Mini Normal 2232 -ENDGAME

[AliceK]

Hello everyone.
Let's have a nice game. ^^

[AliceK]

I’m Town.

That's what scum would say.

[AliceK]

Is that was RVS is supposed to do? Huh. Fair, then. I haven't noticed reactions to RVS-voting someone being important, but apparently, voting for myself can get a response too.

In theory, at least. Debatable how well it accomplishes that in practice. Does the response tell you anything?

yes, moderator, sorry typed too quickly. like, i know what an innocent child is but a day zero one i've not seen before. it is unusual enough that i wondered if the moderator was known for weird roles

viewtopic.php?f=2&t=83755
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=82764

Skimming through our moderator's topics, I found his last two Normal games had a d1 Innocent Child. Though I'm sceptical on how much value we get from discussing this in depth right now.

Hmm, I doubt you would do that to get towncred as scum. Either you would wait with this info few days or keep it for yourself. IMO it is valuable. Yeah you are Town.

[AliceK]

MargotRosa and ssbm are the scumiest from entries.

I doubt Jackson will come to play.

[AliceK]

MargotRosa and ssbm are the scumiest from entries.

I doubt Jackson will come to play.

What is scummy about Kyouko?

I think MargotRosa entry is awkward, repeating my joke could be a scum not having an idea how to enter the thread. And Kyouko could notice that as well and stack a vote, distancing herself early.

[AliceK]

Is that was RVS is supposed to do? Huh. Fair, then. I haven't noticed reactions to RVS-voting someone being important, but apparently, voting for myself can get a response too.

In theory, at least. Debatable how well it accomplishes that in practice. Does the response tell you anything?

yes, moderator, sorry typed too quickly. like, i know what an innocent child is but a day zero one i've not seen before. it is unusual enough that i wondered if the moderator was known for weird roles

viewtopic.php?f=2&t=83755
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=82764

Skimming through our moderator's topics, I found his last two Normal games had a d1 Innocent Child. Though I'm sceptical on how much value we get from discussing this in depth right now.

Hmm, I doubt you would do that to get towncred as scum. Either you would wait with this info few days or keep it for yourself. IMO it is valuable. Yeah you are Town.

This is also a bad post. Arbitrary townread here is bad juju.

Unless you have an argument based on his meta I will stick to my read.

[AliceK]

Alice why do you not think Nathann was distancing from Margo?

Not him, but you. Why you voted Margo?

[AliceK]

I kinda feel like Alice is TMIing her partner and that Jolyene's clue about scum shitting themselves implies jolyene knows something that jo thinks that scum also know, like maybe a special kind of traitor.

If that's the case I'd hazard a guess that "our mob" was not a typo but was in fact a traitor crumb and geraintm voting me is chainsawing for Margot

Another case cracked by bdsm_ultimate_detective

Interesting. I can't see the tmi. Can you elaborate on that?


Your take on geraintm make sense. However, I can't see why geraintm would do such a risky play. It could be easily missed or noticed by Town.

[AliceK]

I kinda feel like Alice is TMIing her partner and that Jolyene's clue about scum shitting themselves implies jolyene knows something that jo thinks that scum also know, like maybe a special kind of traitor.

If that's the case I'd hazard a guess that "our mob" was not a typo but was in fact a traitor crumb and geraintm voting me is chainsawing for Margot

Another case cracked by bdsm_ultimate_detective

Interesting. I can't see the tmi. Can you elaborate on that?


Your take on geraintm make sense. However, I can't see why geraintm would do such a risky play. It could be easily missed or noticed by Town.

The TMI:

MargotRosa and ssbm are the scumiest from entries.

I doubt Jackson will come to play.

What is scummy about Kyouko?

I think MargotRosa entry is awkward, repeating my joke could be a scum not having an idea how to enter the thread. And Kyouko could notice that as well and stack a vote, distancing herself early.

Margot didnt actually repeat your joke, so this feels like working backwards from Margot being scum. Saying I notice that as well and that I am distancing is setting me up to appear scummy on a scum!Margot flip and actually serves to distance you from Margot: why would Margot copy your joke if you were partners? Why would you point it out if you were partners?, these are questions town may ask themselves in the future

I think she did. The same quote, the same outcome.

Setting you up would be a longshot. ngl finding 2 scums on first few pages would be a nice achievement. I am not sure, you think I am bussing Margot to set you up? That wouldn't be a good strategy. I doubt I would do that. I think you should get to conclusion I am not svs with Margo and no one is setting you up. It's genuine read.

[AliceK]

Alice why do you not think Nathann was distancing from Margo?

Not him, but you. Why you voted Margo?

I understand you're saying you don't think Nathann is distancing. I'm asking

why

you think that, given that both of our votes showed a lack of reasoning.

I dont understand how you get to "Kyouko also noticed Margot copied my joke and stacked a vote on to distance", but you

don't

also get to "Nathann also noticed Margot copied my joke and stacked a vote on to distance"

These are our votes. What is it about me or Nathann that differentiates our Margot votes from one another?

