Let's get the day started with a random vote for...
Because voting for a freak in a horror movie game just feels so right.
Now that the role has been revealed I would think his usefulness is pretty much gone, no? If he is telling the truth then no night killers will bother targeting him now.Nightfall wrote: but since my role is I would think, one of our more powerful
She did tell us, in the opening posts. The flavour for the game hints that it might not be a good thing in this town to be "good". The fact that she has given scum safe claims is also in there.StrykkerVerde wrote:d_rouge, I know that because the mod told me and she told me that she was going to tell the whole town. You guys can ask her yourselfs if you want to confirm this.
Again, I don't understand your reasoning.StrykkerVerde wrote:The Number 1 reason I don't believe you claim is because it feels to me like a role you made up yourself as opposed to a role that was given to you. All the scum have safe claims and to me that feels like one of them.
He says he thinks Nightfall made up the claim himself then in the next sentence says sounds like the mod gave it to him...which is it?Strykker wrote: The Number 1 reason I don't believe you claim is because it feels to me like a role you made up yourself as opposed to a role that was given to you. All the scum have safe claims and to me that feels like one of them.
Again, contradictory. He doesn't like the cop coming out this early but encourages a counter-claim, essentially asking any other cop to come out.StykkerVerde wrote: I really don't like the cop coming out this early but a guilty investigation is a guilty investigation.
I'm not going to vote yet however until everyone checks in. We can't just trust him cause he says he's the cop, he probably is but I'd still like to hold back and wait for a counter-claim.
See, the problem I have with this explanation is the assumption that there is only one cop role in this game. How does anyone know that?StrykkerVerde wrote: The cop came out early. That's bad. Who else agrees? On the plus side, he had a guilty investigation. This is good. However any asshole could say "I'm a cop he's guilty" so I would rather wait until most people have checked in because if he isn't the cop. Or if he is and scum try and counter-claim. We have then found ourselves some scum instead of just listining to the one guy blindly and letting the wolf lead the sheep to the pack.
In the end I wasn't trying to get more roles out in the open, I was just trying to stay on the side of caution. The cop has been revealed. There is now no way that that's not true. Because if he is the cop then that's that, and if he's not the cop and the real one doesn't come out then we're following a wolf and the cop would not be smart to let us do that.
And if Foolster did in fact investigate Nightfall, and he is in fact the cop, then I guess I was wrong about his role being bogus. My bad.