In post 16, SilverWolf wrote:
OK, thanks zakk.
Also, Hi Karmic!!
I'll be busy most of the day today but will be around later in the day and also tomorrow after work to chat.
The reason I brought up doing both the rolecop and the kill is because I think I'm less likely to be targeted by a PR at this point in the game than you are.
I would like to read a few more things in the game and discuss it with you first before I take any actions.
Yeah, I fully approve of you doing the kill and the rolecop.
I
n post 18, SilverWolf wrote:
OK Karmic, in any game where I've had any success as scum, I've actively talked with my scum partners. I think that's important. We should talk. We only have so much time before deadline and I'm going to be working all day tomorrow as well.
I have read through the game and some individual ISO's and I'd like to break up the obtown bloc of Thor, Nacho, Garmr. Not only are they obvious town but clearly very skilled at the game as well. Thor practically confirmed himself as town with the Ciara push. As a side note, I'm pretty irritated that Ciara played the way she did and ended up getting up to L-1 and basically disappeared from the game entirely and refused to replace out. I think if she would of stuck around and defended herself or a replacement would of come in and been able to do so, the lynch could of been avoided. It was a tough situation for me replacing in to find you both wagoned. I do appreciate WW towning up this slot and when I read you, I would be townreading you if I was playing this game as town. That's pretty much what I do as scum. I treat my partners like I would any other player. If you do something scummy, I'll call you on it. If you look townie, I'll say so. I'll question you like anyone else. I'd expect you to do the same with me. Otherwise, you get those pesky associative tells if one of us flips.
Anyway, The RC/kill should be within these 3. I didn't see any obvious PR signs from anyone so instead I'm going to just go by play. There is a chance one of these three is protected but my take on that is, it's still worth it to try. I've gone back and forth between Thor or Nacho for the kill. I actually really want to play with these two and Garmr as well but I can't make decisions based on that. Thor and Garmr kind of butt heads so that might create some noise/distraction. Nacho will never be lynched. A Garmr kill might make you look bad and I like how he has my slot as one of his top 3. Garmr comes off as really, really confident. Like he knows he will not be lynched no matter what. My thought is either Nacho kill and Garmr RC or Nacho RC and Thor kill. This is where I was hoping to get your input because you've been playing this game since the beginning and might of seen something I did not.
I don't think Garmr is that obvs town, I feel like we can break him.
Also, sorry for my inactivity here. I'm absolutely on board with talking, I just haven't had a good time to reply to this yet.
I'm glad you're here, but man, Woody replacing out really screwed with my head. My plan was to bus him really hard, and hope that Nacho felt Woody was town. I wanted to really dissuade anyone from suspecting a Woody/Karmic scumteam.
Now, I'm not really sure if I got anywhere from that... you're sort of still Woody, but you also sort of aren't.
You've got a lot of good thought here, and I agree with it in general. Yeah, I need to learn to never type up those broad everyone-included townread lists. They never get me anywhere. I think I can back out of it by saying that I thought they were bad Day 1 lynches, not necessarily bad lynches. Which is exactly how I feel.
Yeah, IDK what Bella's deal is. Proddodge with a little extra, seems like. Same with Eventi and Dave. There are a lot of anemic players in this game, and I don't know how to handle anemic players.
I was a suggested night kill I didn't know how praised I was lol. Also newer scum always think they can lynch me and it tends to backfire on them so nah. If i was a cop I would of probably investigated eventi or dave and left you alone to push a lynch on you. Also lapping silverwolfs praise 
I tend to advocate daily as a good method myself, though that can easily adjust depending on the speed of the game, but at least anyone who complains about daily is being a bit of a ponce.
