Mini Normal 2044: Game over!

[bji]

I wanted this because I agreed with sash’s feeling that voting Garmr at start of d2 does look like bussing in retrospect

Good, I'm still not experienced enough to trust all my reads. I'm happy they be confirmed here.

And in Day 4 you just trusted your reads. This is why you got lynched ...

[bji]

If Clem votes you, I promise that I will give you time to defend yourself.

I lied, sorry

[Sashaddin]

Persivul, why would Sash kill Reaper instead of you? Even if he were roleblocker, I think your level of play is higher than everyone else's here so I would expect Sash to want to get rid of you instead of a player (Reaper) who wasn't really contributing anything to town's chances of winning other than being a warm body.

Furthermore, you are I were both agreeing to vote Sash today. So Sash could predict that he would already have two firm votes today, and only needing one more to be lynched, it seems that his only hope would be to eliminate you and hope that two other town besides me wouldn't vote him.

Additionally, your elimination was expected and so wouldn't really give much info about who the scum was.

The question then becomes, is Sash really ballsy enough to count on the above conclusions and do the opposite to throw us off his track? No offense Sash, but I don't think so.

In my opinion scum is either Clem or Irrelephant.

I need to read more to see which player was more likely to kill Reaper than you. Again, busy with work, not sure when I will be able to do this, probably tonight.

- Both Persivul and I ended Day 2 saying that we wanted to lynch Sash.
Yet Sash didn't kill Persivul or me. Persivul would have been an easy
kill to try to deflate the wagon on Sash - not even suspicious, as the
overriding reason to kill Persivul would be becuse he is cop. So Sash
could kill him, and take pressure away, without any chance of being
suspected. Instead the scum killed Reaper and roleblocked Persivul.
So Sash would have killed Persivul, not Reaper. And Clem might have
thought that keeping Persivul alive would get a mislynch of Sash.
- End of Day 3 both Persivul and I were angling towards Clem (me hard,
Persivul soft). Clem's best play is to kill Persivul. Sash's best
play cannot be known and is WIFOM.

Day3 was my most fun mafia Day ever, and it was because of this

[Sashaddin]

And in Day 4 you just trusted your reads. This is why you got lynched ...

With way Clemency had just posted, I never thought you'd give him one cent of towniness.

[Sashaddin]

And in Day 4 you just trusted your reads. This is why you got lynched ...

With way Clemency had just posted, I never thought you'd give him one cent of towniness.

[bji]

Yeah man that really did almost win it for you. Very ballsy play.

[bji]

And in Day 4 you just trusted your reads. This is why you got lynched ...

With way Clemency had just posted, I never thought you'd give him one cent of towniness.

Did you re-read the ISOs like I did? If not, you should have. When I said at the end of yesterday I would vote Clem I meant it. I was totally ready to post nothing today but a vote of Clem. But then Persivul posted that he would re-read tomorrow and I thought ... Persivul is a better player than I am, if he would re-read, then I owe town a re-read too. Saved the game I think.

[bji]

If a Town-aligned player is lynched today or a no lynch occurs, Town will lose the game.

Just curious ... doesn't this give away information? Town theoretically could have had a Jailkeeper or something, so could have voted no lynch and still survived to the next day ...

[Garmr]

I'm sure playing scum can be hard. Yesterday it did look like you had bji nicely pocketed, and like you were probably going to win

I should have ben more patient in retrospect. Sorry garmr, I dropped the ball.

Nah you didn't drop the ball if anything I did. I should of noticed perc was a power role and I slipped up.

[implosion]

If you want to nominate this game or any people in it (moderator or players) for a scummy, please do!