lord_hur wrote:springlullaby wrote:The sarcasm isn't doing you any grace, quantity doesn't equate to quality. Town do not do 'info gathering', town find suspicious people, press charges and judge - this is the meaning of 'coming with a case of your own'. Your vote on Harcker stinks, even more so because of your claim of being new.
1) You indicated that your vote was only half-heartfelt, why vote if you don't want to? Because people you know are town asked maybe?
2) If you are new, you probably don't know that a)not coming up with a case of your own b)being a people's pleaser c)leaving an exit door while casting a vote, are scumtell.
2a and 2c are bullshit, but 2b and 1 (which are the same thing) are indeed a scumtell that i noticed before. I can't really explain why I cast that vote. Brainfart I guess. Or maybe I was influenced by Mr Stoofer's experience.
Do you really believe that 2a and 2c are BS? Why? Do you know what scumtell means?
More importantly, are you rejecting the responsibility of your own vote on Stoofer there?
springlullaby wrote:I said a 'vague air of suspicion' and no, it is not the same as 1. Examples? Sure.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 78#1001978
This post stinks to high heaven, it is I believe totally artificial. A town mind doesn't come up with so many vaguely relevant questions addressed to so many people, it is more likely a post by a scum who want to look busy - especially since you don't seem to be garnering any insight in the game from the answers you got. Other examples abound, look at your own post history.
Oh hell yes it was completely artificial. I started thinking about a few questions, then thought "hey, why not one for every player, I never tried that, maybe I'll get some interesting reactions?". Sounded like a good idea back then, but it totally failed, as almost anyone ignored it. And yes, it ended up completely artificial.
Hm, are you agreeing with me that your post was artificial there? If you are being sarcastic, cut it out, it is not making you easier to understand.
And I'm not liking your answer there, town who have questions usually don't let them go unanswered, they press the matter because they are actually interested in the answers.
springlullaby wrote:Yes, and it is called playing the newbie card, justification of one's behavior which has been pointed out as scummy by invocation of alleged newbiness. And no, it certainly shouldn't save you any bashing, your newbie game was for something. Are you really not understanding this?
Oh, I'm understanding this, but I claim bullshit on it, because it can be applied to any newb. Instead of pointing to it, you should say what scumtell(s?) I was allegedly trying to cover.
Lol, is this a start of an OMGUS I'm sensing? Tell me, are newbies automatically town? See first point of this post for the example you ask, were you or were you not trying to reject the responsibility of your vote on Stoofer's 'experience', implying that you are a misled newbie?
springlullaby wrote:On the whole, I hate your posting pattern. You asks many questions, opening leads all over the place, but never commit to any strong conviction yourself, nor do seem to follow a distinct direction - I think of the people who where pushing stuff around D1, you were the main culprit. I think you are scum.
Yes, I suck at this game. I can't believe it took me 5 games to figure it out.
Is that an open admission of being scummy? What are you saying there exactly? Is that sarcasm again?
springlullaby wrote:@SeraphicMirth : did you do write down these notes before or after receiving your role PM ?
Noted.
You are seriously implying this was not a valid question? The answer completely changes the way you can use the analysis. If she wrote it before she got her role PM, it is unbiased, not if she did it after.
For the motive you invoke to justify why you asked it, I can answer you clearly that no, I do not believe it is a valid question. Tell me, what is the point of mafia game? After you thought about that, answer me, do you seriously believe that there will be people who post game analysis and commit to a vote before they even read their PM?
Are you really that ... clueless?
@others : keep in mind that it's pretty easy to find a few scumtells in that many posts, and she's having an easy time because no one can strike her back since she's replacing a ghost.
Oh, poor little you, life is unfair isn't it?:roll: If you are town, don't whine, it's unbecoming.
To the point, what is the meaning of that paragraph? What it is you are reproaching me exactly there?
--------------------------------
Others thoughts in another post for clarity.