![Very Happy :D](./images/smilies/icon_biggrin.gif)
Who is Trendall?
In post 54, DkKoba wrote:wait andres i just realized u never got nommed for rising star for 2020. actually makes me sad.
Buddying noted.In post 81, Andresvmb wrote:Is it bad that I also thought that was funny? I don’t know what that says about me.In post 52, DkKoba wrote:i am 12 and this is funny
Do you think the wagon on Cook was powered by bad town or mafia?In post 340, geraintm wrote:all logic based wagons day 1 are bunkum, either powered by bad town or members of the mafia
In post 555, DkKoba wrote:did u conveniently miss where... I progressed into a townlean on cook? and voted Jim afterwards?In post 553, Facebones wrote:In case I didnt make it obvious enough: My interpretation is I think scum want to get out the only voice who was somewhat verbally opposed to their agenda of eliminating Cook
I noticed that. It was directly after Jim town read Cook in his list, before you were drunk.In post 564, DkKoba wrote:Did you also see where I shamelessly said "oh cool Jim is town"?
that was blatantly a false statement.
Agreed. This is what I was trying to get at in post 609. Make up your own mind on people instead of voting for players purely because someone else did. Show some independent thought, yo. Vote for who YOU think is suspicious, don't base it on what others think.In post 659, tris wrote:i'd like it better if you would vote where your heart leads.In post 620, Cook wrote:Justification: I'm sheeping because I trust DkKoba with two votes.
Also, yeah, this is my first Town forum game. First-game scum is a good experience but it means that anything you do as newbtown immediately looks suspicious since there's nothing else to compare you to.
Fortunately, I have a lot of time on my hands and a lot of patience for this so I'll keep playing and trying I guess.
In post 586, Flea The Magician wrote:Apparently there's no nightkills? kewl.
Flea, can you please explain these two contradictory statements?In post 738, Flea The Magician wrote:Scum wastes their kill if they come for me tonight, ngl xD
Is this the point you were referring to?In post 1192, tris wrote:oh, i forgot to mention this earlier. the fact that cook wouldn't vote for facebones even after my prompting even though he was his only expressed scumread at the time that wasn't just sheeping someone could be a scum indication.
They're more town leans than null tbh, but none of their posts really stood out to me like they did with the others. Why do you think they're both town?In post 1338, Egix96 wrote:Huh. I mean, I think that both of those slots are town, so I'm wondering if you have a balance of good/bad points for each of them, or if you just haven't been looking at them.
Where was it said that there's 3 scum total? I can't find it anywhere, but the way you worded that question makes it sound like you're sure there is only 2 scum left to eliminate.In post 1395, geraintm wrote:Just checking in before bed.
Awkward replacement.
But am I right in thinking people think dkkoba is scum, and me, whose only real opinion is dkkoba is not scum and planted that flag,we are the two remaining scum? In what universe would that play make any sense?
In post 1345, tris wrote:I don't know what you mean by this sentence. Why would you being his scumbuddy make his play more consistent?In post 1327, Facebones wrote:Is this the point you were referring to?In post 1192, tris wrote:oh, i forgot to mention this earlier. the fact that cook wouldn't vote for facebones even after my prompting even though he was his only expressed scumread at the time that wasn't just sheeping someone could be a scum indication.
If I was his scum buddy, surely he would've tried harder to make sure his play more consistent, especially on D1.
If he was trying to distance himself from me, surely he would've placed a vote on me, no?that's exactly my point. he didn't vote for you even though you were his only scumread.I think I was his main or only scum read? And he still didn't vote me, even after some gentle persuasion?If he had accepted his fate, that makes it more likely to be distancing does it not?These inconsistencies just make it seem like I was an afterthought when he had somewhat accepted his fate- one last ditch attempt to try and line up a mis-elimination.
That depends on if you've figured out it's potential relevance (or lack thereof) yet. I'm not going to tell you how you should construe something, yo.In post 1349, tris wrote:is it due time yet?In post 96, Facebones wrote:It was just something I found interesting. I'm sure we'll find out if it's relevant or not in due time.
