Mini 1712: Clue Master Detectives Mafia II - Game Over

[Storyteller]

CLUE MASTER DETECTIVES MAFIA

Based on the board game Clue Master Detective, this is a semi-open mini themed game with 10 characters, 8 items and 12 rooms. It involves a mechanic of moving through rooms finding items and using them to help solve the case. Be careful though, some of the guests might use the items to remove you from the game. Use every clue at your disposal to solve who the murderers are. This game has unusual mechanics so it is required to have completed one game.

Player List

shos
farside22
Schrödinger Mislynch (Titus and Varsoon)
Toogeloo
pirate mollie
Metal Sonic

Frozone (Cheetory6 and notscience)

Cheetory6

Gammagooey
Kmd4390
Untrod Tripod

BlueBloodedToffee

hiplop

Pieces in play:

Spoiler: Alive

shos
Toogeloo
Frozone
Kmd4390
Untrod Tripod

Pieces removed from Play:

Spoiler: Dead

DEAD: Schrödinger Mislynch (

Colonel Mustard

,

Town

)
DEAD: pirate mollie (

Profesor Plum

,

Town

)
DEAD: Hiplop(

Mr. Green

,

Town

)
DEAD: Gammagooey (

Madame Rose

,

Town

)
DEAD: Farside22(

Monsieur Brunette

,

Town

)[/spoiler]

Pieces removed, squished, broken and shredded:

Spoiler: Modkilled

Spare Pieces:

Spoiler: Replacements

Untrod Tripod

[Storyteller]

Characters:

Each player is randomly assigned a character. The alignment of the player is also randomly assigned.

• Miss Scarlet
  (Red)
  
• Colonel Mustard
  (Yellow)
  
• Mrs. White
  (White)
  
• Mr. Green
  (Green)
  
• Mrs. Peacock
  (Blue)
  
• Professor Plum
  (Purple)
  
• Miss Peach
  (Orange)
  
• Monsieur Brunette
  (Brown)
  
• Madame Rose
  (Pink)
  
• Sergeant Grey
  (Gray)

Items:

• At the beginning of the game all items are randomly distributed throughout the mansion.
  
• As players enter rooms they will pick up the item that is in the room if they currently are not holding an item.
  
• If several players enter a room with an item at the same time, the item will go to just one player selected randomly.
  
• There will only be at most one (1) item per room.
  
• Each item has a unique use that can be used on any player in an adjacent room and current room unless otherwise specified.
  
• When using an item you can target a player or a room. If the targeted player is outside the range of the item, then the action will fail. If the targeted room has several players, the targeted player is selected randomly.
  
• Each night the player must choose to
  use
  ,
  hold
  or
  drop
  the item.
  
• Failure to submit an action will result in the item being drop.
  
• The player cannot hold more than one item at a time.
  
• The player cannot hold an item for more than two(2) days. On the second night in possession of the item, the player must use or drop the item.
  
• Once an item is dropped or used they will appear on a random room.
  
• The players use the items before dying.
  
• When the player dies the item is automatically dropped.
  
• Items that are not picked up will remain in their respective rooms over the course of the night.
  
• These are the following items:
  
  • Candlestick
    
  • Dagger
    
  • Lead Pipe
    
  • Revolver
    
  • Rope
    
  • Wrench
    
  • Poison
    
  • Horseshoe

Rooms:

Click for larger image.

• Every night a player must choose a room to move too.
  
• A player can only move to an adjacent room.
  
• A player cannot remain in a room. Failure to submit a movement, will randomly select the next room for the player.
  
• All actions are resolved prior to moving to another room.
  
  
• Any identified mistakes will be reported publicly without detail in the thread and players will continue as if their movement was valid. Do not attempt to exploit this rule.
  
