Open 74 - C/9ths (Game Over!) before 601

[Mokina]

It's easy enough to confirm whether this is his first game or not. Look at his posting history.

I did. This is his first game. I am encouraging Snix and ZS to do so as well. ;D

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

I agree with mokina re: eldritch lord.

I would advise dcorbe to start providing some opinions on people.

I also feel like a prod of anyone who hasn't posted yet would be nice (I believe that's mike-zim and sideney)

[sideney]

I have post yet.

Eldritch behaviour don't like me, his first vote was to Snix, with some reasons ,i think, but the jump on wagon of TheSweatpantsNinja don't like me either.
But what most bother me is that Eldritch unvote after Zombie attack him. If i was Eldritch i think i have pointed out the connession between Snix and Zombie. But he don't do that, instead unvote. I think for now that i will

Fos Eldritch Lord
Fos TheSweatpantsNinja

But with high probability of a vote on one of this two.

[donkeyz12212]

I find Snix to be more suspicious than Eldritch lord. Like Mokina said, there is a lot of analytical town read from Eldritch and I truly agree with her on that.

Snix, on the other hand, just gives off this weird vibe for me. Don't know what it exactly, perhaps just a hunch.

unvote: Mokina

I don't believe that Snix and Eldritch could be scum buddies since their open hostility towards each other in the posts on page 3.

vote : Snix

That puts him at L-3.

So basically the same thing I did to Mokina. Feeling nervous Snix?

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Sorry, sideney, my mistake. So what makes my vote on snix scummy?

[Lowell]

As a rule I keep talkative newbies alive on D1. I will NOT be voting for eldritch.

[Elmo]

Day 1, Vote Count #2

Snix (3) <- TheSweatpantsNinja, Lowell, donkeyz12212
Eldritch Lord (3) <- Snix, DarlaBlueEyes, ZombieSlayer54
Mokina <- dcorbe
donkeyz12212 <- Iron Man

Not voting: Mokina, Eldritch Lord, sideney, mike-zim.

mike-zim has been prodded.

[mike-zim]

Vote No lynch

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Mike, why would we no lynch?

[Mokina]

As a rule I keep talkative newbies alive on D1. I will NOT be voting for eldritch.

Remember our good friend Abalidoth from our old newbie game? Eldritch is that same archetype, I tell you!

[Mokina]

Vote No lynch

Oh for heavenssake, introduce yourself first! Say hello or something!

[mike-zim]

well i am waiting to see how people play. so i no lynch now and try and work things out!!!

oh and Hi

[Lowell]

As a rule I keep talkative newbies alive on D1. I will NOT be voting for eldritch.

Remember our good friend Abalidoth from our old newbie game? Eldritch is that same archetype, I tell you!

Maybe, but who cares? He's not going anywhere, and I like to keep talkers around.

[Mokina]

well i am waiting to see how people play. so i no lynch now and try and work things out!!!

In the same position, I would simply reserve my vote for the future. No-lynch is an interesting decision in itself, and deserves the same degree of scrutiny a normal vote might. Remember that the scum get a free nightkill, and if we have no information on who they might pick, we're no better off the next day.

The odds of lynching a townie D1 on limited information are much higher than later on (current voters take note), but in my opinion we ought to see how this day plays out before we decide not to lynch. Maybe someone will emerge as the clear suspect, bringing us out of the realm of "limited information" and into a decent-chance lynch.

Until then, no-lynch is a bad plan. I don't blame you for it, though, because it's a typical cautious newbie suggestion (regardless of alignment).

[Eldritch Lord]

HAND OF SUSPICION!: Mike-Zim

*Dramatic Music Plays*

For epic lurking, and hopping to suggest a no-lynch. Yes, it may be a cautious town move, but with all that's happened thus far, I find it hard to believe you don't find someone just a tad bit suspicious-or that you would have a motive not to say so if you did.

[Iron Man]

Unvote

I was thinking a little random vote wouldnt hurt anyone, but right now, I have found little evidence that donkey is at all scum.

I know, I could probably bandwagon Snix or Eldritch, but right now, I dont find either scummy enough to deserve my vote. So, I'll leave my vote open for now.

