125 South Park Mafia: Game over

[Talitha]

Awesome start, couldn't be better!

Didn't Jesus hang out with Cartman & buddies? I haven't watched SP for a while.

vote: Fishbulb

- because I haven't done that for a while.

[Talitha]

I can't believe you're still sore about that, Fishbulb, hehe.

[Talitha]

Oh, and is popsiclestix going to check in to the game?

[Talitha]

5 out of 6 votes? For not realising the game has started? Most scum realise that the game has started because they're waiting impatiently to see their evil handywork in the morning post.

[Talitha]

It's heartening to see that Popsiclestix is refusing to claim. DP would be very proud!

I dunno... it is day 1 but I feel we could find a better lynchee than PS today. Unlike IS, I don't mind waiting a little while.

But I know that someone sitting there 1 vote away from a lynch is just too enticing for most people... so if you've got an important role I'd encourage you to claim ASAP popsicle.

[Talitha]

blackshadowshade: In your post you seem to assume that popsiclestix is town, yet you want to lynch him anyway? Especially where you say you "might consider chasing some of the

real

scum" if he contributes.

Popsiclestix isn't getting anywhere NEAR annoying enough for me to want to lynch him purely for annoyingness. If you think he's scum, cool, vote for him. If you think he's not scum, don't. It's pretty simple.

Oh and

unvote: fishscum, vote: bss

[Talitha]

Ummm.. can you explain your "gotcha" comment and the vote on Peacebringer please bss?

[Talitha]

unvote: bss, vote: peacebringer

I'd be playing super-careful.. posting plenty but not rocking the boat, unvoting to give people time to talk, like a good conscientious townie... if I lost my mafia buddy night 1.

[Talitha]

Kenny getting lynched Day 1 does seem quite appropriate. If he's town I will feel like a bastard, but no objections from me.

[Talitha]

You're hurting my feelings Pops.

But seriously, I take that to mean you don't want to lynch Peacebringer. Please state your position.

[Talitha]

jedi: Yes I think Peacebringer is probably Kenny.. but he could still be bad. Jesus was bad. Jesus & Kenny?? It's a possibility isn't it? My SP memories are too hazy to remember how likely this is.

And jedi, why are you not voting for BSS if he's the most scummy in your mind?

Popsiclestix: I said earlier that peacebringer was acting like I would be if I lost a partner on night 1. Nice and careful. Also some people have observed that he is acting differently in this game than he usually does.

[Talitha]

Interesting that you would say that you're not voting. The vote count has you voting for popsiclestix, and you knew this because you said:

I still don't think that Popsicle has done anything that really convinces me to take my vote off him

You're looking like someone who is afraid to look like a bandwagoner.

[Talitha]

Peacebringer: I can't really respond to your 'crap' or 'spin' allegations unless you give some specific examples.

[Talitha]

If you're on the town's side PB, you'll tell us exactly what your role is right now, rather than leaving little threatening hints about kamikazee roles, and saying that we should be able to figure out what your role does.

Just tell us.

I really can't imagine someone who is pro-town acting this way, unless it's just a case of sour grapes because we're voting for you.

[Talitha]

Jedi: Uh.. you "know" he's pro-town? If you feel that strongly why aren't you trying to convince the rest of us?

And if you're not prepared to lynch someone who has a chance of being pro-town then you'll never lynch anyone.

If I wasn't so emotionally attached to my Kenny vote, I'd be voting for you right now.

[Talitha]

Ah I knew it. How do we kill you Kenny, you little scum.

I'll vote

Mr Gnome

[Talitha]

Because I blocked you last night and there were no kills.

[Talitha]

Firstly, IS obviously has a posting requirement and I think we should lynch him

Second, I never said we should lynch Gnome immediately, or that he's definitely scum. But knowing that I blocked him and that there were no kills last night makes me believe he's more likely to be scum than anyone else in the game. So I've voted for him, and hope we can bandwagon him. But I know everyone else has their own set of information to go on, and may have a better lead. That's cool.

Bloojay - if you have some definite information that could lead us to catching a scum, then spit it out. Otherwise I think you said too much already.

I'm a little dubious about Peacebringer's explanation.. after the hints he was dropping yesterday. I don't think he was told only that he is town. And I don't think he used the words 'plain townie' yesterday.. did he?

