I'll do a page by page (page = 100 posts) recap and then find scum and lynch it maybe. I do understand the disappointment you guys have in me and the scumreads and the votes. but I have been pretty townie, you just have to understand I come from such a different community from this there might be some actual culture clash going on... like buddying accusations etc.
now let's start with this from whymafia right after he claims:
In post 6, WhyMafia wrote:Not sure if claiming miller this early was the correct play but YOLO
I find the phrasing here very townie with adding the 'YOLO' and all. I think scum would be a little stiff doing this kind of complicated FPS play.
Mulch immediately reacts with a hard town lean, which is understandable with their meta together...
I like
14 from Mulch. From the perspective of me being town, I'm not sure scum would ask town that as often as town asking someone they don't know the allignment.
19 from humaneatingmonkey is not how I'd expect scum to react to a miller claim + a town read on that miller claim, in any scenario where one, both or none of either Mulch or WM are scum.
20 is equally townie, especially his 'predictions'. This is a guy already thinking way too much and way too hard about the game.
21 from BBB is how I'd expect scum to react to someone pushing the WM miller claim if the miller claim is true. Because scum has TMI on WM and would know he is a villager hardclaiming. pushing that as scum can be very awkward, but pushing the people pushing the claim is easier.
Lots of NAI stuff from robbvna, humaneatingmonkey still hard thinking and very very townie. on
34robbvna is starting to actually look a little stiff, after asking why the miller claim is being townread and doing some mechanical posting. Wants to provide me with examples of miller claims done by scum, doesn't follow up with giving any. really wants to lynch WM harder than humaneatingmonkey, who seems to have a much more nuanced perspective in the whole thing. I'm starting to find this stuff a little uncharacteristic of town. let's see how that slot develops.
alright so 50 posts in I have WM and monkey very villagery, Mulch kinda villagery and robbvna maybe a little scummy. I'll stop commenting on monkey's posts because they're all very villagery.
post
55 from Mulch is actually a little >rand scum, like the type of post scum will make that he thinks will make him look villagery because throwing suspicion is effective, but comes off sounding a little too much to me. I will say people always think I'm pocketing every game I play because of how much I appreciate posting etc, but it's just me loving mafia and it's really NAI
62 and 63 are very townie of WM and how I'd expect a town miller to react to pressure here. It's not his fault he is miller, so he won't spend much time defending himself. instead, he is already reading into the pressure he is getting, already suspicious of robbvna's posting, and pointing out good stuff about robbvna posting that seems off already.
good to see my p1 reads were similar when reacting in real time, although now I'm a lot more suspicious of robbvna.
will click send and continue in the next post.