Mini 1757 - Game Over

[Boonskiies]

Successful buddying.

[Alchemist21]

if we hadnt lynched bitten
things wouldve gone much better for us
as it was that was still a crappy path to victory

all main chances of scum win melted on day 4
due really to the circumstances the game was in
before bitten or i subbed in
and some minor pieces of luck

The NK gambit was a mistake. You should have just killed RC and let Madonna be clear.

Robster
Boon*
Zulfy*
Madonna*
Alchemist

Droog
Bitten

At that point you could have paired each of yourselves with an unconfirmed Townie while killing the confTown. At that point if you could have lynched both Robster and me, you could have won even with one of you getting lynched in the process.

[Alchemist21]

If it helps, I didn't suspect you at all until you were basically confirmed.

Also this.

[Boonskiies]

I had such a hard town read on Droog. Like...he was able to get me to consider else where at the end. Like wtf.

[droog]

The NK gambit was a mistake. You should have just killed RC and let Madonna be clear.

i thought about this

killing rc made no sense because that would clear 2
his target and boon's target

killing boon made some sense
only 1 clear that way
but i figured id have 2 night phases left
the odds that rc wouldnt target me in one was very low
and my only path to victory

a nk gambit was the best way
to train everyone that scum would nk
and the jk results couldnt be trusted

i just didnt think he'd push a non-madon lynch

[droog]

I had such a hard town read on Droog. Like...he was able to get me to consider else where at the end. Like wtf.

i wouldve pushed madonna more actually
but i needed to lynch you eventually
to win

and i couldnt come on the last day and say
convincingly
"oh yeah its boon all along dont lynch me the nobody"

[droog]

and even with the nk gambit
i couldve still avoided lynch today

so i think it was the correct move
i just had a very very narrow path

[Alchemist21]

Oh yeah, I forgot about Boon supposed to be clearing someone the same night. Even so a Boon kill would have been a better choice, you would have had to steer a lynch onto either me or Robster that day. Then even if one was jailed the other could kill RC, or just strongman the kill.

[droog]

i couldnt strongman
bittens died

i couldnt even push the idea
that maybe there was a ninja

i wouldve had a tugher sell
with there being a second strongman on scum

[droog]

Oh yeah, I forgot about Boon supposed to be clearing someone the same night. Even so a Boon kill would have been a better choice, you would have had to steer a lynch onto either me or Robster that day. Then even if one was jailed the other could kill RC, or just strongman the kill.

also
that nk didnt decrease the number of lynches i had to make
i figured that i wouldve had to lynch boon anyways

today is probably the closest i couldve come to that

[Alchemist21]

i couldnt strongman
bittens died

i couldnt even push the idea
that maybe there was a ninja

i wouldve had a tugher sell
with there being a second strongman on scum

My bad. I thought we lynched Town after the first no-kill night.

[droog]

hah i wish
with 2 scum alive beating jk is easy

[Alchemist21]

Why did you guys target Madonna in the first place?

[Boonskiies]

I had fun with it. Excited to see RC's rage fit in the dead thread.

[droog]

this was a tough game
i cant claim to have made perfect play

but i really think i played as best as i know how
and thought hard about making optimum decisions

perhaps there is still a path i couldve taken
to win
with all the information i had at the time
but it was always a low chance

[droog]

Why did you guys target Madonna in the first place?

early on the dwee wagon
that was how my analysis was shaping up

that was how i scumread zulfy and rc
i expected 1-2 lynches in that pool

analysis of the dwee wagon was how i got reads
without getting very scumread
if i was going to analyze it more so would have others

madonna's spot on that wagon was pretty damning for us

[droog]

I had fun with it. Excited to see RC's rage fit in the dead thread.

he didnt lynch me after claiming a scumread there
and he pushed 2 mislynches to 1 correct lynch
im pretty satisfied with that

[Alchemist21]

You played really well. If RC hadn't stopped the NK things might have played out a lot differently.

[droog]

Why did you guys target Madonna in the first place?

in fact
i wouldve killed madonna istead of cow
i wouldve kept bbt alive

if scum before me had killed a pr in the night
way different game

[droog]

You played really well. If RC hadn't stopped the NK things might have played out a lot differently.

thanks
we almost used strongman too
i thought about it and decided to hold it for night 4

really wouldve changed the game

[Boonskiies]

it was so annoying when BBT and cow died on the turns I targeted them.

[Alchemist21]

^Lol

[droog]

maybe i buddied boon too hard
i wanted rc to keep pushing the "rolecop" argument

you know as much as i rag on rc sometimes
normally when phases drag on scum has a better chance
when rc was alive longer phases gave town a clearer understanding
i think thats a high compliment

[BNL]

Bumpity

[BNL]

Bump