[Talitha]

It occured to me that maybe the mafia had the option of bringing Kenny back to life instead of killing last night...


IS is quite right that we should follow the concrete info... BSS obviously thinks that his character would not be sane, and I agree that bloojay is less suspicious than IS so

unvote Mr Gnome, vote: IS

(awww - sorry!)

[Talitha]

So what's your explanation for BSS's claim then Fishbulb? I mean logically, at least one out of BSS, bloojay and IS must be bad.... And I don't think BSS or bloojay are bad.

IS looks like he's getting ready to claim doc. And trying to get a cop lynched. Scummy scummy scummy

[Talitha]

bloojay, you said you healed on night 1......

This game just. gets. weirder.

unvote

[Talitha]

Tam: A heal is the same as a protect.

So let me get this straight..... actually I'm not even going to try, I'm too confused.

Popsiclestix: Have we heard all of your results yet? Could we please?

I don't want to lynch bloojay right now.. I think he's protown and I'm still incredibly suspicious of IS.

[Talitha]

Popstix: Both night choices and results please.

[Talitha]

Is there any chance that Barbrady would be naive? In one episode they find out he can't read.

bloojay & bss both have useful roles, if they're pro-town.
I'm wondering if we should hear BSS's role name.. might give a better idea about sanity.

I'm tempted to suggest we lynch kenny again... but that doesnt help resolve these cop investigations.

[Talitha]

re bloojay: I tend to think if he was making it all up he would've got his story straight.

jedi: mods often put some more obscure roles in the game, to make it more balanced.. it guards against the mass role claim strategy favouring the town too much. I'm sure Nanook hasn't designed a game where a mass role claim would be the best town strategy.

I read somewhere that Towelie is the worst character to ever be on SP. Could that mean that he thinks the good players are bad and vice versa? I agree it's a strange role for a cop to have.

[Talitha]

The only reason I'm not voting for IS is because no-one has counter claimed to be the doc.

I've suddenly had another idea that maybe the mafia framer targeted IS on Night 1... thus reversing results on him, thus meaning that BSS should have got a guilty on him, thus meaning that both IS & blooj could be innocent.

So now I'm tossing up between voting for Peacebringer, Mr Gnome, and jediknight. Anyone want to try and sway my vote?

[Talitha]

Did you roleblock me too, Tally?

That depends, did you protect me?

[Talitha]

So you really believe that bloojay went to all that trouble to concoct such an elaborate roleclaim... and then

forgot his made up night results

?
Uhhmm, I don't think that's likely, sorry.

[Talitha]

do you two have a recent mafia history that might cause him to protect you?

Nah.. we're friends. I was just being impertinent.

[Talitha]

You also have to consider the particular player. I've played a few games with bloojay and in my opinion he's not the type to make up an elaborate role claim. Especially with no pressure on him. Did you look at the context in which he made his claim?

[Talitha]

Heh, no offense blooj, but if I remember rightly, the times you've been scum in games with me you have lurked and tried to blend in, and certainly haven't made an unsolicited claim!

So I'm pretty sure that you are who you say you are.. and the fact that you've been so transparent and relaxed about your role makes me believe you are pro-town. It also looks like a pro-town kind of role to me. Please only target people who you think are likely scum, mmmkay?

[Talitha]

He hasn't squirmed, cried, pleaded or begged anywhere enough for me to get any satisfaction out of lynching him yet!

Oh and he might want to claim.

[Talitha]

OK Gnome, I'll be voting for you in 24 hours, if nothing significant happens in the interim. Consider this a cue.

[Talitha]

You're not even going to give us anything to chew over? Hmmm.

If there's anyone present who sees any reason why we shouldn't lynch this man, speak now or forever may he rest in peace.

[Talitha]

dammit. You beat me to it.

[Talitha]

I was about to leap to Tam's defense, because I blocked her last night.
But thanks for that info bloojay.

vote: Tam

I think that's 3

[Talitha]

bloojay had a great role, of course he had to use it!

Nanook: Thank you for a great modding job. Fun game, and your setup was fine I think. Maybe the SK could've had one night kill immunity or something, that's the only thing I can think of.

And great job town.

[Talitha]

Haha... IS won't even forgive me for voting for him.

And 'whoops' about the fast lynch - I think that was my fault for not counting carefully enough.