• The Rooms and Adjacency:

Room	Adjacent Rooms
Kitchen	Dining Room, Trophy Room, ♟Library
Dinning Room	Kitchen, Drawing Room
Drawing Room	Dining Room, Courtyard, ♟Conservatory
Courtyard	Drawing Room, Gazebo, Fountain, Library, ♟Carriage Room
Gazebo	Courtyard
Fountain	Courtyard
Library	Courtyard, Billiard Room, ♟Kitchen
Billiard Room	Library, Studio
Studio	Billiard Room, Conservatory
Conservatory	Studio, Trophy Room, ♟Drawing Room
Trophy Room	Conservatory, Carriage House, Kitchen
Carriage house	Trophy Room, ♟Courtyard
Cloak Room	This room is off limits.

♟Secret Passages

Mafia:

• There are two players randomly selected as mafia.
  
• Mafia are required to find an Item in order to perform a kill.
  
• Mafia can only make one kill per night.
  
• Mafia are forced to kill every other night. If they choose to not kill or cannot kill during a night, the next night in which they can kill, they are forced to make the kill, as long as they have an item.
  
• The kill will use the item as a weapon and can only be used in adjacent rooms and current room.
  
• Mafia can opt to use the item as intended, instead of making the kill.
  
• Mafia always knows where everyone in the game is. As all killers do.
  
• Mafia can talk at any time day or night as long as they are alive.
  
• Mafia share a two time use power that allows the user to move to any room they wish at any point in the game.
  
• Mafia share a one time use power that allows the user to pick up any item not in possession selected randomly at any point in the game.
  
• Mafia is limited to the same movement limitations as town, with the exception of using the above mentioned power.
  
• Mafia can only kill a player in an Adjacent Room or Current Room, unless otherwise specified by the item.
  
• Mafia may or may not have other rules and privileges not expressed here.

Voting:

• Votes are used to Lynch players during the day. When a player gains a majority of the votes, half of the players plus one, then that player is lynched and removed from the game board.
  
• Vote in
  bold
  or use the
  VOTE:
  tags.
  
• Unvotes are not necessary but may help.
  
• No lynch votes follow the same majority rule as any player.
  
• Place votes on new lines. Although I allow inline votes, I do not guarantee that I will see it.

Rules:

• Do not talk about the game outside the thread, unless your roles specifically allows it.
  
• Prods will be issued to players if they have not posted within a 48-hour period. Players who have been prodded have 24 hours to respond in the game thread before a replacement is sought. Saturday and Sunday will be considered a 24-hour period.
  
• When you are pressured to reveal your role, do not copy my message. Use your own words. Do not quote anything I send to you.
  
• Ask me questions if anything is unclear.
  
• I am absolutely infallible. But I occasionally make intentional mistakes just to make sure if you players are paying attention. If you find a mistake point it out so that it can be corrected appropriately.
  
• Have fun. It is a game, and I expect courteous and mature behavior. Mafia is not a game to win, it is a game to enjoy.
  
• Do not edit the content of your posts. It is not fair if you post something that some people get to see and other don't.
  
• Do not use this formatting:
  This is me commenting.
  
  
• Actions not received will follow the following protocol: Items will be dropped, if possible the player will move to a random adjacent room.
  
• Actions may be submitted ahead of time and can be changed as many times as desired; at deadline, the last action that was submitted will be used. Actions may be submitted via PM.
  
• I reserve the right to add or alter any rule in the game including the rules herein.
  
• Any situations not covered above will be handled on an individual basis.

Deadlines:

• Days will be at least 21 days (3 weeks) long. It may be longer depending on my schedule and weekends.
  
• Nights will be at least 2 days long. It may be longer depending on my schedule and weekends.
  
• If a day deadline has been reached and I am not around, the day will continue until I stop it. Don't assume that this will happen though.
  
• Twilight is defined as the moment in which the hammer vote is cast until the game is stopped. During this time, you are allowed to continue talking, but any votes or unvotes cast during this time will not count towards the vote counts.

Win Conditions:

• Town wins when all threats to town have been eliminated.
  
• Mafia wins when all town members are dead or nothing can prevent otherwise.
  
• In the event that there are equal number of town members and mafia members at day break, mafia will automatically win, regardless of what items are in possession.

Confirmation and Night 0:

• Please confirm your role by PM.
  
• During Night 0, you have to perform an action, if possible, and make a move.
  
• Confirmation will last 48 hours or until 8 of the players confirm.
  
