In post 1114, UC Voyager wrote:Last night, i decided to jail keep Rhah. as you can see, someone was still killed! This tells me that either he isn't mafia, or he is a non-killing role
I'm pretty sure the mafia get to choose who does the kill? Or is there something in the setup I missed
That is to say, I think you could have targeted him and someone else did the kill
True, but in most every game I have been scum in, the goon generally does the kill...so if he is scum, he is either mafia roleblocker or encryptor....I don't think mafia would risk their encryptor or RoleBlocker so it is safe to say that rhah is most likely not a goon....
But could still be Roleblocker or encryptor.
In the end, I don't want to take my chances....we can confirm he didn't do the kill....which makes the odds of him being scum a lot lower
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 11:33 am
by Rhah
VOTE: una
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 11:34 am
by UC Voyager
:lol
there isn't a cop...lol
there is a vanilla cop, but i will play
I got vanilla result from WaveMode
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 11:36 am
by UC Voyager
Hey... I love how one of the biggest suspects from yesterday totally goes off about the issues of my results.
"aw shit. They know Rhah has a good chance of being town. Lets make a case that he could still be scum
I still think Una, and Necro are scum.....
Hey rhah. Lets vote Necro......Seems like a good choice......we could also try Porkens crazy list based on my role...
there isn't a cop...lol
there is a vanilla cop, but i will play
I got vanilla result from WaveMode
Lol UCV - anyone who comes up as not vanilla who is not you, is mafia.
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 11:51 am
by Morality
I’ll play.
Vanilla on Zulfy.
VOTE: Vanders
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 11:56 am
by CheekyTeeky
What's the case on Vanders?
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 11:58 am
by Morality
In post 869, Morality wrote:I’m weary of a wagon flipping over to Chip suddenly if Una wagon doesn’t go further. If that starts to happen, please don’t push it further. Don’t need two claims here.
VOTE: Vander
In post 871, Morality wrote:Vander is playing in a way where he’s staying out of the direct wagons, but in a way where it will allow him to jump on either if he needs to, especially this close to deadline. Tomorrow, I can see ScumVander completely taking over and being able to push through another mislynch.
In post 871, Morality wrote:Vander is playing in a way where he’s staying out of the direct wagons, but in a way where it will allow him to jump on either if he needs to, especially this close to deadline. Tomorrow, I can see ScumVander completely taking over and being able to push through another mislynch.
I agree on Vander but would rather get this wagon pushed as UnaH still has yet to respond after saying he would today.
Pretty sure you already agreed with my reasoning.
Also, his placement on the Porken’s wagon.
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 12:00 pm
by Morality
We’re lynching on the wagon. Who was on Porken’s and Chip? That’s likely where scum is too.
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 12:01 pm
by Morality
Oh, what do you know...Vanders was on both. -.-
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 12:02 pm
by UC Voyager
Spoiler: Graveyard
Spoiler: Night Results
UCV (Jail keeper) targeted Rhah (No immediate noticeable effect)
UCV
Vanilla on WaveMode
Morality
Vanilla on zulfy
CheekyTeeky
Vanilla on Rhah
Unah
Vanilla on CheekyTeeky
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 12:03 pm
by UC Voyager
oh..i forgot to mention vanilla cop in current.....bla
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 12:07 pm
by CheekyTeeky
Yes I have lingering suspicions from D1 on Vander. You say you could see scum Vander pushing another mislynch today, so wouldn't it make more sense to wait and see his direction to confirm your theory? Seems a bit rushed/premature to lock scum him, when you've nerfed the info potential of your push.
Pedit what does Chip have to do with proving someone is scum?
it was mostly to help me remember these things lol
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 12:21 pm
by Rhah
Una or necro today
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 12:24 pm
by Rhah
I cannot believe you jailkept me and not someone who actually drove that horrendous mislynch
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 12:39 pm
by CheekyTeeky
VOTE: necro we have other roles that can deal with Unah.
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 12:49 pm
by Morality
In post 1139, CheekyTeeky wrote:Yes I have lingering suspicions from D1 on Vander. You say you could see scum Vander pushing another mislynch today, so wouldn't it make more sense to wait and see his direction to confirm your theory? Seems a bit rushed/premature to lock scum him, when you've nerfed the info potential of your push.
Pedit what does Chip have to do with proving someone is scum?
It’s not. It’s just how I play. When he posts in response to me, I can tear him up. I’m best in 1v1 interaction.
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 1:09 pm
by CheekyTeeky
So I think necro is looking pretty bad since acid died. I'd like to see some content from him before I disclose why I think the NK implicates him.
Acid didn't really help us out much in terms of reads. I think his lack of connections to others might be why he was NK'd. I saw he didn't want a vanders lynch and was happy to lynch in {Chip, Rhah, Me}. Porkens had bad readslist but some good points after the hammer.
so here is what i got.
Last night, i decided to jail keep Rhah. as you can see, someone was still killed! This tells me that either he isn't mafia, or he is a non-killing role
I say this gives him a better chance of not being mafia....
im assuming as least 2 of the mafia were on Porkens.....this is who was on him
Myself (Jailkeeper)
Rhah (non-killing role)
UnaH
Necro
SheepSaysMeep
Chip
Vanders
here is what I know
Porkens had a scum read on a few people. notable people such as rhah, Necro and CheekyTeeky.
Rhah, who i can confirm is most likely town, also has a scum read on necro....
Acid didn't really push necro, but definitely questioned his reads.
right now. If you asked me, i would sya
scum team = Necro, Unah, still trying to find the third
I wish you hadn't claimed this.
All it means is that rhah wasn't the person who put in the NK, which really doesn't tell us a lot.
Also, I could not care less what Porkens' reads were.
In post 869, Morality wrote:I’m weary of a wagon flipping over to Chip suddenly if Una wagon doesn’t go further. If that starts to happen, please don’t push it further. Don’t need two claims here.
VOTE: Vander
In post 871, Morality wrote:Vander is playing in a way where he’s staying out of the direct wagons, but in a way where it will allow him to jump on either if he needs to, especially this close to deadline. Tomorrow, I can see ScumVander completely taking over and being able to push through another mislynch.
In post 871, Morality wrote:Vander is playing in a way where he’s staying out of the direct wagons, but in a way where it will allow him to jump on either if he needs to, especially this close to deadline. Tomorrow, I can see ScumVander completely taking over and being able to push through another mislynch.
I agree on Vander but would rather get this wagon pushed as UnaH still has yet to respond after saying he would today.
Pretty sure you already agreed with my reasoning.
Also, his placement on the Porken’s wagon.
I jumped on Porkens who was a direct wagon, and I townread CT pretty strongly while he was a wagon.
It's fairly worrying that you're still using this.
Can you actually give specific examples of wagons that I was scummily avoiding?
