First, his initial reads had him admitting that there were good points for Carcalilly-scum, but he was very hesitant to follow through on them. At the same token, he used my suspicion of her to throw shade on me... on top of making a very fluffy case full of essentially nothing based on your own case on me.
He backed down from me near immediately when I called him out on his case without addressing it.
He also had Tchill as his strongest townread and turned on him after anti-Tchill sentiment started gaining steam.