• If you do not confirm after 48 hours, you will be prodded. After being prodded you will have 24 hours to respond or be replaced.

Additional Information:

• This game has been run before here.
  
• If you were a player in the last game, be sure to reread the rules and guidelines as they may have changed since last time.
  
• If you wish to
  replace
  into the game, PM me and I will add you to the replacement wait list.
  
• There is a lobby for this game, all dead go there and any player that wishes to
  spectate
  can request access to the lobby. Once you are a spectator, you can no longer play in the game.

Invitation

Dear

___________

,

It will be to your advantage to be present on this date at Tudor Mansion, Hampshire, England because a Mr. Boddy will bring to an end a certain long-standing confidential and painful financial liability.

Please RSVP.

A Friend.

P.S.:

Town

.

INVITATION

Dear

_____________

,

It will be to your advantage to be present on this date at Tudor Mansion, Hampshire, England because a Mr. Boddy will bring to an end a certain long-standing confidential and painful financial liability.

Please RSVP.

A Friend.

P.S.: I have a special job for you. I wish that each and every guest to Tudor Mansion be eliminated. I want you to do the job. Since you are a professional goon from the

Mafia

, it should be easy. You will be partnered with __________, and you can coordinate your plans using this method day or night. Eliminate everyone and you will be rewarded. Your specific instructions will be sent after you confirm.

[Storyteller]

All roles have been sent, please confirm via PM.

I apologize for the delay but I have a hurricane Erika in my backyard, which had nothing to do with the delay, that was due because I was busy doing something else.

I advice that you read the rules thoroughly. Night 0 will start when at least 8 have confirmed or 48 hours have passed, whichever comes first.

If you are interested in Spectating or Replacing in, feel free to PM me.

[Storyteller]

Good evening everybody to Tudor Mansion. I will be your butler: Wadsworth. Feel free to meet the rest of the Guest:

Miss Scarlet

(Red)

Colonel Mustard

(Yellow)

Mrs. White

(White)

Mr. Green

(Green)

Mrs. Peacock

(Blue)

Professor Plum

(Purple)

Miss Peach

(Orange)

Monsieur Brunette

(Brown)

Madame Rose

(Pink)

Sergeant Gray

(Gray)

I believe everybody has received a letter inviting you here. I was also invited here and told to be your host and accompany you in the evening. I am a butler you see and I will do what I do best, butlering.

*Doorbell rings*

Ah, Mr. Boddy has arrived. Please wait here while I go get him.

You lockin' me in? I'll take the key.

Over my dead body, sir. May I take your bag?

No. I'll leave it here 'til I need it.

It contains evidence, I presume?

Surprises, my friend. That's what it contains--surprises!

*Wadsworth and another man enter the room*

Ladies and gentlemen, may I present Mr. Boddy.

What are they all doin' here?

Sir they are here to resolve some business as per the letter we all received.

*Lightning flashes illuminating the house*
*At the same time, the light goes out.*

Oh dear. Please excuse me, I'll go fix the lights in a jiffy. Feel free to go to your designated rooms. I will call for you when the Lights are fixed.

[Storyteller]

It is Night 0!

You will receive shortly your initial position (randomly) from which you can select an adjacent room to move to per the rules.

Please make sure you understand the rules and if you have any question feel free to ask me at any time.

Night 0 will last at least 48 hours.

[Storyteller]

Night 0 Deadline is due in:

(expired on 2015-08-31 09:30:00)

[Storyteller]

Deadline is extended 4 hours. I currently have no ability to start the day until then.

To avoid confusion, no player will die night 0. I thought it was in the rules but must have missed it. So. I'll update that today.

[Storyteller]

DEAD

Found strangled in the cloak room.

This is terrible, this is absolutely terrible. This is not what I intended.

*Wadsworth Walks around impatiently.*

I invited you here, it was all my idea. And now Mr. Boddy is dead.

Each and everyone of you have been blackmailed by Mr. Boddy. I am not going to go into details about the blackmails. All I intended was for all the blackmail to end. Mr. Boddy here was blackmailing everyone here. I thought that by bringing you all here, confronting him will cease all blackmails.

