Mini 472 - Cartman Mafia - Game Over

[Earwig]

FOS:DeanWinchester, Estes

both have posted without actually posting :/ i consider that slightly scummy.

Dude, it's d1, 1st couple of pages - you're supposed to post w/o really posting.

Random vote

Vote: J-man

There...

[Earwig]

unvote, vote: Earwig

for placing a 3rd vote on J-man and trying to pass it off as random

I hadn't noticed that - sorry.

Unvote: J-Man

[Earwig]

So, was it indeed a random vote? Or did you just call it random when it was really a "for the heck of it" vote?

Completely random bro.

[Earwig]

…………I am tempted to switch my vote, but earwig is not only "very shady", he is extremely shady for his vote on j-man and then the apology right after....

It was a compleyely random vote - simple as that. I should have checked votes first, but I didn't - again, simple as that. That was the reason for the apology, other than trying NOT to be rude.

[Earwig]

Several times so far, I've seen it said that my first post was "very shady", and I'd swear that I saw someone say it was "extremely suspicious", but I can't seem to locate that post right now. I can't see how placing a random vote on someone could be considered "very shady", even though it was the third vote. I've explained this already, but my vote truly was random. There hadn't been a vote count yet, and I hadn't gone through and done one myself. I've also heard it mentioned I'm acting paranoid. I can't help that - I'm paranoid by nature. Also, I try hard not to offend anyone - that's the reason I appologized. I am going to take Ryan's advice to heart though - give an explanation, then move on, no appology needed. I've got some suspicions, that I will post separately.

[Earwig]

I really have to wonder why ryan is so eager to put, and keep, Zeek on the town list.

…..

Scum List

Off the Mark
DeanWinchester
Earwig

Not Sure

J-Man
ChaosOmega
SorintheSeeker
GatorGuy

Townies

Estes
Me
ZeekLTK…..

My group of three:

Ryan
estes
zeek

Zeek because ryan put him in the town category for no real reason. I understand if ryan is a competent player he would do this also, but i'm not getting a smart vibe from him.

What reason is there to put Zeek in the scum category? And what reason have I given you to put me in the scum three? I mean you want to talk about no reasoning, your post screams that.

He tries to explain his reasoning here:

……..

As far as Zeek is concerned, I believe he's made valid arguments so far, called out scummy behavior and played pro town. Granted, we are only 5 pages in so that can change, but so far I haven't seen anything scummy, so I put him in the town slot so far.

Not quite enough for me to vote yet, but

FoS: ryan

@ZeekLTK: IGMEOY means I've Got My Eye On You.

[Earwig]

I didn't say I thought Zeek was scummier, I said I had to wonder why you (ryan) were so eager to keep someone (anyone for that matter) on a town list. You (ryan) even seemed a little steamed when someone else had Zeek on their scum list.

[Earwig]

…………

What reason is there to put Zeek in the scum category?

(bold here added by earwig)And what reason have I given you to put me in the scum three? I mean you want to talk about no reasoning, your post screams that.

….

I believe I've stated already that Zeek is on my town list for now. I never KEEP somebody on a certain part of my list as players change behaviors and I do as well with my thoughts on them, I have to wonder why you, the three people I've fingered as scum have deflected to Zeek being scummier, very interesting. Having you all three think Zeek was scummier (and one even placing a vote) I find very opportunistic, definetly makes me believe that one of you three is scum

Upset might be a little strong. Concerned might be a better term to use here. I was wondering why you cared that someone had put Zeek on their scum list.[/b]

[Earwig]

fair enough, for now.

[Earwig]

Vote:Gatorguy91

Could you explain?

I think we'd all like to hear some content from you. Suspicions? Opinions? Thoughts? You asked for Dean to respond to one of your questions (which I believe he did) and we haven't really heard anything from you since.

I believe I'd like to hear from you too.

[Earwig]

I would like an official vote count before I vote. Also, I don't appreciate ANYONE trying to bully ANYONE, J-Man