They were a
_ _ _
It is now Day 6.
The day will end in
If it doesn't make sense, why is scum more likely to do it than town? Are you saying that scum is looking for a reason to make nonsensical plays and draw your attention?In post 2153, PenguinPower wrote:Always a great idea to throw down a vote in MyLo before discussion. Sara is totes scum.
Surely just typing that last sentence already made you realize how entirely based on WIFOM this line of thinking is. I.e. if scum really did believe that you thought that I was guaranteed scum if I lived until tomorrow, then of course they'd just let me live until tomorrow for the guaranteed win via my mislynch.PenguinPower wrote: I would, however, like to debate the idea of a no lynch today. 95% chance that means bji dies tonight, but it at least gets that 5% chance out of the way that he's been playing us all.
So what do you think changed after day 1? I notice this:In post 2157, karnos wrote:But I'm truly on the fence. It could be Saru, he was acting hella scummy on day 1.
Do you have an explanation for Saru's behavior post Thor's flip that fits this narrative?In post 388, karnos wrote:In the scenario where Saru is scum, and the Tracer/Thor slot is scum, this is scum!Thor telling Saru to back off because he is drawing too much attention to himself and he will be the next one lynched after I flip town.In post 387, Thor665 wrote: Your debate with Saru is becoming very much white noise to me. I do tend to agree with his stance, because you appear to be more emotionally worked up, and I think his point about suggesting his scum read on you is based on you beating him elsewhere is pretty plainly fabricated (feel free to explain how it's a valid issue if you can - it looks like flail to me).
Are you calling Saru scummy?
If not, can we drop the debate and/or simply focus on what he's calling you scummy over?
@Saru - same goes for you, let's just pretend you bested Karnos on all the piddly points, and narrow down those walls by about half, yeah?
I agree with this 100%.In post 2156, karnos wrote:Penguin has been playing the long con, waiting for this one game to play against his self-imposed meta.
Half serious here. I don't think meta arguments mean much when they are brought up by the person who they personally benefit.
In post 2155, PenguinPower wrote:Just FYI, since I'm responding to Saru today...Your comment on me defending Thor making me scum...I have never once, as scum, defended any of my partners. Ever. I have only ever hard bussed them, except for the one newbie I replaced in (karnos was town in that one). Still didn't defend my buddy, just didn't bus.
Feel free to meta me - which town should do if town doesn't want to lose.
In post 2161, PenguinPower wrote:Well, if you aren't going to, go ahead and lynch me so the game can be over. Please don't drag this day out.
Still think we should no lynch today.
lmfao this guy has zero arguments and is just hoping town starts doubting itself with his emotional crap. I've done that before as scum. Almost worked like a charm in my last scum game against rb.In post 2086, Saru wrote:No offense to bji, but I don't see Penguin necessarily being lynched tomorrow.Instead, I predict more flailing and emotional BS that will let him win it all.I would not be a happy camper. But hey, I would love to be wrong.
More like "I want to get bji out of the way because he's harder to convince than Karnos."In post 2153, PenguinPower wrote:I would, however, like to debate the idea of a no lynch today. 95% chance that means bji dies tonight, but it at least gets that 5% chance out of the way that he's been playing us all.
lololol keep it up. You're only proving my point for me. I love when scum freaks out when I nail them.In post 2164, PenguinPower wrote:100% confident Saru is scum now.
I'm done, and quite honestly nothing I say will make a difference at this point. karnos and bji can decide what to do.
Saru is blacklisted for me. Totally an not-fun game when this guy posts.
VOTE: Saru
I don't get this.In post 2164, PenguinPower wrote:100% confident Saru is scum now.
I'm done, and quite honestly nothing I say will make a difference at this point. karnos and bji can decide what to do.
Saru is blacklisted for me. Totally an not-fun game when this guy posts.
VOTE: Saru
Yeah, must be real nice when no one calls you out on your BS.In post 2168, PenguinPower wrote:Game was nice when he was lurking.
I don't know.In post 2159, bji wrote:
Do you have an explanation for Saru's behavior post Thor's flip that fits this narrative?
It's just so much resistance to a Thor lynch, including hard pushes to switch to the bji wagon, followed by a switch to voting me... because I hammered scum!Thor? I doesn't make a whole lot of sense from town.1269
This doesn't make sense if you were so strongly scumreading Thor. Why would he be able to convince you of anything (not too mention it didn't really look like he was pushing the wagon that hard)? You also didn't answer why scum!Thor would have potentially bussed scum!malp when he was one of the smallest wagons at the point he hopped on.
You're breaking my heart, karnos.
1289
Dude. Chill out. 14 hours left and Thor already said he wouldn't claim (unless you actually expressed some effort). I think we can give it a bit more time. Still, you're lynching a soft PR claim (same as FA btw).
1320
Can we please hop on the bji wagon now?
1324
Well, I'm certainly not lynching Thor. Strongest toweread claims PR...yeah. This bji wagon is awesome though. More people should join.
1338
Damn it, Thor. You always fool me.
VOTE: Thor
1474
VOTE: karnos
Breaking my heart.
When Thor flipped scum. Sorry I had a strong townread on Thor until the bad fake claim...he's one player that I really struggle with given our first game together, and my inability to play emotionlessly. That's also why I struggle - as town - in games with you given my lack of ability to play solely on logic. Even now, I'm not 100% confident that you aren't the last scum...just more confident in Saru.In post 2172, karnos wrote:Penguin: what happened to wanting to lynch bji? When did your read of him change?
This feels like more of that appeal to emotion stuff that I talked about before.In post 2164, PenguinPower wrote:100% confident Saru is scum now.
I'm done, and quite honestly nothing I say will make a difference at this point. karnos and bji can decide what to do.
Saru is blacklisted for me. Totally an not-fun game when this guy posts.
VOTE: Saru