I forgot to bookmark this thread, so I didn't realize it was live.
VOTE: camn
I don't care if you did it as Town. Mass nameclaiming at this point in the day is an anti-Town suggestion. Don't ever do that as Town again.
camn wrote:As if I am taking suggestions from YOU regarding what is town play.
My eye sockets cannot contain the depth of my eye rolling.
bvoigt wrote:Pine wrote:I forgot to bookmark this thread, so I didn't realize it was live.
VOTE: camn
I don't care if you did it as Town. Mass nameclaiming at this point in the day is an anti-Town suggestion. Don't ever do that as Town again.
FOS: Incognito: Weird first couple of posts, then the dice-rolling to decide who was scummier. Not liking it.
So you're not voting her for being scummy, just doing something anti-town?
UNVOTE: Haylen
VOTE: Pine
camn wrote:Hmm.
UNVOTE
VOTE: PINE
ItISa tell. "dont ever do that as Town again".
He knows I am town. He wrote that post knowing I am town. Then he voted me knowing I am town.
QED.
Magua wrote:Pine is probably town, but not as strong as Haylen.
Pine wrote:No, Yos, if there's a vig, it's gotta be Nathan. Luigi is plausible as SK, but I'm seeing the Largo family as the Mafia here. Four Mafia is a bit much for a game this size, so there's probably some internal Mafia politics, that would fit with the flavor. I just finished playing a Star Wars-themed game (on a different site) where there were more Mafia than usual, but they had Usurper mechanics in line with the Sith Rule of Two...there's a similar flavor going on with the Largo family here.
Graverobber as third party. Maybe some kind of unique mechanic to reflect stealing from the dead or Survivor. Shiloh is a VT role. Amber may be the non-Mafia Largo, she's the most self-interested and least...evil. Pavi may have some kind of mechanic related to his face-changing. Blind Mag is probably some kind of investigative role. Watcher maybe?
But yeah. I can't see Luigi Largo as Town, and certainly not as a VT.
UNVOTE: Camn <--Holy shit, I thought I unvoted a while ago.
VOTE: PeregrineV
camn wrote:I think decent scum DON'T Switch targets day 2. They stay consistent day after day.
bvoigt wrote:bvoigt wrote:Pine wrote:No, I don't think I will elaborate. I talked about Incog a while back, and he's done nothing either way to sway me. I believe in sticking with early reads and not second- and third- and fourth-guessing them unless there's a compelling reason to do so.
All I've really seen in your ISO about Incognito is that his first couple posts were "weird," and he used the dice tags to decide who to vote. Also, what happened to your suspicions of camn?
@Pine: Is this a correct summary of your Incog suspicions? What are your current thoughts on camn?