Mini Normal 2309 | Finished!

[Bellaphant]

VOTE: civil

People Mainly replace out due to....life.

Starfire and nurse might be town.

[Bellaphant]

Mainly vibes? Starfire is relaxed, enjoyed.the humour, random's response to civil is more thought out than I think scum would bother.

[Bellaphant]

Also, this isn't a player list I know well at all: I've played with greeting a few times, read a fair few of italionos games, maybe one of Starfire's and std is probably the player I know best.

[Bellaphant]

Eh, I'm a fairly gut ready person. What did you play recently, I might be wrong, linky?

[Bellaphant]

3p is just third party normally, like serial killer

[Bellaphant]

UNVOTE: civil

[Bellaphant]

The bazuf thing is weird because I'm explicitly not saying it's meta or knowledge, or referring to them: I'm doing the opposite in the literal next post, and the. The rebuff is I don't know them? Yes, that's the point: I clearly said I'm making a snap judgement based on vibes in the thread. Also, if I was scum why would I contradict myself in two posts?

[Bellaphant]

Indeed, the notion that you are allowed to have gut vibes on players you know but are not allowed to have gut vibes on players you don’t know is indeed very strange logic.

I actually don't understand this?

[Bellaphant]

Random catchu up thoughts since page 9:
I liked nearys'd read post. It is a bit vague but I'm also finding the game a little hard to parse, so it's a pass from me.

Agree much more with Bob than civil about scum hunting, but am tr-ing civil a lot more than Bob.

I re-read the greeting/civil convo three times and am not really sure what I'm missing? Obviously it can be faked, but tr-ign civil for newbie-ness isnt what people are doing anyway?


Happgs probably town. @pc, hii. I really enjoyed playing with you: can you throw some questions my way?

[Bellaphant]

My issue with bazuf and Bob was that they made their votes on me without engaging me and still haven't interacted with me, while being weirdly declarative about their votes.

Kkfc is confusing because I literally tr one post and sr the next.

[Bellaphant]

Bait for what? Do we have experience together? I feel picked on

[Bellaphant]

Tbf I mainly read you like kkfc, my read is flip floppy on you. I think there might be scum in you/bazuf and it's probs bazuf?

[Bellaphant]

What would it mean if people had? What does it mean that they haven't? I need more, babes

[Bellaphant]

I find it weird that you are using this many words and efforts to discuss someone who isn't here??

(That's shade btw)

[Bellaphant]

Me? I've already said I'm really on the fence with you. I could go through your iso and green and red them if that would help start a convo?

[Bellaphant]

Kkfc's first five posts are mainly about theory and game: it's fine.
6 is fine to start with, but the make it hurt is weird.
The follow up in 8 9 10 is poor, 11 is much better but why did it take four posts to get to a sensible answer (the fact that it's taken a dialogue suggests to me that 6 8 9 10 were poor for other people too)
12 isn't great, 13 is better
I disagree with a lot of 18 but can see the thought process
Happy with the std Sus
I still think the defense of a player who isn't here and isn't under that much pressure is weird. If they were a leading wagon, id be less weirded out
The first half of 25 looks really town and the second half feels like reaching for a conclusion you already know.
Why are the tr on me fine? I wasn't really aware anyone was apart from civil, and that's because I seen to just be agreeing with them a lot
You thinking I'm scum reading you isn't quite what I'm saying, though. I think it's more town that you are this jumpy, maybe. Even your paranoid about 'starting the convo ': I meant funneling it down to this.
I like the std vote.

I'm willing to think this is just me having issues with your communication style.

[Bellaphant]

I find greeting really hard to read but they are pretty good at susssing me when I'm scum.

[Bellaphant]

I've made up my mind about a few things. I'm willing to change starfire from scummy to town probably maybe depending on their posts. bob keeps telling me hu tao is town so I might maybe just move hu tao as well.

town

PC
Happy
civil ape
kkfc

lean town

RN
save dragons

null

yimm
bellaphant

lean scum

hu tao
starfire
greeting

scum

naerys
bob

VOTE: bob

Bob is way too low, greeting is maybe town, ST D is....sure a read, talk me through that one? And the Bob one, honestly

Did kkfc not respond to my walk through their iso? I'm sure I raised some talking points.

[Bellaphant]

Cool, I think we are saying the same thing about the civil/nearys convo: there was a misunderstanding. I think what you've said now is actually what you thought then and that's fine.

I think the bazuf thing bothered me because his push on me felt really bad, but as you said, he hasn't been back. I think activity is nai and it felt like you were implying it wasn't, but reading back that might be a me issue.

The shade thing was also kind of a joke: I'm sure someone had been talking about shade and I was just messing about.

My read on who? You? You are probably town from this chat. I could see std being scum really easily, I've identified them as town fairly quickly in other games. I think if there is scum pushing lhf it's those pushing hu, not std

[Bellaphant]

@std, I'm comparing to the pirate game where you got a ton of heat early on but I knew you were town, and a bit to team mafia (I just rechecked your iso there: your realist by post 800 and something has all the scum as null/scum reads and every tr is correct - good job) and I'm not getting that feeling here. Maybe give me something to work with: when I think 'what does std think of the game ' I can't get an answer.

Greeting might be town mainly because I don't see any bad faith/agenda pushing in their posts. I feel like they were genuinely trying to get understanding on both sides out of the 1v1 with civil.

[Bellaphant]

That's more like it

[Bellaphant]

VOTE: srarfire

[Bellaphant]

@civil, I'm honestly not following how I went from one of your strongest tr to scum? What did I miss?
Yimmy seems really town , I think pc comes off better from th civil interaction.