In post 1350, tris wrote:At what point did you stop believing this?In post 553, Facebones wrote:In case I didnt make it obvious enough: My interpretation is I think scum want to get out the only voice who was somewhat verbally opposed to their agenda of eliminating Cook
In post 1467, RLotus wrote:Jim- I think he is very likely town because he had a sizable competing wagon to Cook mid day 1. Seems unlikely that town gets momentum on 2 different scum without the scum team diverting one of the wagons onto someone who is town.
Do you think Cook was the only mafia member trying to divert one of the wagons onto Jim?In post 512, MiniMegabyte wrote:Vote Count 1.8
Jim Hawkins (5): DkKoba, Cook, bugspray, Andresvmb, tris E-2
I kinda touched on this before in my 1339 but Jim hadn't said anything which stood out to me as obv!town like the top tier of my list.In post 1486, Andresvmb wrote:And how am I more Scummy than geraintm for example? And why is Jim null? It’s a completely absurd list.
Hmmm?
Andre and DkKobra's interactions seemed... weird. My guess is scum!Andre didn't want to elim town!DkKobra D1 because as he stated earlier, DkKobra is the only reason why Andre signed up for this game in the first place, and there was plenty of other viable options on D1. If Andre did vote with DkKobra for Essoa, and the wagon built and she flipped town, Andre knew there would absolutely be questions asked of him so from a scum!pov it would be best to not touch her with a 50 foot pole.In post 1467, RLotus wrote:andre- I already thought he was town for pressuring cook in day 1, but in hindsight knowing dk and essoa were town him playing peacemaker between them makes it hard to believe he is mafia.
Hypothetical: You join a game only because of person A. You roll scum, they roll town- would you want to vote for person A on D1 and have them eliminated for the rest of the game or would you prefer to keep them around for a bit longer and sheep their reads, in a very similar vein as one of your scum buddies (Cook) did?In post 1499, Egix96 wrote:Hardly relevant imo.In post 1498, Facebones wrote:My guess is scum!Andre didn't want to elim town!DkKobra D1 because as he stated earlier, DkKobra is the only reason why Andre signed up for this game in the first place
After swapping your votes from Cook to Essoa to Polaris to Jim before finally realising that bussing one of your scum buddies might be the best play to get the townie cred you need to further yourself and your faction in the game.In post 1504, Andresvmb wrote:In post 1498, Facebones wrote:Andre and DkKobra's interactions seemed... weird. My guess is scum!Andre didn't want to elim town!DkKobra D1 because as he stated earlier, DkKobra is the only reason why Andre signed up for this game in the first place, and there was plenty of other viable options on D1.So many options, in fact, that I landed on my Partner and advocated for that execution. Seems legit.
Is it outside the realms of possibility that when scum see 2 townies going at each others throats they'd have one egg them on and another try to calm them down?In post 1508, RLotus wrote:But, why would he interject instead of letting town fight and vote each other?In post 1498, Facebones wrote:If Andre did vote with DkKobra for Essoa, and the wagon built and she flipped town, Andre knew there would absolutely be questions asked of him so from a scum!pov it would be best to not touch her with a 50 foot pole.
In post 1530, geraintm wrote:if this is from town, then this and dkkoba's claim yesterday are just the dumbest things going. why would town do such stupid things??
In post 1536, Andresvmb wrote:If that involved either trying to pocket someone I like in the game, or hard pushing that same person, if the situation called for it, I would do it.
My read of Geraintm is getting townier by the day.In post 1545, Andresvmb wrote:If geraintm is Town in this game, and based on their analysis it’s totally possible that they are, thenyou’ll notice that {bugspray, RLotus} do in fact start to look a lot worse relative to you Facebones.So help me out here. Stop seeing me as Scum (I’m really not, in a demonstrable kind of way), and start focusing on other slots.
RLotus has picked up on the fact that I've been trying to solve and help town.In post 1636, geraintm wrote:Facebones- do you have any good reason why you shouldn't be eliminated today?
I'm not sure what the point of this timer was considering I was at E-2 at that point and bugspray was already on my wagon and therefore couldn't hammer.