In post 2673, MariaR wrote:Can you give me some explains of lying that town has done so I can get a better idea by what you mean by lynch all liars? Because I think there's a dif between gambit lies and good lies
fake guilties, fake PR claims, Fake VT claims, any lie really. Any info that isn't true.
i'm actually hypocritical here because i always claim VT in mass claim but heavily, heavily crumb my role before mass claim. So in that instance i'd be arguing for my lynch due to the zero tolerance. I'd rather have it that way though than to continue to allow others to lie repeatedly.
lying about reads isn't concrete info. I'm talking about info YOU KNOW specifically.
no, its literally any lie. I've played more games than this one krazy. While that tilted me to oblivion, it was the final straw of terrible play I've seen from so many players here.
In post 2679, Ankamius wrote:Tchill where's the line for fake claims between good and bad? Where does a 2-shot doc claiming 1-shot doc fit in?
could lead to misleading setup spec. I'm not gonna argue it's full proof obviously its not. I'm saying the majority of the time lies hurt more than help the way lies are used on this site and as such i'd rather do away with them than continue to use them.
To argue certain intricacies can't help my case. such as 1 shot vs 2 shot.
In post 2685, MariaR wrote:I remember a lie we did in real folks mafia that outright won town the game so hey
how many lies do you think outright lost town the game?
You're gonna think of negatives before positive always
Only when a negative tends to happen more than a positive. I think good town lies are great. I think good town anything is great. It's just that more times than not players think they're making good town lies when in fact they're making good individualized lies for themselves that actually put the team in a worse position to win.
Maria I understand your point. I don't necessarily agree that the bad should out weigh the good. In the context of everyone though, I'd rather get rid os something used wrong on a regular basis.
I was 100% sure that I would finish this game without replacing (I replace out a lot, and honestly mostly for fickle reasons), but this one kinda wasn't my fault. Shit hit the fan in real life and I needed to focus on that and had no time or patience to play mafia. Once a week I would do a quick read in the game though to see how it was going.
I wasn't added to any dead thread though, so I couldn't comment my thoughts (I was wrong most of the time)
but talking about the game, woah, how come you flipped scum on me TW? :/
Like, my first thought when I looked on tw slot was "ok, he kinda sounds like he is staying under the radar and avoiding attention" that may be sometimes something scummy but I always was used to scum!TW being kinda townier and more vocal as scum, so I thought he was a power role since from the start (and idk if he just was unmotivated, this was his normal way of playing or faking a power role was his plan since the start). Also, the replacements he did weren't strategic guys, it really just was a pun between us, I even considered subbing in as my alpaca alt as well.
Aside from the fact that he cornered himself in the end, I think TW played well honestly. Better than most of us townies at least.
About Mumble...eh...I dunno. I didn't read afterwards but while I was playing he posted so little, and I have the impression that he would post similarly as either alignment. Idk how to read slots like that at all...
About the fake guilty I dunno what to say? I laughed a lot when Tchil flipped town though, Oath's reaction was funny as well.
"What?! Tchill was actually town? How come..."
My reads this game were bad though...
I think there was no scum in my day 1 priority lynch pool if I remember right
when I realised it was undisclosed 2:11 I was planning a PR claim from the get go - I actually had a feeling you had a feeling that was what I was up to Yuurei.
don't feel too bad about it... bad reads happen and this game was messy.
