Mini Normal 1843 - Endgame

[mhsmith0]

I read the dead thread and feel like i got trashed around quite a bit for no reason. I tried my best with the little experience i had, no reason to insult me or imply anything just because my claim wasnt optimal.

in fairness I'd say the insulting was more towards the villagers who just bought it with no real questioning; I didn't think you'd done a great job pulling off the fake claim, but since it worked, the proof is in the pudding i guess.

[Hoopla]

Well played mafia!

Was a mostly fun game with occasional patches of apathy for me. I thought BlackVoid played very well and Sotty left her scum partners in better positions when she died, which is always the goal if you have to die as scum. I think when you end up talking yourself into conspiracy theories like "well, all the evidence suggests he's town, but he's probably good enough to fake it" like I did with Raskol, you know they're a good player. Well done raskie!

I thought the setup was fine, and within the realm of balance (though I generally prefer something with a bit more variety). The fact that of the two other 3-mason setups, that there was an identical 3-masons/3-goons setup means Cloud never should have been cleared in LYLO just based on historical data (especially when he wasn't killed at night). In saying that, I think his claim was very good and suited the setup well, and we were perhaps all underselling his ability to make a claim suitable to this site's meta, which is a large reason why he was pseudo-cleared. So, I think Cloud deserves a bit of credit for that and having the cajones to claim in the way he did by risking getting himself hammered before he got to make his good fakeclaim.

[CloudKicker]

A lot of people dislike the "oh my god I'm so random you can't predict me so don't try" when it turns out you're scum. It's the sort of shit that works exactly once, because no one who plays with you here will ever let you get away with it again, and if that means mislynch so be it.

We will see, underestimated me there was the reason i didnt get lynched, not my good claim or that i was random

[Raskolnikov]

Rask is also obvtown, guess who's left.

VOTE: Rask

L-1

b-b-b-but why

[Raskolnikov]

I guess I deserve this for being wrong on hoopla, fitz, and cloud tho

s a l t

[TwoFace]

b-b-b-but why

He obviously wasn't taking this game seriously. That's why

[Raskolnikov]

"well, all the evidence suggests he's town, but he's probably good enough to fake it" like I did with Raskol, you know they're a good player. Well done raskie!

Nah not well done. My scum game is MEDIOCRE I have negative winrate and average scum winrate is like 60-70%
WHERE IS THE PARANOIA COMING FROM

HOW DID I GET KNOWN AS A "OOOH SCARY BETTER LYNCH FOR HIS SCUMGAME" WITHOUT ACTUAL SCUM WINS WTF

[Raskolnikov]

s a l t s a l t s a l t

[Raskolnikov]

good game well played scum

peace

I usually avoid postgame of losses

[BlackVoid]

Can we see the private scum topic?

[mhsmith0]

scum topic
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=68823

mason topic
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=68824

[Hoopla]

Nah not well done. My scum game is MEDIOCRE I have negative winrate and average scum winrate is like 60-70%
WHERE IS THE PARANOIA COMING FROM

HOW DID I GET KNOWN AS A "OOOH SCARY BETTER LYNCH FOR HIS SCUMGAME" WITHOUT ACTUAL SCUM WINS WTF

Well, I've never seen you until now, so all I really had to go on was the quality of your play in this game. Usually when someone is convincing and creative as town they make good scum players also. Noted for next time!

[GreyICE]

I'm impressed how BV made perfect sense in the mason QT and was scumreading actual scum. Then Lloyd and Harry show up and try to sell you on some townie. It explains why you read as so town but your reads were so unbelievably schizophrenic.

[I Am Innocent]

Funny how my reads got so much better after ur slot died and surprisingly flipped town. Don't be so bad in the future...

[GreyICE]

Grow up

[I Am Innocent]

If u can't take the heat stay out of the kitchen

[GreyICE]

Dude you made like 4 posts. That's always an excellent vig shot. The fact you got butthurt over that didn't make me scummy, it made you butthurt. Nice job losing the game.

[MariaR]

Let's all just be friends

[I Am Innocent]

Let's all just be friends

For sake of all the classy people that played in this game, I'll end my responses now, otherwise [redacted] will just keep posting crap that I'm actually starting to think he honestly believes in that warped head of his.

Friends tho...not likely.

[CloudKicker]

Angry sex solves everything

[Gamma Emerald]

<3<
KISMESIS BICHACHO

[Nexus]

To nominate this game and any players or mods in it, please see the Scummies nomination thread.