VOTE: MargotRosa

VOTE: Kazyan

Why the self-vote?

Let me know what you eat for breakfast, as that will form the basis of my scumhunting.

What if I don't eat breakfast?

No need to thank me but I've found our first scum
VOTE: MargotRosa

Order. There is a good chance scum would sheep a vote of a player with the most decent entry especially on a scumbuddy.

[AliceK]

VOTE: alicek

My child, don't do this.

[AliceK]

Alicek's reaction to Kyo feels good so I'm inclined to call that t/t

Why so sure that's t/t and not s/t?

[AliceK]

Cause Kyo is posting town thought processes

Could be, there are flaws in her reasoning, but it doesn't mean much.

VOTE: JacksonVirgo

[AliceK]

@Alice, no comment on the last paragraph of my 74?

@geraintm, why are you voting Kyouko?

I actually didn't check that you played only a single game. I was expecting that someone played with you!scum and saw a similar behaviour. But well 1 game, forget about that.

Right now your contribution to the game screams Town. Not only based on the post I mentioned earlier.

[AliceK]

Everyone, shush about the IC bs. It's a normal game, ICs have set rules and it has absolutely exactly nothing to do with anything. It's a mod confirm not some fake news. I didn't expect to have to explain why fox news is a bad news source to people on this website ffs.

Alice, dwlee, geraintm are the three scum. We can pack it up.

ger is engaging in an inane conversation with no relevance but originally framed it as having relevance. Alice is trying to make friends and shoot for cred off it which is text book scum stuff. Dwlee is just being dumb, probably not actually scum, but best guess so far.

I think accusing 2 people from 1 post is not a good way to make friends. Which part in your opinion comes from scum text book?

[AliceK]

2 mafia means two things, either mafia is very strong

or town is very weak (almost to mountainous)

11:2 with ic and no other power roles is quite balanced.

[AliceK]

I have some time to catch up.

[AliceK]

Kazyan progression is quite random which I think comes from Town. Geraintm also gives good vibes. I will keep my vote where it is.

[AliceK]

Kazyan progression is quite random which I think comes from Town. Geraintm also gives good vibes. I will keep my vote where it is.

Ellaborate.

He voted me, did readlist where he put me higher than someone else. Someone pointed this out and he changed the vote. I think he wouldn't make that mistake as scum.

[AliceK]

btw bc we have 4 ML i can easily solve this game within d1.

also vig dont fucking shoot if you exist. If theres a compulsive role you claim that shit now

i agree 2 maf in 13p is probably easy and i guess a day 3 end with town victory. @ me in post game.

i see how it is a 2 player as well -- there is way less interactions than expected and the vibe of this normal feels differnt then how i played in another normal.

maf is just 2 strong prs. 2 goons / 1 shot / weak prs wouldnt make sense. for this game, i believe we get the most info on day 2 especially with ic outted on day 1.

pr should out any info by day 2 if they have any info that will help us progress the game. and i believe there will be another game mechanic changing thing that will occur on day 2 after night. some rebel type shit

2:11 vanilla is still mafia sided

[AliceK]

Currently my townreads are :
Dwlee, Kyouko, Andres


I have a couple names that are close to earning a spot on this list.

Dwlee? I actually think he is scum. Likely him and Enchant.

[AliceK]

Currently my townreads are :
Dwlee, Kyouko, Andres


I have a couple names that are close to earning a spot on this list.

Dwlee? I actually think he is scum. Likely him and Enchant.

Dwlee feels bland. Posting a lot, but it is not a strong content.

[AliceK]

I believe there is obviously mafia on my wagon.

If you needed to say who is it? Who would you pick and why?

[AliceK]

(If you're red-green colorblind, I'll provide a different version)

Green is a townread, pink and red are weak/strong sumreads, white is null, and Jolyne gets a special conftown green. All of the blank gray spaces are where I couldn't find an opinion. Alice and Nixie get question marks because Nixie is being replaced and Alice is not very present. GMo has his gamesolve filled in. Also, a lot of these reads are super out-of-date and should be updated in the context of GMo's gamesolve post.

Oh, a lot of question marks under my name. I will try to provide info once I catch up after weekend.

[AliceK]

Hmm, no joining Kazyan wagon. His early day reads were too chaotic to come from scum. If he can fake that I would be impressed. He is one of few people I would like to not lynch.
This is my suggestion:
VOTE: Dwlee99

[AliceK]

All scums are in this group imo:
<Titus, GrandpaMo, DrippingGoofball, Andresvmb, Dwlee99, Ythan, Enchant>
Im the least confident about GrandpaMo and Ythan, because I skipped a lot of pages due to lack of time during last 3 days and apparently they provided some AI content. I will catch up over the night.

[AliceK]

Hmm, no joining Kazyan wagon. His early day reads were too chaotic to come from scum. If he can fake that I would be impressed. He is one of few people I would like to not lynch.
This is my suggestion:
VOTE: Dwlee99

not eliminate. I forgot lynch is forbidden word