the worst Idea Mafia - Game Over!

[Carcalilly]

FIR 1ST

[Carcalilly]

Carca I'm surprised you didn't go for the spook faction
Like idk your other options but the ability to steal a role in this setup sounds amazing

.D---.
J U-U

But I can only posses one dude. Plus I like to *spongebob censor noise* more.

[Carcalilly]

OwO hey guys lets make this the GAME of the month

[Carcalilly]

So am I correct in thinking that the town discards are not aligned with town?

nope maybe not

[Carcalilly]

That is honestly a really sad looking elephant I'm sorry

[Carcalilly]

.....____(O ., ,. )O
>-- \ \
Ll Ll Ll Ll \ \

[Carcalilly]

.....____(O ., ,. )O
>-- ___ \ \
Ll Ll Ll Ll \ \

[Carcalilly]

.....____(O ., ,. )O
>-- __ ___ _\ \
Ll Ll Ll Ll \ \

[Carcalilly]

Close enough

[Carcalilly]

But that assumption makes the game boooringggg

Pedit Its a goddamn elephant

[Carcalilly]

Are we even supposed or allowed to post in pregamr

[Carcalilly]

vote*

[Carcalilly]

OwO I was right

[Carcalilly]

what are you all even doing

[Carcalilly]

this entire game is already a meme

[Carcalilly]

kekekekekekkekekekekekke

[Carcalilly]

What the fuck is this

[Carcalilly]

What TV show could describe this game perfectly right now

[Carcalilly]

guys quit playing the game it hasn't started yet

[Carcalilly]

I have a headache but rce wagon has a good point with terrible execution

[Carcalilly]

I have a headache but rce wagon has a good point with terrible execution

What do you mean?

rce is a little bit scummy but the naked votes and lol wagon are kinda unnecessary

[Carcalilly]

Skitter you're town correct?

[Carcalilly]

you're casual lines sound forced
Either that or you're humor is pretty dry right now

And you're using a couple fence words that really just makes things awkwarder

[Carcalilly]

How dare yoy

[Carcalilly]

WTF guys stop voting me I'm a goddamn town dolphin

[Carcalilly]

VOTE: Carcalilly

I found scum

Which of her, like, five serious posts gave you that impression?

LMAOOO

[Carcalilly]

Althpough I agree with you Invis I'm wary that Carca can be lynchbaity.

Are you sure you haven't played with me before?

[Carcalilly]

you're casual lines sound forced
Either that or you're humor is pretty dry right now

And you're using a couple fence words that really just makes things awkwarder

My humor is not for everyone, that's not scummy.
.can I get an example of these fence words?

I don't think

I like using meta

but

since we are using the micro we played as a baseline, Ausuka took the same opening with me (

why does your play look so different

) and was scum in the end,

so meh

.

Also I will pass unless the mod confirms

you COULD have taken town and DID take town. Instead I'll settle for your red flip.

Ehh my suspect list for discarded roles would be

something like

SS, shock, potentially cheekyteeky, I

forgot

who I included in my original scumteam prediction

but that guy too

. POTUS is 3rd party or town, lane is never scum.

You make you're posts a lot more awkward then they need to be. Not scum indicative to me, though.

[Carcalilly]

VOTE: carcalilly

I have a headache but rce wagon has a good point with terrible execution

wagons r good, also awkward post

I have a headache but rce wagon has a good point with terrible execution

What do you mean?

rce is a little bit scummy but the naked votes and lol wagon are kinda unnecessary

awkward defense

I live and breathe awkwardness

[Carcalilly]

Gonna sheep invis on this
VOTE: Carcalilly
Carca there is a disconnect in your statements. Example you liked the wagon forming on me, your objective should be to lynch scum or at least pressure scummy behavior, votes are the weapon of town. That would make the wagon on me necessary to pressure scummy behavior or possible scum. Unless of course you are implying your objective is not to lynch scum.

If I think a wagon is shit I'm gonna call it shit. I ain't stoppin you from wagoning but I'm going to track behind it like a grumpy old lady to get my points across.

