#93 High School Mafia - Day Five - GAME OVER

[thorred]

'firm

[thorred]

Oh, we've started. Sorry, I missed the bus.
I'll start with a random

vote: samadhi

.
An inexperienced scum, if they felt threatened, probably would out an experienced player. What the heck is Magic the Gathering anyway?

[thorred]

Sorry I have not been active.

I agree with Jaguar that Pbug could've voted Yaw instead of just giving
a FOS. It's early in the game and there are 6 votes needed for a lynch
so I dont see how 2 votes can be too much of a problem.

I think there's something fishy with Uraj45's last post, but I can't put
my finger on it. It's just the way he says it probably. I was about to vote for him, but then I read his first post and thought it would be stupid for a nerd to say that magic the gathering's the best if he was a nerd.

I'm in between voting for Uraj45 and Pbug, and maybe Argoti (my gut tells me). I'll sleep on it and see what happens from now until tomorrow, if I can come online tomorrow.

[thorred]

unvote samadhi

(forgot to unvote random vote)
PBug I think has cleared himself, and Uraj45 I will give the benefit of the doubt.
Melchizedek, why do you want Yaw to come out with a claim? I don't think that is necessary now. Very fishy, so

vote melchizedek

.
On the Argoti bandwagon, I won't vote yet unless he comes up with a better explanation. But i will put a

big FOS on Argoti

.
(And I'm not sure how much I should trust Talitha's scum radar, I think it's broken. )

[thorred]

Vraak has only made a few useless posts which do not tell us about what he thinks of the game so far.
I thought Uraj mentioned in the beginning an sk maybe involved, but blocked, so we would be looking out for an sk as well as scum. (If that's what you do if there is sk, I haven't yet played in one where there is). I agree with what others have said about him being suspicious.

These are some other points that have seemed a little suspicious to me:
- I find it hard to understand BadAndie's reaction to Yaw voting her to start bandwagon.
-maybe I'm reading oo much into this, but on rereading the thread, it seemed that Melchizedek was trying to put people off voting BA (when Yaw was trying to start bandwagon).

For now, I will

vote Vraak

and put an

fos on Uraj45

.

And I'd really like to know why you are looking closely at me.
The reason I had not posted much is because I had other commitments, and now there is pressure from college too. Don't be surprised if I disppear, it'll just be because I've failed and been exiled.

[thorred]

Just thought I'd pop in and say howdy.

However, Uraj45's actions do cry "classic scum".

So do yours. Vote stands.

[thorred]

Sorry about your grandfather, condolences to the family, Yaw.

If Uraj45 has a pro-town role (not scum), he's probably going to be the most likely target at night. Should we get him to come out with some info before we decide on a lynch?

It's going to be really hard for me to post till 1 April, I really need to sleep. Just to let you know.

[thorred]

I agree, Uraj. Good situation for the town.
I believe Uraj's claim. And Badandie's reason for voting Uraj does not convince me at all. And somehow Badandie avoided voting Vraak, just like Vraak avoided voting Argoti.
I was suspicious of melch, but looking back at the last few pages, BadAndie seems the most scummie. I'll read through again to make sure, then vote.

[thorred]

Well, I just reread the whole game, and found that BadAndie I don't think is scum, because of her tiff with Argoti. Jaguar immediately jumped on me, Uraj and Vraak X in the new day. Would she have needed to do that if she was scum? I'm not sure. Melch I think is most scummy, just for that killing Talitha thing. He hasn't said much else in the game, then he comes up with that.

And Talitha just made me more confused. Now I think everyone's scum.

To add a little pressure, I'll add a second

vote on Jaguar

, and I nearly forgot to

FOS Melchizedek

.

[thorred]

No-one at school??
Not much has happened since my last post, and I have nothing to add. But where is everyone?

[thorred]

A lot of roleclaims. I tried to come up with some action we could take.

unvote jaguar

We vote either Melch or Badandie.
If Jaguar investigates Uraj tonight, and survives the night, we look at her results. If Uraj is not town, we can lynch him tomorrow.
If she dies we know the truth. If there is another doc, doc protects Jaguar.
I don't know if this is going to work. Seems to be lots of holes in it, can anyone help?
And we have to fit Tal in there somehow.

How possible is it that there are two mafia left?

'night.

[thorred]

I'm willing to vote Melch today, if everyone agrees. And if there is a backup doc, we'll get him/her to claim tomorrow. Uraj could target someone, of course not Melch or Tal. Samadhi, who'd you rather vote?

Or maybe we should just lynch Melch and do roleclaims tomorrow.

I agree.

Whats a vanilla townie?

[thorred]

I just realised BadAndie is the only townie not a cheerleader or jock. I find it a bit strange.

[thorred]

Wow, Talitha, you were good. Had me completely fooled.
vIQles, I really think you did a good job modding, made it more interesting than some other games I've played.