I will lock the cloak room to make sure nobody tampers with the body of Mr. Boddy.

*Goes to lock the cloak room.*

One of you is the murderer. I know because there is nobody else in this house. We cannot leave until we figure out who the murderer is. Lets Discuss this like civilized people.

Day 1 Begins: Deadline Monday, September 21, 2013, 03:30 pm UCT -4

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.00

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(0):
Schrödinger Mislynch(0):
Toogeloo(0):
pirate mollie(0):
Cheetory6(0):
Gammagooey(0):
Kmd4390(0):
BlueBloodedToffee(0):
hiplop(0):

Not voting (10): shos, farside22, Schrödinger Mislynch, Toogeloo, pirate mollie, Cheetory6, Gammagooey, Kmd4390, BlueBloodedToffee, hiplop

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.01

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (0):
farside22 (1):

Kmd4390

Schrödinger Mislynch (2):

pirate mollie, BlueBloodedToffee

Toogeloo (0):
pirate mollie (0):
Cheetory6 (1):

Gammagooey

Gammagooey (1):

farside22

Kmd4390 (0):

BlueBloodedToffee (3):

Toogeloo, hiplop, Schrödinger Mislynch

hiplop (0):

Not voting (2): shos, Cheetory6

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

Mod, is this game exactly the same as the last Clue game or is it possible that changes have been made?

I've made some changes but not many, and those are in the rules. If I've missed something, that would likely be clarified as it comes up.

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.02

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (0):
farside22 (1):

Kmd4390

Schrödinger Mislynch (2):

pirate mollie, BlueBloodedToffee

Toogeloo (0):
pirate mollie (1):

Schrödinger Mislynch

Cheetory6 (1):

Gammagooey

Gammagooey (1):

farside22

Kmd4390 (0):

BlueBloodedToffee (2):

Toogeloo, hiplop

hiplop (0):

Not voting (2): shos, Cheetory6

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.03

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (2):

Gammagooey, hiplop

farside22 (0):
Schrödinger Mislynch (1):

pirate mollie

Toogeloo (0):
pirate mollie (1):

Schrödinger Mislynch

Cheetory6 (0):
Gammagooey (1):

farside22

Kmd4390 (0):
BlueBloodedToffee (1):

Toogeloo

hiplop (3):

Kmd4390, shos, BlueBloodedToffee

Not voting (1): Cheetory6

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.04

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (0):
farside22 (0):
Schrödinger Mislynch (3):

hiplop, pirate mollie, farside22

Toogeloo (0):
pirate mollie (0):
Cheetory6 (0):
Gammagooey (0):
Kmd4390 (0):
BlueBloodedToffee (1):

Toogeloo

hiplop (4):

Kmd4390, shos, Schrödinger Mislynch, BlueBloodedToffee

Not voting (2): Cheetory6, Gammagooey

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.05

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (0):
farside22 (0):

Schrödinger Mislynch (3):

hiplop, pirate mollie, farside22

Toogeloo (1):

shos

pirate mollie (0):
Cheetory6 (0):
Gammagooey (0):
Kmd4390 (0):
BlueBloodedToffee (1):

Toogeloo

hiplop (2):

Kmd4390, BlueBloodedToffee

Not voting (3): Schrödinger Mislynch, Cheetory6, Gammagooey

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.06

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (0):
farside22 (0):

Schrödinger Mislynch (4):

hiplop, pirate mollie, farside22, Gammagooey

Toogeloo (1):

shos

pirate mollie (0):
Cheetory6 (0):
Gammagooey (1):

Schrödinger Mislynch

Kmd4390 (0):
BlueBloodedToffee (1):

Toogeloo

hiplop (2):

Kmd4390, BlueBloodedToffee

Not voting (1): Cheetory6

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

@All, I do analysis for a living. That means no brain by Proxy. Determine the edges and work backwards. I concur with Varsoon in saying that y'all are being dumb. Disagreement with convention by novel thought is not scummy. Frankly, it is being treated like that here.

