Mini 1368 (Game Over)

[Nobody Special]

Vote: Kublai Khan

Total OMGUS.

[Nobody Special]

You so funny.

[Nobody Special]

Nice catch, pecanpie. I'll wait for an answer before I vote.

[Nobody Special]

@NS: How do you feel about whats happened in the game so far?

I think a large amount of energy was wasted on geometry.


I'm not sheeping pecan, I arrived at this conclusion on my own.

Vote: Cherry Dog

I also think that FUT is newb!oblivious rather than newb!scum.

[Nobody Special]

Note to self: read from post 103.

Modem died at home. Hopefully connected tonight, maybe tomorrow. Will only be on once a day, briefly, until it's fixed.

[Nobody Special]

Hey guess what!!! I've got a working modem! Yay!!

My 5 votes for Nobody Special were meta-related. I've never been able to accurately read him because he heavily lurks as scum and town.

Well this is good to know, I'll have to meta him myself. I was thinking of voting him because he hasn't said shit. However I do find his last post strange:

@NS: How do you feel about whats happened in the game so far?

I think a large amount of energy was wasted on geometry.


I'm not sheeping pecan, I arrived at this conclusion on my own.

Vote: Cherry Dog

I also think that FUT is newb!oblivious rather than newb!scum.

Earlier he had said he thinks pecanpie made a good catch, but unless I've misunderstood pecanpie, he's saying that FUT seems suspicious because of coming to CD's defence.
Then his next post he just votes CD to put him at L-1 and says that FUT is just oblivious instead of scum.
@NS: Why the change from thinking FUT was suspicious to saying he wasn't and voting CD? And also, could you spend some more time posting your thoughts?
For now VOTE: Nobody Special
I'm also going to meta him to see if I can find anything different in his style of lurking.

FUTs posts between 63 and 98 just read as though he wasn't defending a buddy, but that he's adjusting to our site meta.

I hate people who just go with the flow.

Is going with the flow a town or a scum mindset?

Yes.

CD, what are your thoughts on Hellhound?

I also think NobodySpecial is very inactive and is not contributing to the game.

Do you think NS is scummy?

No, he is still null, didn't do anything terribly scummy. But his scummy traits are lurking and not contributing to the game. That deserves a lynch if we don't find anyone else that pops out and automatically says scum.

You've got it backwards. My former meta (in the process of currently changing, thanks) was Lurky McLurkerson as town and pretty active as scum. Now I'm cutting way down on number of simultaneous games and maintaining a good level of activity across the board.

Oops RVS is over.

Unvote

I also think NobodySpecial is very inactive and is not contributing to the game.

@NobodySpecial, what do you think about Cheery Dog, FUT, and hellhound, and which one of them are the most scummiest to you?

And I'm going to read through again, my V/LA sucks.

I don't really like the way you've given me a menu to choose from. Why not ask for my general reads, or ask for a full list? It's like scum to narrow down the focus of who they want the spotlight on.


Now that I have access at home, I'll be here a lot more than I have been.

[Nobody Special]

The scummiest on that wagon would be NS.

Honestly,

that question

made me really see the point of the wagon on him. Lurking is one thing but putting someone at L-1 for no real reason.

VOTE: Nobody Special

I know I can be a bit slow at times, and for that I apologize. But

which

question, specifically?

NS, who are your scumreads?

Lupo's #155 was a bit scummy but #162 is even more so. His reasoning and scumhunting has been lackluster thus far, and his hop on the NS wagon is sheepy and hasty. I agree with pecanpie that a Hellhound-Lupo team definitely makes sense.

My scumreads in roughly decreasing order now are Hellhound, Lupo, Cheery Dog, and Melmond. I had found FUT scummy but killerjester makes me have the slot as a town read for now.

I have to say, I find it a bit scummy when someone produces

four

scumreads on Day One. So, you'd be my top scumread right about now.

[Nobody Special]

unvote

Vote: triangle

I was rushed, and forgot to change my vote.

[Nobody Special]

I do think that having four (strong? perhaps I read too much into it) scumreads on Day One is scummy. It's overkill. Unnecessary.

[Nobody Special]

I don't do pairings on Day One.

And yes, many scum tend to do unnecessary things to try to make up for their lack of real scumhunting. Think about it.

[Nobody Special]

At the moment, yes.

[Nobody Special]

I've been changing since the discussion about me always self-hammering as scum. Probably about 3-4 months, and I honestly can't recall which game sparked the discussion.

I was then, I'd rather lynch triangle now.

[Nobody Special]

The scummiest on that wagon would be NS.

Honestly,

that question

made me really see the point of the wagon on him. Lurking is one thing but putting someone at L-1 for no real reason.

VOTE: Nobody Special

I know I can be a bit slow at times, and for that I apologize. But

which

question, specifically?

Still would like this answered.

[Nobody Special]

Hi.

[Nobody Special]

You're welcome.


(Essentially, I'm waiting for Hellhound's replacement to show up.)

[Nobody Special]

[Nobody Special]

Just waiting for CDBs input. Willing to hammer depending on that.

[Nobody Special]

Posting. Will catch up in he next half hour and post more.

[Nobody Special]

I find the lack of a night kill fascinating. Either we have a very good (lucky?) protection role or scum decided to no-kill for some strategic reason (which I truly will never understand).

Reading over Day One, no obvious doctor or jailkeeper person jumps out at me, so if they do exist, they're quite stealthy.

