Mini 1705: Game Over

[BananaCucho]

This is the only thing me and Fire agree on lmao

[Firebringer]

I looked at other Normal games and when they had masons they also had 2 other Power roles.

Are you serious that all we had was masons and Neopolitian?

[Firebringer]

I can never get over how weak roles are on this site.
Neapolitian = Weak Role.
Masons = Weaker Role.

[BananaCucho]

Yep and 3 goons

[BananaCucho]

Omg here goes Fire again.

We had 3 goons. 100% balanced.

[BananaCucho]

You say you love VT but you don't

[Firebringer]

Omg here goes Fire again.

We had 3 goons. 100% balanced.

The game disagrees.
None of you got lynched.
It wasn't even 'close'

[Firebringer]

I am sorry, I get like this when I lose.
I do think this could have used 1 decent tpr to help more with balance.
Like a 1 shot cop or something.

[BananaCucho]

Omg here goes Fire again.

We had 3 goons. 100% balanced.

The game disagrees.
None of you got lynched.
It wasn't even 'close'

That has nothing to do with the roles but everything to do with town being unreasonable

We killed TheWorst for being reasonable. We eventually started keeping the most unreasonable players around even though you were all voting together for the longest time

Kling was the LYLO set up lynch for daaaaaays

[Not_Mafia]

VC 4.01

Bacde (0)-

duppin (0)-

Firebringer (0)-

SamX (0)-

BananaCucho (0)-

Klingoncelt (4)-

Firebringer, Gale Wing Srock, SamX, BananaCucho

LYNCHED

Gale Wing Srock (0)-

Not Voting (7)-

Bacde, duppin, Klingoncelt

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-18 20:00:00) - Sep 18th 19:00 GMT

[Not_Mafia]

Klingoncelt

has been

lynched

day 4

, she was

Spoiler: They were

Vanilla Townie

Firebringer

the

Vanilla Townie

and

bacde

and

duppin

the

Town Masons

have been endgamed

SamX

,

Gale Wing Srock

and

Banana Cucho

the

Mafia Goons

have won

Dead PT
Mafia PT
Mason PT

[/spoiler]

[St Constantine the Hermit]

What the fuck did I say about Gale being confirmed scum. I was also scumreading Cucho, but I don't know if I said that in game.

[Gale Wing Srock]

What the fuck did I say about Gale being confirmed scum. I was also scumreading Cucho, but I don't know if I said that in game.

How did you know that Constantine?

[Ether]

I can never get over how weak roles are on this site.
Neapolitian = Weak Role.
Masons = Weaker Role.

Give the town some credit!

Neapolitans, which are not rolecops, are one of the strongest roles on the whitelist, and they synergize with masons dangerously well to boot. The power roles in this game were on track to strangle the scum alive, and then apparently Salamence went and claimed rolecop and hammered himself, and nobody bothered to look up what neapolitans actually are when he flipped?

On Day 3, there were 9 players alive. Two of them were confirmed innocent due to being masons. Salamence had another confirmed innocent, as well as a more ambiguous result on scum. If he'd claimed and you'd believed it, nearly half the game would have suddenly been rendered unlynchable. (Although I think some towns wouldn't believe it due to thinking it was too

townsided

.) I didn't expect all three power roles to be alive coming into Day 3 in the first place, but they were, and this was town's game to lose.

[/reviewertangent]

Speaking of which, congratulations to the scum!

[Not_Mafia]

General cluelessness about normal games plagued the game, there was talk of jesters at one point, if town had slowed down in lylo and gotten their bearings, I think the game would have become more of a toss-up.

Modding wasn't up to my usual standards, I recently started a very hectic job, I hope you all enjoyed the game

[Gale Wing Srock]

General cluelessness about normal games plagued the game, there was talk of jesters at one point, if town had slowed down in lylo and gotten their bearings, I think the game would have become more of a toss-up.

Modding wasn't up to my usual standards, I recently started a very hectic job, I hope you all enjoyed the game

Yeah Not_Mafia, I enjoyed the game, thank you for modding. And thank you reviewers (I read up on Neapolitans, but still believed them to be Role Cops ). Didn't like it when I rolled scum, but learning the Pov of scums actually helped me in my games as town. It was a learning experience and I thank everyone for the game.

I was in half mind of whether to claim Watcher / Tracker or VT, but I didn't get the time to calculate all angles as a PR, so just lazily claimed VT in the end.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

How did you know that Constantine?

For someone who has been playing as long as I have, there are certain people who just cry out scum

I am surprised you made it past day 2, but I guess you had the other townies fooled.

[TheWorst]

Oh I guess I was three for three. Nice.

Well this was a shame. Dunno what else to say. Good job scum, I called it (on my second try), it was the nicest mafia of all time.
They even sent us dead people a saccharine as hell message to apologize.

I'll gingerly add this loss now, this sucks.

[Bacde]

Lmao GG

I didn't do so hot this game

Sorry Kling, I didn't vote you at the end cuz I knew something blitzy was going on

[duppin]

Good game.

Sorry Kling, I thought you were scum. I was trying to consider a world where you weren't, unfortunately you got hammered before that happened. I was considering voting on SamX instead, before if you were town, she was definitely mafia as Firebringer and Banana most likely weren't aligned based on day 1 and 2. If you were scum, she was also pretty much mafia based on her RNG vote. So she was definitely the smartest lynch.

Fire, please be more careful with your votes in lylo!

[duppin]

Eh, before = because*

[BananaCucho]

Oh I guess I was three for three. Nice.

Well this was a shame. Dunno what else to say. Good job scum, I called it (on my second try), it was the nicest mafia of all time.
They even sent us dead people a saccharine as hell message to apologize.

I'll gingerly add this loss now, this sucks.

<3

[BananaCucho]

[Firebringer]

I can never get over how weak roles are on this site.
Neapolitian = Weak Role.
Masons = Weaker Role.

Give the town some credit!

Neapolitans, which are not rolecops, are one of the strongest roles on the whitelist, and they synergize with masons dangerously well to boot. The power roles in this game were on track to strangle the scum alive, and then apparently Salamence went and claimed rolecop and hammered himself, and nobody bothered to look up what neapolitans actually are when he flipped?

On Day 3, there were 9 players alive. Two of them were confirmed innocent due to being masons. Salamence had another confirmed innocent, as well as a more ambiguous result on scum. If he'd claimed and you'd believed it, nearly half the game would have suddenly been rendered unlynchable. (Although I think some towns wouldn't believe it due to thinking it was too

townsided

.) I didn't expect all three power roles to be alive coming into Day 3 in the first place, but they were, and this was town's game to lose.

[/reviewertangent]

Speaking of which, congratulations to the scum!

You are right on Neapolitan I never bothered looking it up, I went like "what's that?" Then just went with I guess alt name for role cop?

Masons are never confirmed except by each other so that's so false it hurts.
Any scum team could claim masons. It is not a good role.

[Firebringer]

This could played a lot differently if we understood what a Neapolitan did and if masons revealed yesterday instead LYLO