Whatever you do, don't touch shos Farside Toog kmd or Cheetory. Lynch Titus then win out.

If your are going to slip out of your Hydra, be sure to quote yourself as soon as possible.

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.07

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (0):
farside22 (0):

Schrödinger Mislynch (4):

hiplop, farside22, Gammagooey, pirate mollie

Toogeloo (1):

shos

pirate mollie (0):
Cheetory6 (0):
Gammagooey (0):
Kmd4390 (0):
BlueBloodedToffee (2):

Toogeloo, Schrödinger Mislynch

hiplop (1):

Kmd4390

Not voting (2): Cheetory6, BlueBloodedToffee

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.08

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (0):
farside22 (0):

Schrödinger Mislynch (4):

hiplop, farside22, Gammagooey, pirate mollie

Toogeloo (0):
pirate mollie (0):
Cheetory6 (0):
Gammagooey (0):
Kmd4390 (0):
BlueBloodedToffee (2):

Toogeloo, Schrödinger Mislynch

hiplop (1):

Kmd4390

Not voting (3): shos, Cheetory6, BlueBloodedToffee

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

Cheetory6

will be replaced.

Frozone

(hydra of Cheetory6 and notscience) will replace Cheetory6

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.09

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (0):
farside22 (0):

Schrödinger Mislynch (4):

hiplop, farside22, Gammagooey, pirate mollie

Toogeloo (0):
pirate mollie (0):
Frozone(0):
Gammagooey (0):
Kmd4390 (0):
BlueBloodedToffee (2):

Toogeloo, Schrödinger Mislynch

hiplop (2):

Kmd4390, shos

Not voting (2): Frozone, BlueBloodedToffee

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.10

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (0):
farside22 (0):

Schrödinger Mislynch (4):

hiplop, farside22, Gammagooey, pirate mollie

Toogeloo (0):
pirate mollie (0):
Frozone(0):
Gammagooey (1):

Schrödinger Mislynch

Kmd4390 (0):
BlueBloodedToffee (0):
hiplop (2):

Kmd4390, shos

Not voting (3): Toogeloo, Frozone, BlueBloodedToffee

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-09-21 03:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 1.11

With 10 alive it's 6 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos (0):
farside22 (0):

Schrödinger Mislynch (6):

hiplop, farside22, Gammagooey, pirate mollie, Frozone, BlueBloodedToffee

Toogeloo (0):
pirate mollie (0):
Frozone(0):
Gammagooey (0):
Kmd4390 (0):
BlueBloodedToffee (0):
hiplop (3):

Kmd4390, shos, Schrödinger Mislynch

Not voting (1): Toogeloo

A lynch has been reached.

Schrödinger Mislynch wave function has collapsed.

[Storyteller]

*Everybody corners Colonel Mustard*

I'm pretty sure he is the murderer.

Are you sure? He doesn't look suspicious to me.

We'll he is, and that's that.

Well, I completely agree.

You bastards #$%%$#, you are getting the wrong man.

Such foul mouth, he most defenetily must be the murderer.

I say we get rid of him.

Gentlemen, let's not get riled up. I have already called the cops but it will take a while for them to get here.

So what do we do with this?

Have more respect. I am a model colonel.

Let's gag him and tie him before he goes Pirate of Penzance on us.

I'll tell you what! Lock him in the cloak Room.

*Everybody grabbed Colonel Mustard and tied him up.*

*Then they dragged Him down the hall.*

*When they got to the cloak room. Sudenly, they found out that Colonel Mustard was dead.*

Ahhhh!

Well, somebody killed him as we dragged him here. Unfortunately I can't seem to guess how that happened. Anyways, we need to spread the up and find clues. Each one can return the rooms we were all before and start our search there. Good luck.

But isn't that how people die.

Don't be silly that's just in the movies.

DEAD: Schrödinger Mislynch (

Colonel Mustard

,

Town

)

Lynched in the Gazebo.

