Mini 1791: Mildly Dangerous Mafia [GAME OVER]

[RadiantCowbells]

Youre getting lynched tomorrow if apricity flips town. I will make sure that happens (really dont want you alive in lylo)

that's not what you said. I'm done with mafia for at least a while anyway, just drop it.

[Antihero]

loosely followed this

postie's idea behind the setup where a lot of importance is shifted to the night game is a pretty neat one. and one that i had before, in fact: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=84&t=33689

BUT

the setup probably could've been better balanced. massclaim was obviously optimal b/c it created two different lynch pools that would sink scum if the game went on long enough. it effectively made the game white flag. the fact that: 1) the scumteam was fragmented and 2) scum didn't have daytalk, kinda' cut scum off at the knees and didn't let them coordinate claims.

there was also the weak bg. in this case it didn't end up mattering since the titus/fourtrouble slot never ended up doing anything (which may have been a smart move here given town were ahead in the count most of the game) but anybody with at least semi-decent townreads drawing that role would've been game breaking. scum probably needed a 1-shot strongman or something to make it not optimal for them to claim on day 1.

the consequences were that it didn't leave scum with much room for error at all. it was either going to be a perfect scum sweep or a town curbstomp. so yeah... i probably didn't think things through as much as i should've in the review. my bad.

[Antihero]

Because of stuff her brother said about her meta.

I wanted to call bullshit right then and there and I ended up not doing so. But Anti knows more than anybody I get into sad sack mental funks sometimes.

It wasn't even AtE, I was feeling fussy about things in general that weren't related to this game and I was very much in a "fuck everything" mood when I wrote that. I really didn't mean anything beyond face value, I was just having my morning bitchfest before grabbing my coffee.

for the record, that tell is STILL fucking bulletproof thank you for proving me right

[Dwlee99]

Youre getting lynched tomorrow

if apricity flips town

. I will make sure that happens (really dont want you alive in lylo)

that's not what you said. I'm done with mafia for at least a while anyway, just drop it.

:I

[Performer]

Ah, a town win! Honestly I believe this could've ended up easily a scum win, if it weren't for the heavy setting up of protection targets. Anti has a point...I'd say balance in this game was questionable. Reminds me of the other game with multiple Trackers that I played in .

Huge thank you to folks who protected me.
Huge thanks to replacements zakk & Titus !

Town did great!

Scum team - I'm sorry that Exp & Tell, had to be scum . They seemed to highly dislike playing scum based on their behavior in this game, and who could blame them? I don't ever like being mafia scum...that's not to say it doesn't have its fun moments. Apr I'm not sure, I think she secretly enjoys it more than beig town.

[Performer]

Also , I'm open to feedback. If anyone has feedback for me, let me know!

[Marquis]

i probably didn't think things through as much as i should've in the review. my bad.

same here. should have thought through gamebreaking strategies a bit more.

[Antihero]

Ah, a town win! Honestly I believe this could've ended up easily a scum win, if it weren't for the heavy setting up of protection targets. Anti has a point...I'd say balance in this game was questionable. Reminds me of the other game with multiple Trackers that I played in .

camn's apartment was fucking balanced don't give me no lip

[Expedience]

You can release the scum pt

And you're right Performer, I don't like being scum. I feel kind of bad for not trying harder.

[Expedience]

I think the setup was meh, the only part that bothered me was that I couldn't kill the players I wanted 'cuz bodyguards and everyone was like "wow bellaphant what an odd kill" when the pool was limited. The town played well and cleared people during the day though, we did have a chance to win.

[Apricity]

Nah Performer, I do like them about the same. I didn't particularly enjoy being lonescum as I said in the dead PT...a lot of the fun in being scum, to me, comes from getting to plan with the whole team and being by myself was pretty lonely and stressful. I still tried obviously but aside from the RC push it was more of a token effort on my part after TTH died.

[Apricity]

Also , I'm open to feedback. If anyone has feedback for me, let me know!

My point about you focusing on NAI things holds true. The stuff about me saying when I am/will be absent, among other things, is something I do as both alignments and I would never lie about that.

[Postie]

Scum topic has been released. =]

[Apricity]

Also I missed that town could win without killing me if they got all the goons until it was too late, and that's pretty much the only reason I ended up bussing. Wouldn't have done that if I'd known.

[serrapaladin]

Redacted.

-- Postie

[serrapaladin]

Sorry - should really not try to copy across quotes on my phone - please delete.

[N]