That said, I do agree that BBS is being either useless town or total scum. I'm leaning more toward scum at this point. I'm not really seeing the case on Lupo (well, I

see it,

I just don't really think it's as good as the BBS case). Anyway, if BBS flips scum, we can probably look in Lupo's detractors for BBS' partners.

(Also, I forgot this game had 2-week deadlines, sorry.)

[Nobody Special]

Piffle. I'm scumhunting. Just because you don't agree with my methods doesn't mean they don't work.

And it's time to add some pressure:

Vote: basketballstar

[Nobody Special]

Well, my "stupid post" about giving you pressure got you posting and interacting, didn't it?

Not so stupid, huh.

[Nobody Special]

I am pretty much convinced that BBS is scum, and yes, I'm tunneling. Not much else to say right now.

I will switch to Lupo if deadline looms and BBS isn't going to be lynched. Those are my two top suspects right now.

[Nobody Special]

I do not.

[Nobody Special]

And I'm pretty sure I explained why if you'd actually, you know,

read my posts.

[Nobody Special]

This post is to prove that I don't

only

show up when I'm mentioned.

So there.

[Nobody Special]

We really should lynch BBS. As I said, though, I could go for Lupo.

[Nobody Special]

You people. You should listen to reason, you know.

unvote

Vote: Lupo

That's L-1. Any scum on my wagon, feel free to jump over here and hammer.

[Nobody Special]

Please enlighten me. How have I been scummy?

[Nobody Special]

Will get to this over the weekend.

[Nobody Special]

This is a shameless prod dodge.

I opened the daystart PM and truthfully got distracted and forgot. I just woke up from a Surprise Nap so I'll be up all night and I promise some form of content within about 12 hours.

[Nobody Special]

I always seem to be run up as scummy. Yes, I've been busy and haven't gotten to this game lately, and for that, I'm sorry. I should be able to participate more frequently now.

Idiotking is just trying too hard. Most town, since they're confident of, you know,

beng town,

don't care much when cases are made against them, and instead focus on scumhunting of their own. IK is just spending all his time on defense.

Vote: Idiotking

[Nobody Special]

pecanpie, here you go. (Yes, I'll keep it up. Don't worry.)

Melmond, what would you like to hear?

[Nobody Special]

IK is spending a little

too

much effort in defending himself. Defending yourself

to a point

is fine, just don't over-do it.

[Nobody Special]

No, fuck him. My post is a better representation of IK's play. NS is just trying to sound like he's not sheeping my brilliance by saying something I haven't.

[Nobody Special]

basketballstar24: absolute scum. I could be wrong; he could just be new to this site, but gut tells me he's scum

pieceofpecanpie: Eh. Town? I suppose so.

I Am Innocent: null/town

Melmond: Townish

killerjester: null/town

triangle123: null-to-scum; mainly gut

Cheery Dog: I want him to be town. Really I do. Afraid he may not be, though.

Idiotking: obvscum

Kublai Khan: historically hard to read; let's just stick with null

[Nobody Special]

He's lying. I can feel it.

(obvscum and absolute scum are interchangeable, to me.)

[Nobody Special]

I'd honestly rather lynch triangle over IAI. (And IK over those two, but I seem to be in the minority.)

[Nobody Special]

Well, since my IK wagon has totally stalled,

unvote

Vote: I am Innocent

(which he likely isn't, IMO.)

[Nobody Special]

triangle seems scummier to me than IAI.

[Nobody Special]

But...

[Nobody Special]

Well, since my IK wagon has totally stalled,

unvote

Vote: I am Innocent

(which he likely isn't, IMO.)

OMGUS?

No. I honestly didn't even realize you were voting me (not that I expect you to believe me).

[Nobody Special]

Well, isn't this a fine kettle of fish.

I'd rather lynch CES (triangle), but KK is being scummier than he was earlier. For now,

unvote

Vote: Kublai Kahn

But I'd happily move to CES by deadline if need be. He's just barely participating.

Also, basketballstar is still scum. Why won't anyone believe me?

[Nobody Special]

I find the lack of a night kill fascinating. Either we have a very good (lucky?) protection role or scum decided to no-kill for some strategic reason (which I truly will never understand).

Reading over Day One, no obvious doctor or jailkeeper person jumps out at me, so if they do exist, they're quite stealthy.

That said, I do agree that BBS is being either useless town or total scum. I'm leaning more toward scum at this point. I'm not really seeing the case on Lupo (well, I

see it,

I just don't really think it's as good as the BBS case). Anyway, if BBS flips scum, we can probably look in Lupo's detractors for BBS' partners.

(Also, I forgot this game had 2-week deadlines, sorry.)

So, I guess it's time for me to claim. I'm

Town Roleblocker

and N1 I blocked Lupo. N2 I blocked triangle, N3 I blocked basketballstar.

[Nobody Special]

I suspected both Lupo and BBS (as well as triangle), it was almost an "eenie meenie miney moe" thing to choose between them.

My current top suspects are BBS and one of (pecanpie, Cherry Dog). BBS is far scummier than anyone else in this game, and the other two are quite a bit below that, but a bit scummier than everyone else.

[Nobody Special]

You're totally lying.

I just can't tell to what end, though. It's not like you couldn't have pushed a mislynch on me without going to such lengths.

[Nobody Special]

Vote: I Am Innocent

(which he totally isn't, just sayin)

[Nobody Special]

Oddly enough, I thought I was only 1-shot RB (one of many, many mistakes made this game). I know we discussed checking various people for guns in the QT; apparently those were never submitted.

I'm okay linking the QT if the others are.

[Nobody Special]

Oh. I forgot about the 'only one action' thing. That's pretty non-standard, right, ChaosOmega?