Mini 1769: Ice Cream Mafia - Game over!

[Ircher]

Hmmm... Well my game is in the normal queue. While I certainly would accept you, that may drive away other players, which as a first time mod... cannot really be having. You understand the dilemna pf letting you into my game, right? (I would only reject though if I got a ton of complaints)

Looking at the dead thread... We basically lost from the start... Oh well.

[KainTepes]

im not sure why people hate me??? i thought i played OK this game,,, do you think i was bad?

[Ircher]

No, you played fine. Experience will help and that's about it. That and not using caps all the time.

[KainTepes]

i will not use caps all the time then...!!

[Boonskiies]

Welp.

[Boonskiies]

Maybe I should just start modding again instead....haha.

[Aquanim]

Mafia chat will be released in 24 hours after the mafia members PM me any posts they wish removed from the chat.

Uh... yeah, there's gonna be some of those. There are a lot of flames from me. I'll take out the unreasonable ones.

Things I don't understand about this game:

- Why Kain was not lynched on any of the four days
- Why anybody scumread Keyser ever
- Why Titus did that whole Mason thing instead of just asking Guy to claim
- Why nobody thought to ask "if Thor was the last to claim and is scum, why did he claim anything"
- Why nobody believed Thor would investigate Slandaar... seemed like an obvious investigate from him, really
- Why TellTaleHeart claimed Jailkeeper
- The size of BBT's ego

[Ircher]

Kein wasn't lynched because Odd Cop + RB sounded balanced.

[Ircher]

I see TTH jailed me -- I want to know -- Was it cuz you thought I was scum or thought I was town?

[Boonskiies]

Kain buddied the hell out of me, haha.

I went into the dead thread guessing the scum team as BBT-Massive-Aqua.

[Boonskiies]

As to Massive: No kudos to you. You were your same lurktastic self and I am apalled that no one really questioned whether you were town the entire game.

to be fair, this is how he always is. He posts the same amount every time. He doesn't post at specific times. He's very consistent, and I don't think that's a bad thing. I've been scum with massive before, and I really enjoyed it. When I mod, I always invite him to the games I mod, and is one of the names I look for when looking at playerlists to /in at.

[Aquanim]

I was actually wondering if Boonskiies was a Voyeur who was hoping to match up the claimed PRs to the actions he saw.

[TellTaleHeart]

im not sure why people hate me??? i thought i played OK this game,,, do you think i was bad?

I don't hate you at all. Don't misconstrue my thinking you were scum as me hating you.

I thought you were thoroughly scummy from start to finish and it was terrible play on town's part for refusing to lynch you.

- Why TellTaleHeart claimed Jailkeeper

Because of Boon's claimed "result." His result implied the existence of a special outside the claimed ones of mine, Kain's, and Boon's. Four specials would call one of the other three into question and the one

most

questionable was Kain's. I thought I was making a one-for-one trade with Kain, but so much for that.
I didn't mean for the "jailkeeper" specific to come out right then and there. That was more a consequence of my heavy-handed crumb.

[TellTaleHeart]

Kein wasn't lynched because Odd Cop + RB sounded balanced.

That argument is overly simplistic and quite lazy.

[Aquanim]

As an addenum to #1931, I think I

do

understand why Titus was lynched, but there's a reason why there were literally no scum on that wagon.

Also, putting Titus to L-1 and the hammer were both not clever. The hammer more so.

[Aquanim]

EBWOP: literally no scum on the wagon, and literally no townies bar Titus herself off it.

[TellTaleHeart]

I see TTH jailed me -- I want to know -- Was it cuz you thought I was scum or thought I was town?

Jailkeeper is so hard.

It was because I thought you may be scum. I probably should have used it like a doc but I was terrified of stepping on a town special's action. I ended up doing exactly that anyway. >:\

[Boonskiies]

I wish i was online like 15 minutes before the titus hammer.

[massive]

As to Massive: No kudos to you. You were your same lurktastic self and I am apalled that no one really questioned whether you were town the entire game.

to be fair, this is how he always is. He posts the same amount every time. He doesn't post at specific times. He's very consistent, and I don't think that's a bad thing. I've been scum with massive before, and I really enjoyed it. When I mod, I always invite him to the games I mod, and is one of the names I look for when looking at playerlists to /in at.

If you asked me whether I would rather be 2-0 vs Ircher-town, or get kudos, I would pick 2-0 every time, by the way. And I love ya Boons.

[Aquanim]

I kind of expected the half-dozen replacements all into town slots to sink us.

[Ircher]

No, you did wiell in garnering the town's respect.

[Performer]

Mafia chat will be released in 24 hours after the mafia members PM me any posts they wish removed from the chat.

Uh... yeah, there's gonna be some of those. There are a lot of flames from me. I'll take out the unreasonable ones.

Things I don't understand about this game:

- Why Kain was not lynched on any of the four days
- Why anybody scumread Keyser ever
- Why Titus did that whole Mason thing instead of just asking Guy to claim
- Why nobody thought to ask "if Thor was the last to claim and is scum, why did he claim anything"
- Why nobody believed Thor would investigate Slandaar... seemed like an obvious investigate from him, really
- Why TellTaleHeart claimed Jailkeeper
- The size of BBT's ego

I agree with Aqua. Why was KT not lynched...I'm thinking people thought he was just rookie town throughout this game. As for why people scumread Keyser...I'm quite surprised at that one, as I was watching the game.

I am very shocked town lost this one...especially without any scum being caught .

I think Aquanim did a fantastic job , partly due to the daytalk mechanic in this game. I believe that without him , KT & massive wouldn't have won.

[Ircher]

I thought mafia thread was to be released in 24 hrs....

[Ircher]

As to Massive: No kudos to you. You were your same lurktastic self and I am apalled that no one really questioned whether you were town the entire game.

to be fair, this is how he always is. He posts the same amount every time. He doesn't post at specific times. He's very consistent, and I don't think that's a bad thing. I've been scum with massive before, and I really enjoyed it. When I mod, I always invite him to the games I mod, and is one of the names I look for when looking at playerlists to /in at.

If you asked me whether I would rather be 2-0 vs Ircher-town, or get kudos, I would pick 2-0 every time, by the way. And I love ya Boons.

I have had enough of lurkers & will prob. launch a crusade against you the next time we play.

[SirCakez]

Whoops, forgot.

Mafia Chat: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 7#p7694417
Setup Review: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=65080