Mafiascum.net

In post 544, Tchill13 wrote:You also know as scum that someone would be pointing out the fact you hadn't died yet by now. This has red flags all over it.

To be fair, I somehow missed this.
Chill DID point this aspect out.

Oh, lost thought so I just sent that wall, but I now remembered one thing I wanted to address.

I'm thinking CT (or their teammates) thought it wiser to backtrack the whole claim rather than try to come up with faked targets.
It still wouldn't change the fact they didn't die last night themselves, and assuming they were town and wanted to make a reasonable claim for a target..they would have to claim having saved Boon.

So they couldn't claim a protect on Boon with the hope that Chill survives from the back of Boon "confirming" them, so they decided to not claim protect on anyone else either -> backtrack the whole claim.

Good stuff.

“Blessed Mafia, recommend checking it out if you want to see how scum!Boon+Chill can destroy a mans life.”

Possible new sig quote after this game.

If Unah’s scum, consider me a random $20 on the ground, cuz I am pocketed.

(I just recommend it to everyone because I still caught all three of you out on that gambit, and got praised in the dead thread )

Man, Ducky’s game is making me feel it’s time for the next BooneyToonz game.

Only if I'm invited.

In post 555, UnaBombaH wrote:(I just recommend it to everyone because I still caught all three of you out on that gambit, and got praised in the dead thread )

Yeah, that’s a game I like to point on when I state it doesn’t matter if you know they’re scum, you gotta be able to lynch them.

The dreaded neighborhood vig/gunsmith gambit. Tingles.

BTW, wanna bet Chill is going to come back into this thread saying we are scum together right outta the gates?

In post 559, UnaBombaH wrote:BTW, wanna bet Chill is going to come back into this thread saying we are scum together right outta the gates?

I am getting Increasingly paranoid of you two being scum and messing with me now

Before Flavor said he visited Tchill, I thought the most likely scumteam was FA/Nonny/Tchill. I initially started to rethink my reads, but Tchill's latest posts have caused me to doubt him again. If he wanted to see who opposed his plan to control Carca's shot, why did his various lists of who should be killed not include FA in 452 and 468? Also, Nonny is missing from these lists as well despite being a lurker. Tchill has actually mentioned Nonny only around twice, in the posts 11 and 530. I'm curious, have Nonny and Tchill played together before?

By the way, I don't know for sure Gamma watched Profii on N1, that's just a guess of mine because its what I would have done. A PR claim is likely to get attacked or draw town protective roles on n1, so watching him makes sense. I can't confirm this though obviously. I like trying to guess what the power roles scum have are because it help me understand their strategy or judge whether someone is fakeclaiming.

In post 562, Completly Trustworthy wrote:By the way, I don't know for sure Gamma watched Profii on N1, that's just a guess of mine because its what I would have done. A PR claim is likely to get attacked or draw town protective roles on n1, so watching him makes sense. I can't confirm this though obviously. I like trying to guess what the power roles scum have are because it help me understand their strategy or judge whether someone is fakeclaiming.

He said he didn’t target Profii through my gambit

As for why I and Flavor Leaf didn't die last night, I think this is probably what happened. The scumteam knew Gamma was a watcher somehow and decided to kill him, probably afraid that he would see them going after one of the PR claims or because they wanted to kill a threatening PR while also incriminating the other claims. If they had a roleblocker, they surely blocked Flavor Leaf. That plan would prevent them from being caught by the watcher while also setting up a mislynch of one of the claims.

In post 545, UnaBombaH wrote:

In post 543, Tchill13 wrote:This is what I was looking for when I said we should control carcas shot. I was looking for someone, more than one person but it's fine, to hesitate to do that.

Is this you giving townpoints to FA for saying it?

Scum points.

In post 553, Flavor Leaf wrote:Good stuff.

“Blessed Mafia, recommend checking it out if you want to see how scum!Boon+Chill can destroy a mans life.”

Possible new sig quote after this game.

Town didn't play well that game.

Flavor could be town trying to make things more difficult than they are. I need to get to a computer and really take a deep look. Luckily I'm off tomorrow.

My name is getting thrown around as scum a lot due to association it looks like.

Meanwhile I don't think I've had 2 votes on me.

Town has no idea what's going on, I seriously suggest we proceed with caution. Need to get some strong TR's as a group and move forward.

For those worried about how well some work together as scum (messing with my thoughts too) I suggest you throw that out the window. It's just gonna make things more complex.

FA and CT are at the top of my scumdar due to legitimate play.

Gamma seems to be doing something I used to do all the time (major complex conspiracy theory)

My read of una is null.

If we don't start reading ppl based on play, town won't win. It'll just get more confusing.

Dave hasn't done shit to game solve.

FA, CT.
Dave
Flavor
UNA
Gamma

That's my scummy to less scummy list.

Do you realize Gamma is dead Tchill?

Also, what do you think about the scenario I described in 564?

Damn. Una, not gamma. I got the avis mixed up. Sorry.

Assuming the scum had a roleblocker and knew about Gamma being a watcher, here's a list of the things they could do.
Block me, kill Gamma- This lets Flavor investigate successfully
Block me, kill Flavor Leaf- This probably results in the watcher noticing the roleblocker or catching the killer in the act.
Block Flavor Leaf, kill me- There's a high chance of the watcher being on me
Block Gamma, Kill me- This lets Flavor investigate
Block Gamma, kill Flavor Leaf- They probably thought I was an actual doctor, so attacking the obvious protection target wasn't a good idea
Block Flavor Leaf, kill Gamma-This stops both invest results and leaves potential mislynches available.

If there is no roleblocker, then Gamma is the obvious target if they know about him. They would not want to attack me because of the watcher and Flavor would probably be assumed safe due to a doctor's protection. Therefore; it makes sense that I and Flavor lived.

[quote="In 573”]
Therefore; it makes sense that I and Flavor lived.[/quote]
Only on the premise scum knew or guessed Gamma was a watcher. Show how you think scum knew this? Is there a breadcrumb? Is there a claim?