[Carcalilly]

WTF guys stop voting me I'm a goddamn town dolphin

For clarification is this a full claim?

UNVOTE:

Carca will confirm herself on any flip so even if we lynch town and dolphin doesn't flip it's a 1 for 1 trade.

yeah lmao as simple as that I knew I would need it

[Carcalilly]

Spook was a role
It was a 3p
I took nothing from that card.

[Carcalilly]

me

[Carcalilly]

Feel scum dolphin would be better off holding the claim. Paired with her 3p discard I feel alright voting elsewhere right now.

I had several posts within the last few pages focused on my Carca read.

Huh? Why would scum hold back the claim?

Does anyone else understand RCE’s logic here?

As scum I would wait to see how town reacts to dolphin flipping, they can judge of hardclaiming dolphin is safe or if fakeclaiming is safer.

Now that I've said that I feel I kind of have to claim that I'm also a dolphin so expect 2 flips.

You really shouldn't have claimed so early.

But that having said, if you're scum I don't see the thought process behind claiming as part of pushing Carca in this manner... I definitely think you're town.

lmao this hurts my brain
this is either complete scumplay or you all not realizing how bad that play just was

[Carcalilly]

Oh my god I'm dying

[Carcalilly]

Is there a case on ceejay at all? It’s normal for him to post weirdly. I find the case on Carca more convincing than Ceejay.

this is his entire iso:

Hi

Hi is this still pre game

VOTE: Carcalilly

I found scum

he has basically no contributing thoughts, and his vote on carca is bandwagon-y and oppurtunistic and doesn't actually indicate why he think she's scummy

he's fully capable of more (see open 737) when he plays as town

==

As scum I would wait to see how town reacts to dolphin flipping, they can judge of hardclaiming dolphin is safe or if fakeclaiming is safer.

Now that I've said that I feel I kind of have to claim that I'm also a dolphin so expect 2 flips.

a) honestly dolphin is like the safest claim i can imagine for scum if they are in fact dolphin; i really can't imagine what kind of backlash someone would get for claiming and flipping dolphin; in fact doesn't dolphin just flip after day1? how can someone even fake-claim as a dolphin ... ?

b) yeah so i think the dolphin thing is tw's gimmick for this game; there's no way this many dolphin-related cards show up randomly; we got town scubadiver (which we used as our aligment card) - if there's dolphins in the game we'd be lovers with the dolphins; if there isn't it's effectively a named townie. i was like ... the odds of there being dolphins in this game is incredibly low given that there's like 5000 roles in play + i don't want to lovers if there is + named townie is kinda boring in a grand idea game

c) i'm getting jester vibes from you which is making me kinda wary

==

@mod can you

a) do a vc

b) prod everyone in prod range please?

---- skitter

So you're not a scubadiver right?!
I got a scum dolphin card that I took the role from. Took town from vanilla townie.

[Carcalilly]

Yeeeah, I'm not gonna lie, I'm not used to not getting much attention. If anyone wants to do something that involves me that'd be suuuuuper

Yee

Spoiler:

Mega snipped

Dear god..

Overly generic entrance

sorry

Unnecessarily apologetic

<3

oh god

WiFoM

That's a bad word

you're not scum though

[Carcalilly]

VOTE: Carcalilly

I found scum

I'm a day and night cop. Carca is scum.

Disclaimer: my sanity isn't guaranteed tho

are u fuckin kidding me that is actually a straight up lie

[Carcalilly]

Like you will literally see me flip town once today ends either you're a Lynch me role or just didnt think this through didn't you

Tell me what you're role does including all bastardized mechanics

[Carcalilly]

okay ss I'm paranoid af about cops because of my last game please get them to take back that joke

[Carcalilly]

waaaiit is there a cop role that occasionally gets wrong results

holy shit gamma

[Carcalilly]

They're either paranoid/insane cop and I suggest checking another person during the night to figure it out

[Carcalilly]

Keyser, Vanilla townie is my favorite role : )

