Mini 1693: Fire vs Ice Mafia(End Date: 7/19/15)

[Netherspite]

^^^Scumclaim.


Who are you people?

If it was a scumclaim why no vote bra?
VOTE: Brain

Here is your vote

VOTE: They call me R

[Netherspite]

whos up for a mass claim?

I thought about it but we don't know what the setup is and it will be hard to distinguish lie from truth.

[Netherspite]

whos up for a mass claim?

Actually since wincon is about ice/fire elimination the setup can even consist of ice/fire townies only. Or there can be both fire and ice townies and mafia.
in both of these cases mass claiming won't make sense.

[Netherspite]

You really should read the thread.

Except I did ?

[Netherspite]

GG WP Brain is scum. 1st page - personal record.
@All - Sheep me to victory.

@Ika - lets wait until page 2. Its too early now.

Care to explain?

[Netherspite]

You really should read the thread.

Except I did ?

If you had (and had a basic level of reading comprehension), you wouldn't have said what you said.

Try again?

Care pointing at the exact post that my setup spec contradicts with ?

[Netherspite]

Look now. Brain is scum. Just... sheep bro.
Also where are you fromm

English is not my native language if that's what you want to know.

[Netherspite]

Country bro. Also a vote with me would be appreciated. ;3

Pedit: Just a tip. Placing your vote somewhere even early on is, well, useful, at least more useful than keeping it to yourself. So hop on my Brain wagon and lets lead the first scum lynch together *bro fist*

Bulgaria. I'm not Bulgarian tho.

I won't hop onto his wagon until I'll be thinking that he's scum myself. First of all I'd lIke to hear his comments on your case.

[Netherspite]

You win if all Fire members are eliminated.

whos up for a mass claim?

Actually since wincon is about ice/fire elimination the setup can even consist of ice/fire townies only.

Or there can be both fire and ice townies and mafia.

in both of these cases mass claiming won't make sense.

Here you go.


VOTE: Netherspite because he's probably scum trying to derail town's scumhunting efforts with this type of stuff.

How does that exclude the possibility of having fire townies in the setup? That's just a sample.

[Netherspite]

I am from Bulgaria too :3

Really? The world is small indeed

[Netherspite]

My thoughts? He's weird. Not necessarily scummy weird. I want to hear more from him to decide.

[Netherspite]

@Dean Harper

@Prolapsed Brain

There can be different wincons in different townie role PMs.
Also, it looks like we have a scumslip here from

Dean Harper

. You say we can't know if that was the real wincon sent in townie role PMs thus you didn't get townie role PM?

VOTE: Dean Harper

[Netherspite]

By the way, I don't see the reason why can't I just ask out loud:

If there is a townie with wincon different from the sample wincon in the first post, please tell us that you do exist.

[Netherspite]

However please avoid quoting or paraphrasing your role PM as it is prohibited by the rules.

[Netherspite]

@Prolapsed Brain

This is closed setup with bastard modding. Why can't we have such things? It's possible.
In my #63 I'm trying to find out if this is the case or not.

[Netherspite]

No. You said that we can't know whether this wincon was sent in town role PMs. You can't know that only if you're either not townie or got other wincon PM. Which of the two is correct?

[Netherspite]

If you're scum - why not? Please do claim
If you're townie and have a different wincon then you claiming will have a good effect on the town as well.

[Netherspite]

We can hammer at any time.
I'd rather first wait for the prods to the inactive players.
We have only 10 (!) players in the Activity Overview with one of them having 1 post and one of them being the Mod out of 12 players total.
So 4 players posted zero to one posts total.

[Netherspite]

Gj derphammering. So much contributing.

[Netherspite]

Ignore last post. That's not a hammer. Need to sleep more...

[Netherspite]

Still not hammered.

Mod, can you send out prods please?

[Netherspite]

Even if you have an ability to place 2 votes instead of one, it is still not a hammer.

[Netherspite]

You're lying anyway.

[Netherspite]

I hope now we will finally get prods on the absent players.
This activity makes me sad.