[Snix]

unvote

I'll give you that this is his first game and that he could be wrong about certain things but he doesn't really act nor talk like a new player. He acts like a person who has researched this game better then some of us and just has a different view on random votes. He's taken away his OMGUS vote which was one of the core reasons I was after him and I believe he needs some room to breath as well.

I'm mildly worried about TSN and Lowell jumping to his side though, it looks mildly like, instead of actually reading the argument, they went "oh look words, I bet he's right."

Either way I'll be watching them.

[Eldritch Lord]

Vote: Lowell

You voted Snix to give my argument some legs, the thing is my argument barely had a base. I am shamelessly starting a Lowell wagon. Discuss.

[Snix]

Vote: Lowell

I agree with this product/service.

Lets turn up the heat.

[Mokina]

I disagree with Snix on several counts. He pretty much jumped on EL as scum when it's obvious he's simply new to the game. In fact, he's looking fairly protown (or at least analytical).

I believe in analysis and patience. Snix has just joined the Lowell wagon with no explanation, and that's a practice I simply can't agree with. So far, he has contributed very little analysis and far too much vague voting.

Vote: Snix

[ZombieSlayer54]

1. What is wrong with sharing Snix's logic? Especially since it IS logic.

2. The emotion comes hand in hand with logic. It is not just pure emotion.

3. DO NOT GIVE ME THE FRAKING CLUELESS NOOB EXCUSE. IT DOES NOT FLY WITH ME.

4. There are other things I have against Eldritch, namely his ignoring of Snix's and my own logic. I mean, he does not even TRY to argue against it. All he says is:

I see an exact, pointless repetition of Snix's logic combined with insulting, emotionally-charged monologue. Calm down.

Nothing else. He literally does NOT try to argue against it AT ALL.

5. "Feeling nervous Snix?"

Donkeyz, what was that? Seriously?

6.

FoS Mike-zim

. I see no reason to no-lynch at this point.

7.

FoS Snix

. You seemed to jump off the Eldritch vote pretty quickly after people started drilling you.

8. 92.

I do believe I need to say little else.

[DarlaBlueEyes]

I am back, just need to catch up. will post later

[Eldritch Lord]

So, ZS do you make it habit to

FoS

everyone who will not agree with your attempts to bandwagon: so far this has included Mokina and Snix in less than a 1 page span. It seems as though you love to pressure people into bandwagoning by FoS'ing them and its about as close as you can get to an OMGUS without it actually being and OMGUS.

I am not defending Snix, I just find your attempts to be forceful and it seems as though you assume a false mantle of leadership--where your logic has always been a bland repetition of previous posts and the logic of others'. Later you FoS Snix despite the fact that you "share" his logic in the very same post, that is unless something changed halfway through posting.

I don't think you're scum, I just think you try too hard to get people to agree with you.

[Snix]

First off I'd like to say that you're satire meters are broken. All I've done with this vote is put pressure on someone I think needs to be looked at. He has posted little to no actual content. The closest he's gotten is voting me to give EL's idea's a little leg room. Even EL has posted that his idea's didn't have anything substantial to them.

And yes I backed off because I achieved what I needed to achieve, I knew he wasn't going to be today's lynch. That would be ridiculous, to lynch him based on the fact that he made a newb mistake/did not agree with me.

To note all I did was repost TSN's post 37.

[Mokina]

Snix argues that Eldritch Lord initially pushed for a no-lynch, then pulled some epic OMGUS.

You have dubbed our reactions the "clueless noob excuse" but there

is

some logic behind it. New players are more likely to be cautious, and no-lynch appears on the surface to be a cautious town move (and incidentally, looks like a bad move for scum). Note mike-zim's initial reaction; he's doing the same thing, if a little less eloquently. They are both newbies, and I doubt they are both scum. No-lynch is an incredibly tempting option for D1 (uninformed) new-town, and combined with a tendency for analysis, that's my current impression of Eldritch.

It follows that Snix is either forgetting a crucial fact about EL or taking advantage of his ignorance, actions which look antitown and plain scummy, respectively. It smelled like quicklynch, Snix. If I have missed something, let me know and I will reread.