[Carcalilly]

Sorry I faded

[Carcalilly]

If I dayvig someone who's still in can I take their spot?

are u

[Carcalilly]

I just feel like there's nothing much to look into at this point. Maybe we just lynch Carca to get the game moving again?

nO NOT AGAIN

[Carcalilly]

Like you will literally see me flip town once today ends either you're a Lynch me role or just didnt think this through didn't you

Tell me what you're role does including all bastardized mechanics

i thought just your role flipped; not your alignment

(ie i thought the flip was of the form 'Carca, a dolphin, has performed a flip')

==

okay ss I'm paranoid af about cops because of my last game please get them to take back that joke

i also learned i really can't read you so

==

He literally said his sanity isn't guaranteed,

so even if it is real, it's not a hard guilty...

Also I might recall some roles existing that were day/night cops where the day part and the night part have different sanities. Let me check that real quick.

right so my problem is that he said 'vote:carca i found scum'

==

Seems an awful lot like saying "if I'm wrong, dont lynch me bro, it was just a prank"

+1

==

I seriously wish I knew.
I could partially lean towards Vax because of his slot saying some questionable things. But it wasnt enough for me to think they're def scum though

his slot as said literally nothing game-related thus far besides playing hangman (which indicates that he's clearly following along yet not contributing)

==

cool with lynching cj + like any of the lurkers
i scumread rce too but i think they're a jester

----- skitter

Awwwh what?! I'm aware that scum dolphins can exist because I literally got my role from that card but then what's the point of dolphining if it doesn't flip your rolecard

[Carcalilly]

WAS THE GUILTY ACTUALLY FAKED

[Carcalilly]

Also if any of you know me or played with me before you know I prefer town because I am SHIT as scum

[Carcalilly]

you guys are mean

[Carcalilly]

@people who played with him before

how seriously should I take cj, in general

[Carcalilly]

No one is obviously real and one isn't.

I found my new fave koan

i liked this post.

i briefly iso'd BNL and he seems vaguely towny
RC seems kinda town but shrug
i also skimread the past 2 pages, i have nothing to say about them
i'm not really playing this game!

-EP!

aww look it's a fluffy

[Carcalilly]

Hmmm. I think CJ retracting his claim is kinda towny. Not keen to move to RCE atm. I find BNL a little LAMISTy.

VOTE: BNL

can you explain why retracting claims is beneficial to town?

[Carcalilly]

That's an idea. I was thinking BNL might be the lyncher since he's pretty determined I'm scum for no great reason.

are we even sure we have a lyncher or could this be an excuse for flailing scum .-.

[Carcalilly]

I think if Ceejay really wanted to lynch Carca he wouldn’t have mentioned his sanity

Maybe it was backup for when I flip town


Pedit
I see that but imo something so blatantly game rambling is just,,, no

[Carcalilly]

UNVOTE: Carcalilly

Hmm what are the chances that Carcalilly is faking not knowing that flipping dolphin only flips role and not alignment

why would she fake that?

I think you were not interpreting that correctly

I am saying that it was unlikely that Carcalilly knows that dolphin does not flip alignment, so I doubt she chose scum Dolphin. I was referring to the hypothetical situation that Carcalilly already knew that dolphin flips only role but chose a scum dolphin and faked not knowing that dolphin flips only role, and I say that situation is unlikely.

I wish I was that good lmao

[Carcalilly]

i feel like if we overthink whether or not every scummy person is a jester we'll never get anywhere or lynch the scummy people tbh

Best post in the last handful of pages

[Carcalilly]

I'm claiming survivor

ffrick off

[Carcalilly]

nope.avi

Wait we're you always in this game? Where have you been??

[Carcalilly]

3 steps to win the game

1. Don’t lynch lane... ever
2. Don’t lynch ceejay... ever
3. Eat duck

VOTE: ceejay

[Carcalilly]

That's an idea. I was thinking BNL might be the lyncher since he's pretty determined I'm scum for no great reason.

are we even sure we have a lyncher or could this be an excuse for flailing scum .-.

