Mini Normal 1874: Camping Trip Mafia (Game Over)

[Nadpool]

VOTE: Massive

[Nadpool]

[Nadpool]

All I need to know is that no townie should ever do something so stupid which means you are most likely scum.

Really? Do you really think no townie would troll day one and fake claim? I've seen both scum, and town fake claim on page 1. You say massive is scum because he voted for something that is NAI, but you are doing the same thing with Sick claiming mason day 1. Trolling page 1 ≠ Scum, just like not doing RVS ≠ scum.

VOTE: TwoFace

^^

VOTE: TwoFace

[Nadpool]

VOTE: TwoFace

[Nadpool]

VOTE: FaceTwo

[Nadpool]

VOTE: TaceFwo

[Nadpool]

VOTE: CowFate

[Nadpool]

VOTE: lucca

[Nadpool]

Town:
fykus
matt

scum:
???

UNVOTE:

[Nadpool]

Sickofit1138 (3): I Am Innocent, TwoFace, Soulmil07
mattblackguy (2): ssbm_Kyouko, Sickofit1138
lucca261 (1): Lil Uzi Vert
TwoFace (1): SensFan
shannon (1): massive

Fykus (1): lucca261

Nadpool (1): Fykus

Fykus (1): shannon

@Mod

???

Fixed, thanks for the heads-up - Leon

[Nadpool]

Offering something as to why you're voting for someone is alot better than just voting and saying nothing else at all for 10 pages wouldnt you agree? I assume you do agree in some sense because Nadpool is one of your scum reads. As to pointing out that I waited for a page before putting my vote onto twoface after i grilled him, I'm pretty sure that I offered an explanation already. For now though, I believe where my vote is currently is fine where it is until something else/someone else acting scummy pops up.

^town

[Nadpool]

The fact she's never seen it before but says it's scummy obviously raises red flags. The rest of those reasons sound good in theory but I don't think necessarily apply to this game since none of that really happened.

I still have issue not so much with the fake claim (yes people shouldn't lie in general unless they have to so I'll always have issues with that) but the bigger issue I have is sick basically scum reading somebody for knowing it wasn't a legit claim and voting him and him acting like the claim was legit. I don't see town casting shade like that. That's a scum manipulation move. It also means his original reason for claiming cause he was joking or whatever wasn't true cause you don't scum read somebody for reacting in a good way to a joke.

^^^

[Nadpool]

Figh-cuss, darkMatthew, dubface = townbloc

[Nadpool]

Meta/gut feeling but this is scum I think

Nadpool = Loopdan = TTTT

[Nadpool]

No my problem is you said a player was screaming scum (Player A). Then you vote a player who has offered nothing (Player B) without ever changing a read on the player screaming scum.

[Nadpool]

you keep trying to draw attention to him yet you don't ever directly interact with him to try and get him to participate more.

^^^

[Nadpool]

Fykus pops in throwing out accusations that Two Face's play screamed scum to him. (Yet doesn't vote TwoFace)
Fykus later votes TwoFace. When called out about this delay in voting, he said it was because he wanted to see how TwoFace reacted first. So one could deduce that TwoFace failed the reaction test, meaning he only screamed more scum to Fykus.
Fykus later votes Nadpool for "offering nothing". Nowhere between those quotes does he renounce his read of TwoFace.*

* Sorry, but if someone screamed scum to me, I would not move my vote to someone whose play was just "offering nothing" unless it was near deadline and it was to avoid a no lynch. I'd be pushing that read hard the whole day if he really screamed scum to me.

Then again, maybe the "scream scum" was only shade from someone who drew a red card this game...

^^

[Nadpool]

VOTE: Fykus

[Nadpool]

@dubface

Fykus (6): shannon, I Am Innocent, mattblackguy, ssbm_Kyouko, Nadpool, Sickofit1138

^ ^

[Nadpool]

UNVOTE:

[Nadpool]

I think it's bullshit

^^

It's ok to not believe a claim. The risk isn't worth the reward. If he's scum he's basically caught. If he's town we're helping mafia

^^

[Nadpool]

someone is fake claiming. anyway.

VOTE: Kyouko

[Nadpool]

Massive or Matt are both ok lynched today.

No.

[Nadpool]

Jesus. What is this game?

Just caught up on what I missed. Can someone quickly explain why you have a policy of not lynching any Scum on D1? Because that's the effect of not hammering any PR claims.

Not Voting (4): SensFan

[Nadpool]

I'm on page 9 and got lazy to read.

What should I do? I'll try to iso fykus

You don't? I see it as faux naive (use newbies gotta stick together), non-committal (sorry for the lack of a definitive idea, just took it at face value, maybe he could be scum), and vague. It gives me bad vibes, is all I can say.

So this I think were all that Fykus wagon started.

