Mini 1080 -- txtMafia -- Game OVER

[chamber]

likely to be town of the 'red's given how much he looks like a good natured moron. What I don't understand though is how I'm above RF and most grievously pumps.

[chamber]

Every scum scenario I come up with save 1 has pappums as mafia, and that last 1 is too asinine to be worth mentioning. Still rereading.

Vote: Pappums Rat

[chamber]

If you had a town read on me why would you be voting me over FtF?

[chamber]

Thats the worst reason to have a read one someone ever, sigh.

[chamber]

and most grievously pumps. <- should read pums, as in pappums. As in hes by far the best lynch today.

[chamber]

OMGUS? Are you fucking kidding me? You were my lynch of choice yesterday. If anything you OMGUSed me.

[chamber]

That setup is horribly balanced in scum favor, pretty sure AV is town at this point, but I wasn't going to say anything if it kept me alive threw the day.

[chamber]

They have an RB at least given AV's claim of being blocked.

[chamber]

Is SIFOM a WIFOM typo? If so I don't get why that post was especially filled with WIFOM.

[chamber]

AV At this point I have to assume that you are town, so I'm going to ask you to do a favor for me.

[chamber]

Can you go back to what FIRST made you think I was scum, now look at it, if it's just OMGUS to me attacking you, or a bad reaction to my playstyle,

[chamber]

I want you to look at all the other points you think you have against me and decide if they were made under the mindset of

[chamber]

"I'm assuming chamber is scum so what could explain scum making this post" because that's what a lot of your recent accusations against me have felt like

[chamber]

Its a useless way to scumhunt, and I really feel you got on me initially for completely terrible reasons.

[chamber]

The first one, or when I was going for the lynch?

[chamber]

Sorry that I was unclear. I meant the first time I voted for AH, or one of the other 2 times when I was just padding the lynch vote and didn't really want to?

[chamber]

RF is a competent player, he has value even as a VT. WW seemed pretty useless at the time, and give his recent GD activity has reinforced that opinion.

[chamber]

And at the time I thought they were both town. (Much less so on RF now given the claims)

[chamber]

On not answering qs: I'd need to go back and look, but its not strange for me to ignore questions that I think are clutter or that specifically ask for cases.

[chamber]

Knowing what I know now would I have voted RF in that situation? Yes. But I still feel I made the right call given what I knew at the time.

[chamber]

fonz, if that is linked correctly, I have no idea what you sare saying.

[chamber]

The questions I see that I didn't answer:??????
All asking for cases, not surprised I didn't give any.

[chamber]

Post of yours that I found while looking for questions; explains why I pressured you for a claim day2 no?

[chamber]

"protected chamber" <-- Nice anti me spin you managed to put on that.

[chamber]

It being a typo of doc explains it. Without that though it suggests the RB blocked AV

TO

protect me.

[chamber]

Do you have any reason other than intuition to think that a town JK reduces the change of a Mafia RB?

[chamber]

Question2: Why did you feel the need to explicitly state all of those NOW, when all but mafia doc had previously been mentioned?

[chamber]

Thats an unlikely occurance, and only takes the mod deciding before hand how the interaction would work to handle it.

[chamber]

Hey hero, you haven't really given your reads since the claims happened, care to share?

[chamber]

Thanks for completely ignoring the 3 reads that matter the most imo atm. Give me a ranking on me RF and Rat.

[chamber]

So Im a little confused, are you calling ME scum? Or saying that me KNOWING that they have to be scum by POE is tainting my ability to read them relative to me?

[chamber]

Your point against P_R seems to assume both me and tasky are town aswell...

[chamber]

If I'm town No Lynching = Lynching me because AV will almost surely shoot me, and the mafia can just not rb there. Nice try though PR.

[chamber]

You guys should read PR in iso, its kind of funny from my pov.

[chamber]

If I was scum then it would be a possibility but it's not the ONLY one, hence negative spin. Its been sorted out though I don't see why that needed readdressing

[chamber]

fonz, are you actually reading the thread?

[chamber]

You raised a point that had already been settled?

[chamber]

What are you *twitch*ing at exactly?

[chamber]

I'd actually prefer an ordered ranking of all 4 reds, assuming they are your top 4 reads.

[chamber]

hi?

[chamber]

Vi, I speak when I have things to say. Is there anything you want to ask of me?

[chamber]

Are you honestly suggesting that I haven't been contributing? Just because I'm drawing a blank on relevant things RIGHT NOW doesn't mean I haven't been.

[chamber]

You mean where I asked Fonz a question and he ignored me? That was enough of a response in itself. He's also talked more about the reds in general since.

[chamber]

Hence the third sentence in that post.

[chamber]

Has anyone gone and looked at PR in iso like I asked?

[chamber]

I meant just PR. Maybe only I can see it because I know that I'm town.

[chamber]

If I was going to say what I saw I'd have said it, not told you to iso him.

[chamber]

RF is likely scum, but PR

is

scum. I still have a town read on RF, despite POE making it nearly impossible for him to be town. I'd rather lead with the PR lynch

[chamber]

Based on his play alone I'd still call him town, but POE looks VERY VERY bad for him.

[chamber]

When I say 'read' I mean based on his play, not things like POE.

[chamber]

Investigations would be something else I'd ignore when saying 'read'.

[chamber]

I'm town. If rayfrost is town, well played tasky. Here's to hoping that there is a tomorrow.

[chamber]

Thinking about it more, if you are town, we are probably dealing with a 2 man scum team *crosses fingers*.

[chamber]

GF + RB + Everyone has a terrible post restriction. I can see it. (Also under 2 scum no reason you or AV can't be lying). But we can worry about that if RF flips town and the game doesn't end.

[chamber]

That post also implies that the scum team is me + him + PR though, and I know that to be false.

[chamber]

Tasky had me fooled . After I got over my initial OMGUS to fonz fingering the 'reds' at the start of day 3, I was back to being pretty sure Vi was scum, and I would have pushed for his lynch over RF's day 4, but no way I was lynching Tasky over RF unless he seriously screwed up at some point. Oh well.

[chamber]

You had me fooled this time tasky, but you can only play the "I'm a moron" card once. *shakes fist*

[chamber]

There were a bunch of issues about people courting modkills in this game, but I'm actually fairly impressed with how Tasky was able to NOT look like scum while doing it.

I hadn't thought about it much sinse it was posted, but that MD topic is super sketchy when you consider that tasky was scum :/

[chamber]

I would probably not have made it if I was being called out for "pretending to do something townish".

The fact that the events in this game effected you making it at all shows that you needed to wait until the game was done :/

[chamber]

I think if I were to change the rule set:
1 I wouldn't make quotes use up characters.
2 I wouldn't allow double posting.


I think that would do nicely. The lack of quoting being reasonable turned following what was being said into hell.

I'd really like to see the QT's