What is this accusation of "flailing scum" when there aren't even any votes on Cheeky?

No no, I was talking about, like, if scum fakeclaimed and it didn't work out, they could just fuck around with all their claims and be like hahahahahah yeah this is my strategy when it's really just shit scrambling.

[Carcalilly]

My role is kinda confusing as fuck, so yeah, maybe we jsut stop this non-sense?

we all have really confusing roles please just explain

also did you replace alban??

Rush replacement killing usually ends up badly guys, dont hammer unless we have like less than a day left

[Carcalilly]

I hardly remember anything shock value said lmao

What I don't get is why you all want to push off the ceejay Lynch when you all seem to want him dead already anyway, like, nightkill/tomorrow?? Unless they actually claim and give us something worth the time the next day why not just do it now;;

[Carcalilly]

I hardly remember anything shock value said lmao

What I don't get is why you all want to push off the ceejay Lynch when you all seem to want him dead already anyway, like, nightkill/tomorrow?? Unless they actually claim and give us something worth the time the next day why not just do it now;;

They did claim

:We_smert:

Is survivor worth carrying them to endgame?

[Carcalilly]

Wait what the fuck unlynchable survivor

No lurker lynching

[Carcalilly]

But what if BnL/Cheeky is a really aggressive TvT or Tv3p? It seems like that to me honestly.

Also I don't think Eragon is working his ass off hard enough to be scum either. :shrug:

[Carcalilly]

Invisibility what's ur alignment

[Carcalilly]

Hnnngh I'm honestly worried about the discards because I don't know what other stuff they could've had

I for one got one Town, one 3p, and one Scum alignment cards. It's probably not the same for everyone but Im guessing it might be common, at least.

[Carcalilly]

slimer why

[Carcalilly]

Also I don't think Eragon is working his ass off hard enough to be scum either. :shrug:

I also don't get why anyone is scumreading BNL tbh they're my second to top townread rn, just under POTUS, so if anyone can give a tl;dr case I would really appreciate it

[Carcalilly]

Insert cat gif here

I think this post is scum indicative for you eragon

[Carcalilly]

in b4 replace out

[Carcalilly]

is invisibility always scummi

[Carcalilly]

Yeah no.

Carca, is that a scumread on Invisi there?

More of a FOS

[Carcalilly]

I wish shock value would post more

And again can someone please explain to me why lynching BNL/Cheeky is even being considered right now???

[Carcalilly]

awhh I understand that you're busy it's just hard to read your slot rn uwu take it easy though!

[Carcalilly]

also you guys suck because those were legitimate questions
so instaid of helping me out and explaining why the fuck who's scumreading who instaid of lynching me would very much be great thank you very much

[Carcalilly]

what is English wtf

[Carcalilly]

I'm pretty sure my vote is still on ceejay but if it's not VOTE: ceej because I want this slot OUT

[Carcalilly]

If you don't believe I'm a town dolphin you could at least wait for me to flip whatever that means

[Carcalilly]

a50 you were in that other game where I flailed a guilty and it really shouldn't take so much analysis to realize how different this time is

[Carcalilly]

I mean what the heck would you all do if someone bullshited you guilty

people that know me here should know that if I had a choice there's no way in hell I'd choose a scum alignment because I am. Crap. At. It.

[Carcalilly]

If you want to quicklynch me or something then I guess at least I get to say I told you so. And dolphin isn't a super useful powerrole anyway.

[Carcalilly]

*chirping noises*

[Carcalilly]

Nawh you get the exact role you ask for

[Carcalilly]

fine and just for today ceejay
If someone's a big shoot em for me
VOTE: shockvalu

[Carcalilly]

lol, contributing

[Carcalilly]

Lol I volunteer to be a lynch if SS flips scum

I don't have an opinion on SS but this makes me inclined to go through with it.
I'd prefer a claim if so, though.

