Alright, I'm down with a read wall. I like read walls.
Asterisks on the players who were in on GiF's lynch, since there was almost certainly scum there.
ArcAngel9*
169 Explains why Nunez's actions are scummy, and then asks peta to explain why Nunez was scummy. Why?
195 Looks town as smurf -- The Nunez and baboon RP'ing posts annoyed the trout out of me as well. I know her annoyance here is genuine because I share it.
295 Both of these reasons are trout; Replacing out because one is in too many games isn't that uncommon, and people pick the game they're least interested in to replace out of, and meta should be used only to reinforce an existing point, never stand alone
316"even if he is town, i doubt his alignment." What does this mean?
I'm not willing to lynch Arc today because I don't trust the flashmob that's building on her.
Belisarius
Dashing, erudite, and incredibly handsome
Bomberman*
51 It looks like Bomber has pranay as town in this post, but wants to lynch him anyways.
229 is question dodging -- Bomber's attack on Psyche's vote on Pacifist is a classic example of telling not showing, and here he's refusing to show.
306 and
337 are both promises of "content later" and little else.
459 A++ would read again. Post more like this.
Townpoints for calling for a readslist.
Demon*
-I don't care if Monty
was
joking, the fakery in the first 300 posts of the game is scummy as hell
346 NK analysis is WIFOM
353 What scumhunting? Jakes reads were gut.
356 "352 isn't talking about how you're being scummy" -- so you're fine with lynching town?
364 Contrived, I know, but "to be honest" is a bit of a red flag. It implies you haven't been honest previoustly.
418 Fluff, and not at prod timer; if you have nothing to say, why are you talking?
448 Speedlynching is bad
504 What scum read? The only times you've mentioned Arc before that vote was a reasonless listing of her in your scumlist back when you were pretending not to understand English and asking her for a read on rmp.
Goodbar*
124 So those reads are gut, yes? Why not say gut instead of refusing to explain? You don't like transparency?
MontyWhittaker
473 Why are so many people voting for bile over scumreads in this game?
501 No. Claims come with intent to hammer, and Nero was not even at L-1 at 501[/post]
Nero
427 Read the goddamn game
443 A game like this calls for tryharding.
Pacifist*
OK, chat mafia player; I usually don't expect much from chat mafia players, since day phases are too short to actually scumhunt in chat mafia, so they don't ever really learn how. Unless of course you call follow the cop scumhunting.
129 Oh yes you do.
Starting to run out of steam here; I'm going to have to stop doing reads in alphabetical order.
petapan*
Not willing to lynch peta today; I've seen too many people saying the equivalent of "lynch player x, not because I think they're scum but because I don't like them," and peta's been rude enough to pass for a Torontonian -- that tells me he sees himself as expendable, which scum don't. That may sound a bit WIFOM'ish, but the risk/benefit analysis of pissing people off is significantly more favourable to town than to scum.
454 Here's another player voting for Arc when the only time he's mentioned her was to call her pretty town. At this point, about the only thing that could possibly make me vote Arc would be if I were in lylo with her and Jesus Christ.
rmpeacoc
27 Voting for someone other than your top scumread doesn't make sense, L-2 or otherwise; town won't quickhammer and scum don't dare. Wanting to have a vote in play even when you don't know who to vote for is not town thinking.
76 Votes baboon for lurking, says what is syntactically equivalent to "If Goodbar has been lurking, at least he's been lurking." What?
SafetyDance
Not enough to go on yet, but intuitively, this feels like the same Safety I just finished a game with, and he was town there.