[Netherspite]

Brian is town. dean harper looks kinda scummy but not scummy enough for me to put him onto L-1.

We're just 5 days from the deadline or so.
I think we'll soon have to lynch someone.
Who would you prefer?

[Netherspite]

@Kari

Noone meant to offend you really.
I just guess that everyone thinks that joining a mod Q is a good idea only if you really have time to mod a game.

[Netherspite]

Well, since

Dean Harper

is not posting after I caught him on his slip, I assume that's a scumclaim and he doesn't want to provide any associative tells.

Prolapsed Brain

is weird but not neccessary scummy weird. I'd prefer to hear from him more.

DragonTyrion

is strange in that he doesn't want to vote caught scum. He explains it by stating that his scumread is voting him but honestly I don't get this kind of reasons for not voting someone.

Others are pretty much in shadows. I'd like to hear some more reads from everyone before we hammer

Dean Harper

.

[Netherspite]

@They call me R

So your only read is a scumread on

DeanHarper

?

[Netherspite]

@They call me R

Any townreads?

[Netherspite]

Okay.

Others who still care about this game please post your main reads as well.

[Netherspite]

Provided my scumreads here.

Slight townreads so far are on you and

hiplop

.

[Netherspite]

VOTE: DragonTyrion

[Netherspite]

I'd say there is a vig.
Why Dragon Tyrion guys?

Cause he attempted to chainsaw def his partner

Dean Harper

.

[Netherspite]

Right, because my issues with hiplop aren't valid at all.

I just didn't find Dean Harper all that scummy. I townread him, so I didn't vote for him. I don't see your "chainsaw defense"

You've attacked hiplop because he pushed your scumpartner.
That's canonical definition of the chainsaw defense.

[Netherspite]

Go back and read my iso.

Fine. You asked for it.

---

I didn't even mention Dean Harper.

That's just a straight lie:

Spoiler: Quotes

I rather like Dean's posts so far.

This is why I don't want to vote Dean Harper.

Why are you voting him?

---

While you're at it, please refute my points against hiplop, because there ain't nobody even caring that literally all he does is parrot other peoples' cases, then "oh you voted me? K you're scum"

The fact that his scumhunting ain't good doesn't change the fact that you started attacking him immediately after he pushed

Dean Harper

:

Spoiler: Quotes

I think I agree that dean made a scum slip. Mine says the op.

Coaching and slipping at page 3

UNVOTE:
VOTE: hiplop

Coasting. Calls scum, waits for others to make a case, and then parrots it. Throws in a not-so-subtle town claim for no reason whatsoever.

Zero contribution.

You just picked someone who you can attack of those who pushed your scumpartner and started doing so. Thus you do look scummy while his behavior may well be explained by the lack of experience.

[Netherspite]

btw, i REALLY dont think it was a vig that killed dean

Why?

[Netherspite]

There's a distinction between attacking someone in order to defend someone, and attacking someone because they seem scummy.

I attacked hiplop because he seemed scummy. End of story.

That's your word.
I don't believe it.

[Netherspite]

im so lost

what just happened?

Summary:

Flames682

didn't post for a while and got modkilled.
He flipped fire member.

Dean Harper

was pushed yesterday by me,

hiplop

and

They call me R

for scumslip and other things; protected by

DragonTyrion

with a kind of chainsaw defense.
He was killed at night and flipped fire member.

We now push him for being

Dean Harper

's buddy and he is trying to defend himself.

[Netherspite]

cool summary.

so i have one quesiotn remianing: mass claim or no?

Your opinion?

[Netherspite]

There is old good popcorn method.

[Netherspite]

Read his post. Carefully.

Hmm care explaining for the dumb ones?
I still don't get it.

[Netherspite]

I'd still like

Prolapsed Brain

to explain what's wrong with

ika

's post.
He seemed really sure and I don't get it.

[Netherspite]

@Mod

Can you explain what the setup was now? I'm still kinda confused.

[Netherspite]

There were 3 scum.

[Netherspite]

@ika

Your slip wasn't really a slip imo.
Someone even pointed it out during the game and I still didn't consider it a slip.
You played well.