[Carcalilly]

becauss I thought it'd be useful for me since I always get townlynched so maybe being conftown would help but I guess that's not how it works

[Carcalilly]

POTUS is our god

[Carcalilly]

BTW you do realize that there was an actual capability for the entire game to be 3p alignment so one 3p claim shouldn't invalidate another one?

[Carcalilly]

So you're OK with achieving Ceejay's wincon if he's jester, but not if he is survivor?

im too paranoid to carry them to endgame

[Carcalilly]

lmao how many towns do we even have at this point

[Carcalilly]

fine
UNVOTE:

[Carcalilly]

I'm just thinking that out of all the stuff we coulda chosen there's no way this is perfectly balanced.

[Carcalilly]

oh

[Carcalilly]

Can anybody else that's comfortable claim as a 3p? Maybe we can work something out.

[Carcalilly]

anybody can be scum RCE, even you

[Carcalilly]

WHAT HAPPENED TO CARCA’S AVATAR

Calm down, I'm just going through a Team Fortress 2 phase.

[Carcalilly]

I don't understand why RCE is relenting

Like seriously, not wasting a d1 lynch is a pro-town idea, that and helping carca flip.

Maybe if you didn't shitclaim I would see the point. :>

The ceejay that cried werewolf, if you get what I'm sayin'

[Carcalilly]

uggggghhh
ceej promise us all this isn't a shitclaim on top of a shitclaim,, just please

[Carcalilly]

ceejay just promise ya wont take it back

[Carcalilly]

despite me wanting ceej to move from here to the dead thread, I really wanna flip

[Carcalilly]

So you won...?! What

[Carcalilly]

ohh... damn

thanks for taking the hit though... oof

[Carcalilly]

It will be fineeeeee

[Carcalilly]

A50 do you think you can meta me?

[Carcalilly]

Okay because... Take this game heavily on me when it's done. My towngame is a lot more prominent/characterized than my scumgame.

Also, it's okay slimer. Irl problems really suck </3

[Carcalilly]

A50 seems to be in a much better mood than I'm usually used to lmao

[Carcalilly]

How do you even read Invisibility?!

What the fffuck does a town traitor do

[Carcalilly]

VOTE: shock value

[Carcalilly]

RCE are you one of those Town-by-Default players?

[Carcalilly]

I mean how does one sort you lol

You're not 3p are you?

[Carcalilly]

You put out the same amount of effort every game despite your role. Perhaps it's a nullification to meta but it makes me paranoid because I would never concieve you as scum.

[Carcalilly]

Effort/content that is

Also Invis
what

[Carcalilly]

come on guys place your votes down

[Carcalilly]

hi chara you're scummy

[Carcalilly]

You put out the same amount of effort every game despite your role. Perhaps it's a nullification to meta but it makes me paranoid because I would never concieve you as scum.

Maybe I'm super sneaky.

sToP mAkInG mE paRaNoId

[Carcalilly]

OK, nevermind

[Carcalilly]

I almost forgot eragon existed

[Carcalilly]

Awww poor AeroAri </3 life is hard and Mafia takes time.

[Carcalilly]

chara

if your town role sucks then Mafia members will probably keep you alive

[Carcalilly]

SS I also forgot you were here wtf

[Carcalilly]

okay

VOTE: Carcalilly

[Carcalilly]

lololololol

[Carcalilly]

Hecc ari is gonna play a little km happi

[Carcalilly]

Slimer have you been busy or really just not feeling this game?

[Carcalilly]

I do not like this at all why are people claiming

[Carcalilly]

Vax is actually making me pretty nervous right now

[Carcalilly]

Yeah but like wtf are you doing this all for and my last game with MariaR lyncher made me paranoid of this exact behavior

[Carcalilly]

ok ok but it better be a good reason

[Carcalilly]

Eragon, claim, and if Vax ends up with no result or this was all bullshit I'll votepark him.