For me, I think he does really sound newbie. I've been newbie also regardless of my alignment, so I know how it feels to be scumread when you're being wishy-washy and inconsitent esp if you're newbie and trying to learn the game. He's not scum because he's a newbscum.

(Don't take this post as serious atm since I'm on page 9, it could change once I've read it all.)

Fun Fact: Massive's account was created when I was 4 months old. I was born March 1 2003

To people who thinks I'm ignoring 2F's case on sicko

, I'm not. I'll provide a summary about it later.

This post is accurate.

Getting town vibes from

this player

.

---

So, I think sicko is scum because of not answering the questions even if it's shitposting stage or w/e. Like, why not answer the question? He also did OMGUS 2F which made it even worse. I can see what 2F is pointing out.

VOTE: Sicko

VOTE COUNT 1.09

shannon (5): massive, lucca261, Soulmil07, Sickofit1138, Fykus
Fykus (4): shannon, I Am Innocent, mattblackguy, ssbm_Kyouko
Sickofit1138 (1): TwoFace
lucca261 (1): Lil Uzi Vert

Not Voting (2): Nadpool, SensFan

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.

Day 3 ends in (expired on 2017-02-09 16:49:02)

Marshmallow fun fact: The modern method of marshmallow production can be traced back to 1954, invented by Greek American confectioner Alex Doumak.

Yeah that is some real crap on the Shannon wagon. How about most of you on the Shannon wagon move over to Soulmil? I would feel better about Soulmil and Fykus as the top 2 wagons instead.

Continuing my reading,

Now that I've replaced this guy, what do you feel now about my slot?

VOTE: keyenpeydee

[Nadpool]

Massive or Matt are both ok lynched today.

These are terrible reads.

^

[Nadpool]

I think two scum are in {Fykus, Sick, and keyen}. Other scum I'd lean in your slot of SensFan at the moment.

I Am Innocent = town


@I Am Innocent

Code: Select all

[vote]keyen[/vote]

[Nadpool]

Townbloc

TwoFace
Matt
massive
IamI

[Nadpool]

Can you talk to me nadpool

I am.

[Nadpool]

He's at L-3 and already saying "congrats lynching a pr". Yeah that sounds fake to me

^^

VOTE: Keyen

[Nadpool]

I think it's a good idea to get claims from KNPD, and Sickofit as well. Both have hinted at PRs. This way, we'll have the information to figure out who's most likely lying out of these two and Fykus and assess the game. At this point with a claim and a couple more soft-claims, it benefits town more than scum to have clear information out in the open for scumhunting purposes.

[Nadpool]

[Nadpool]

Nadpool would like to hear Shannon and ssbm's current reads on each other.

[Nadpool]

@mod - replace me out please. Feeling overwhelmed lately and this is one of the shorter (page length) games I'm in, so it's easier reading for the replacement

Nadpool believes this is a town replace-out.

[Nadpool]

Nadpool would like to hear Shannon and ssbm's current reads on each other.

You suspect that they are partners?

Nadpool does not believe Shannon and ssbm are partners. Nadpool requested reads as they have shared games with a Nadpool alt and Nadpool believes it would help Nadpool sort their slots better.

[Nadpool]

It is Fykus or Sick D2. Nobody else. I want a claim from Sick, so all aboard...

Nadool tentatively agrees that it is Fykus or Sick D2.

VOTE: sick

[Nadpool]

Nadpool has no objections to this lynch.

[Nadpool]

Also, nadpool, what are your top 3 scum reads so far this game? What order do you believe we should lynch in order for town to win?

Nadpool believes everything depends on the way the sick lynch proceeds and how it flips.

[Nadpool]

Nadpool would like to point out that sick still hasn't voted Fykus.

[Nadpool]

Mattblackguy is curious how Nadpool's speech will evolve on day 3. Will Nadpool be speaking in eloquent essays?

Nadpool is unsure. Nadpool has yet to survive to day3. Nadpool looks forward to the opportunity to evolve into a more complex being.

[Nadpool]

@Jupiter, If sick flips scum Nadpool will highly suspect Sens. If sick flips town, Nadpool definitively wants a Fykus lynch.

[Nadpool]

Nadpool sees no reason why Fykus should still be alive.

VOTE: Fykus

Nadpool doesn't think a Jupiter claim is necessary until tomorrow.

[Nadpool]

Nadpool still has no problem with a Fykus lynch. Nadpool thinks some of you are too easily handing out town-reads when Fykus isn't flipped yet. Nadpool is saddened by his lack of evolution in play style today but looks forward to being alive tomorrow and advancing his play.

[Nadpool]

Nadpool would like to thank our mod for excellent work.

Nadpool loves games where town finds each other.

Nadpool has no regerts over lynching KNPD.

Nadpool is surprised that Nadpool was the NK.