voting profii. I think my guess is probably right and it isn't urgent just yet. Won't bother me if you do answer now but it might defeat the purpose.

This approach is why I think I’m town reading carcalilly overall

[profii]

@tchill, gonna want to know later what your motivation is for voting profii. I think my guess is probably right and it isn't urgent just yet. Won't bother me if you do answer now but it might defeat the purpose.

This approach is why I think I’m town reading carcalilly overall

I think you're scum (for a lot more reason than you acknowledged) but there is a chance I'm wrong, in which case it would really help to understand your reads.
I'm not following you on this. I made a comment to tchill about a vote on you, and you quoted it but commented on Carcalilly.
The disconnect in this read isn't helpful at all. Does it mean you think tchill is scum?

There’s scum on my wagon and now I don’t know if it’s Tip or Dave

Tchill does have a chance as well but less so

[profii]

I like Nonny's explanation of why they made the "lynch happy" comment in 84 Reundo. I still don't feel that well about her though, especially with the follow up vote on Profii literally one post after I did with similar reasons to other people who voted him in 147. If I change my mind about Profii, I'll probably go back to voting her.

The reason I thought that Profii''s comments were weird is because he said there should be a counterwagon in 111, then didn't vote anyone until Gamma asked him to despite saying he found both Tiphaine and Carcallily suspicious in 140 and 143. He also said he would vote Davesaz if he didn't see his point in 117, but didn't despite Dave only continuing to push him in 125. I felt like he was appeasing Gamma by voting who he wanted, especially since he had not talked about Tiphiane at all before that post.


I don't agree with the people voting Carcallily, I've seen people do supposedly anti-town things before while ending up having a perfectly good reason to have behaved that way. I have a suspicion as to why she made those posts, but will not say what it is for now.

there should be CWs
As per what Tchill said - force people to take stances - in a scum game I got caught saying “oh I’d lynch my partner” all of day 1 but with no wagon I never had to do it

If there is momentum on people 3 things happen
-people vote
-people say they won’t vote
-people say they will vote and hesitate

If there is no wagon then you can say “oh yeh I’d vote ____ if a wagon starts” and just hope no one wagons


At the time when nonny was wagoned it was page 2 and this game has been relatively low content- picking someone for delaying game seemed the best idea


Not sure why you reference 140 - gamma said check Tiphaine, I did, I voted
143 was bait - I think I know what Lily is doing so I’m actually town reading there - note lack of voting!

In reference to Dave - I know he is a tough lynch so unless he does something really bad that a lot of people jump on him for then he is not a day 1 lynch - saying that, doesn’t mean we can’t probe him for later as per that post

[profii]

Who was it that say 7 days is plenty?

We have had 2x official vla and 1 person say they will struggle over the weekend

Let’s say you all push me to l-1 - I claim and we do the usual reset- how do we do that with 3 players missing?


So let’s just get a semi claim out the way to try and help - im not a VT, im novice and I’m x-shot (won’t say how many )

So my role could kick in n2 and be confirmable d3 - I appreciate that means I’m asking you to keep me around for 2 lynches but even if people says “scum claim” then fine let’s get my lynch dealt with now rather than with 3 people half missing

[profii]

L-1

[profii]

Did you know that Tchill?

[profii]

Why would not declaring l-1 be an issue my pedigree chum?

[profii]

That was a fun watch. Well done Una, another well played scum game from you

[profii]

I think you were at mylo in the last day? Was there any thought in your head to no lynch and motion detect una again? I think he would have no killed but then you keep doing it to force him ofc

Would that have even worked?