[Carcalilly]

VOTE: vax

So you're just not gonna give us the results? :"/

[Carcalilly]

"why would scum do what I just did"
WIFOM

1.You made someone claim with nothing good coming out if it. (Aggressive rolefishing)
2.Your speculation makes no foundational evidence that you even have the role you're trying to portray

[Carcalilly]

If you can give us substantial information that indicates that you did all this for a pro-town motive, then I'll feel inclined to vote you. But currently, it looks really bad.

[Carcalilly]

*unvote

[Carcalilly]

VOTE: vax

So you're just not gonna give us the results? :"/

no stop it

don't forget his discard

you realize scum discard ≠ definitely not scum

[Carcalilly]

You were pushing me toclaim before I even said anything’

Because I could check your claim. THen you said it was complicated and had anti claim mechanics... that did not check out.

VOTE: Vaxkiller
I
But I never claimed anti-claim mechanics, thus you could not have “checked me” for anti-claim mechanics

Me thinks Vax' play bis anti-town, but not scummy. In other words, I believe this to be a misplay by a townie, rather than bold scum.

If Vax is scum, A50 is too and visa versa.

[Carcalilly]

To me that sounds so much like a distant defense.
Otherwise you watch yourself because you should never forget how mindfuckery this game can be.

[Carcalilly]

A50 are you nervous or in a good mood...?

[Carcalilly]

It's not like it's completely unheard of, and I don't know what kind of player Vax is and I don't want to take any chances.

[Carcalilly]

why the airquotes :s

[Carcalilly]

[Carcalilly]

What if Vax is some obscure 3p?

I see where you're coming from BnL, but do you have someone more beneficial to lynch in mind?

[Carcalilly]

I see a bit red seeping out of BnL and A50

[Carcalilly]

I think there was someone idk

[Carcalilly]

lol I just do this kind of thing to escape cop guilties as scum

[Carcalilly]

Other pertinent questions not directed solely at you. Before the wagon on Vax day 1 was broken up who all voted him besides Eragon, POTUS, and invis? He was at L-2 at one point without anyone expressing a scumread non-activity related.

Carca why is A50's "slight distancing" more likely to be a partner interaction than me literally derailing Vax's wagon on both days?

That question only makes me paranoid.

[Carcalilly]

Like, how much has A50 interacted with them before this? Plus if it's a WIFOM situation then the best thing to do is get a mass agreement on the deceiving situation.

[Carcalilly]

I hate it when people are like "if I was scum" or "why don't you scumread this thing I did", like, are you trying to call yourself suspicios?

[Carcalilly]

Invisibility?!

[Carcalilly]

don't make me regret this plz

VOTE: A50

[Carcalilly]

N O

[Carcalilly]

I have my reasons!

I'll make a shitcase tomorrow, I spent the whole day at Disney and I'm completely beat.

[Carcalilly]

whoa thank u BnL :0

[Carcalilly]

There's a lot of spec that seems to have so much more effort than its worth:
916
927
938
In turn took time away from his catch up.

1016 doesn't look super thought-out considering the demonstrated ability, but I may be biased.

1115 are you even okay

1295 This is a light hearted LAMIST which is only subliminally less incriminating.

1318 Chill out bro


Does Almost50 always shitposts this much?

[Carcalilly]

Im a bad mod
Replacing invisibility

Not your fault. His request was virtually invisible!

*hits head on desk*

[Carcalilly]

Okay that's just you, plus my default action is to not believe you because of what happened lol but OK

why is he town

[Carcalilly]

Prodge, not feeling too good today, I'll try to post something meaningful tomorrow

[Carcalilly]

I could do BNL lynch I think.

Both if you aren't looking too good but I'm much more comfortable lynching you

[Carcalilly]

I mean the general gist of A50’s posting is that he is really light hearted and likes to joke around, but in a fun way.

It worries me for some obscure reason >n<

[Carcalilly]

Oh, RCE is either town or 3p but either way they're the most protown person here so don't lynch them please.

the rce/shock buddies aren't even subtle

[Carcalilly]

VOTE: theslim3r

..........why

[Carcalilly]

Great. So Shocks role is anti town. Still don't want to "waste" a lynch on that. I want scum.

Bad Post