Mini Normal 1914 - Sunshine Mafia - Game Over

[mhsmith0]

Day 6 Vote Count 6.01

Nachomamma8 (1): Dunkerdoodles
Dunkerdoodles (1): Nachomamma8

Not Voting (1): I Am Innocent

With 3 alive, It takes 2 to reach a lynch.

Day 6 Ends (expired on 2017-08-02 21:00:00)

[I Am Innocent]

Okay Dunker's voting history doesn't help his case, but would scum Dunker take me to LyLo over Dany, who was pressing Nacho very hard day 5? I purposely stayed silent day 5 so scum wouldn't know where I was leaning.

Jordarrian was pretty scummy as pointed out by TwoFace. Mulch I felt was townie, but post teammate flips, I see his chainsawing of ingeel and he comes off much less rosy. Especially with hard pushes on Drag and Mario and softer pushes on TwoFace, myself, etc. Nacho, I stand by what I said earlier, this is not town Nacho.

If I'm wrong, props go to Mush who I had a strong early game town read on, and is prob driving this choice as much as the connections between mulch and flipped scum.

Vote Nacho

[Dunkerdoodles]

thats hammer yeah?

[I Am Innocent]

yeah, you won, good guy or bad?

[mhsmith0]

Day 6 Vote Count 6.Final

Nachomamma8 (2): Dunkerdoodles, I Am Innocent
Dunkerdoodles (1): Nachomamma8

With 3 alive, It takes 2 to reach a lynch.

Day 6 Ends (expired on 2017-08-02 21:00:00)

[mhsmith0]

A lynch has been achieved...



Nachomamma8 was a...

Spoiler: Flip

Vanilla Townie

A win condition has been achieved...

[mhsmith0]

The light and the sunshine are no more.

Twilight comes as the sun sets for the final time. No longer shall the light reign over the field.

And with the darkness... comes the knives. No men of good faith and good will were allowed to survive, as the evil inside the hearts of men finally consumed them all...

Congratulations to the MAFIA team of Vedith, Syndesis, and Dunkerdoodles!

[mhsmith0]

Mafia topic (released after 48 hours)

Dead topic
(I don't have mod access on dead thread rn)

Mod topic

[MarioManiac4]

Good game all!

[I Am Innocent]

Well this was a great end to a great MS day for me. Sorry all...

[Dunkerdoodles]

Gg, guys!
Pedit: I has a hunch you thought nacho was the last maf so I killed Dany instead. I could've easily been wrong though as I didn't play well at all but mush did which is why we won this game

[iDanyboy]

No worries man, I was going to do the same :/ . Good game.

[MarioManiac4]

If scum had paid more attention to Vedith's role, they could've won on D4, so a scum win is probably the best outcome. It was largely also inevitable for a while; too many townies were mislynchable. Of course, it's a shame that Nacho never got a chance to defend himself, because almost all of the points against him were based upon Mulch.
IAI may have hammered wrong today, but his D1 reads were very good, and he was arguably the MVP on D4, and especially D5, where he was the only one to vote scum without knowledge of my alignment, which was impressive. He deserves a lot of credit for that. And I probably would've done the same thing in his position.

[Vedith]

GG all.
Thanks for modding Frogger! \o/
Happy for Scum or to release.

[Mulch]

Just so you know I didn't replace out of choice. I'm not a dick that leaves a bad situation like that. And it definitely wasn't tactical

[Mulch]

Also I owe an apology to Mario

And GG scum!

[Nexus]

Dead thread is open.

[iDanyboy]

Any feedback?

[mhsmith0]

I'd probably say the game was essentially lost when town managed to lynch three of its own PRs. I forget how much was their claims not saving them and how much was bad setup spec, but obviously that's not a good thing, and I'd say basically a collective failure. No player specific feedback, I wasn't really reading all that closely.

[Syndesis]

so uh

this game was an experience.

props to all my partners for carrying me to my only scum win on this site!

[Syndesis]

well played to the rest of the town. it was fun playing with nacho again!

[Nachomamma8]

Unfortunate result, but probably shouldn't have ended any other way.
I would have liked a bit more time to argue my case - think that mush played pretty well overall but Dunker's scum motivation was fairly clear and obvious and the Vedith death night was something that happened from scum being silly and wasn't a night that I ever would have allowed to happen.

[mhsmith0]

reading and remembering role PMs is usually something I recommend

[Syndesis]

for some reason I had it in my head that Vedith + town death would make it look like Vedith suicided.....but Vedith dying almost always looks like a suicide anyway, so I don't know what I was thinking.

[Nexus]

To nominate this game and any players or mods in it, please see the Scummies nomination thread.