---

Night 1 Starts

Submit your actions and movements by Monday, September 14 2015, 10:30 am UTC -4 ((expired on 2015-09-14 10:30:00))

[Storyteller]

Notice:

1. I was under the impression that the rules were very clear that a player must Hold, Use or Drop an Item else, the player will automatically drop it. That's what I get for copy pasting old games. I will slightly modify the rules so that it is clear that all players have to submit an action with their items, If they do not then the item will be dropped. This is to avoid ambiguous situations. I have notified any player of this during Night 1 but not during Night 0. From now on I will notify any player that forgets to submit an action for their items, but they have until deadline to fix it, or else I will assume that they drop the item.

2.

New rule:

If a player accidentally requests to move to a new room that is not adjacent to the original room, or the movement violates some mechanic in the game, I will notify the problem to the player, and they have until deadline to fix it or else they will be moved randomly to another room. I try to check early, but most of the time I process this late in the deadline and would usually not give enough time to reply, so make sure to check your movements. If I don't catch the error and process the data, then the error will remain in play as if the player was allowed to perform the movement. DO NOT attempt to exploit this. I always check adjacency, but rarely I miss some, especially early in the game when there are more players. If I discover that it was intentional, then the player will be force replaced. If I or a player identifies the error, the affected player would be notified and I will announce that an error of this nature happened in thread without mentioning any details. If the error directly influences the game, (IE, You are scum because you skipped a room.) I will intervene to mention that the player was involved in this mistake at the discretion of the affected player. The affected player can request to be stated publicly as the object of this mistake at any point in the game, even after death. This is to avoid other players to claim having being affected by a mistake that did not affect them.

That said:

!A movement error has been identified!

The game day will start shortly.

[Storyteller]

DEAD: pirate mollie (

Profesor Plum

,

Town

)

Found dead by excessive force to the back of the head in the kitchen.

Oh no! A tragedy has happened. Profesore Plum is dead.

I knew that people die when splitting up.

He will surely be missed.

The problem is that who ever did this, didn't leave anything behind. We better get to the bottom of this.

Yes! Let's Lynch Colonel Mustard.

He's already dead.

Well, it seems that we got some time to figure out who did this.

Day 1 Begins: Deadline Monday, October 5, 2015, 03:30 pm UCT -4

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 2.00

With 8 alive it's 5 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(0):
Toogeloo(0):
Cheetory6(0):
Gammagooey(0):
Kmd4390(0):
BlueBloodedToffee(0):
hiplop(0):

Not voting (10): shos, farside22, Toogeloo, Cheetory6, Gammagooey, Kmd4390, BlueBloodedToffee, hiplop

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-05 15:30:00)

[Storyteller]

!A movement error has been identified!

Is this going to screw up room claims?

It shouldn't

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 2.01

With 8 alive it's 5 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(1):

hiplop

Toogeloo(0):
Cheetory6(0):
Gammagooey(0):
Kmd4390(0):
BlueBloodedToffee(1):

Toogeloo

hiplop(4):

Kmd4390, farside22, shos, BlueBloodedToffee

Not voting (2): Cheetory6, Gammagooey

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-05 15:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 2.02

With 8 alive it's 5 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(0):

Toogeloo(3):

BlueBloodedToffee, Gammagooey, hiplop

Frozone(0):
Gammagooey(0):
Kmd4390(0):
BlueBloodedToffee(2):

Toogeloo, shos

hiplop(2):

Kmd4390, farside22

Not voting (1): Cheetory6

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-05 15:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 2.02

With 8 alive it's 5 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(1):

BlueBloodedToffee

Toogeloo(0):
Frozone(1):

Gammagooey

Gammagooey(0):
Kmd4390(0):

BlueBloodedToffee(4):

shos, hiplop, farside22, Toogeloo

hiplop(1):

Kmd4390

Not voting (1): Cheetory6

KMD VLA until Tuesday
Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-05 15:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 2.04

With 8 alive it's 5 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(0):
Toogeloo(0):
Frozone(1):

Gammagooey

Gammagooey(1):

Frozone

Kmd4390(0):

BlueBloodedToffee(3):

shos, hiplop, Toogeloo

hiplop(3):

Kmd4390, farside22, BlueBloodedToffee

Not voting (0):

KMD VLA until Tuesday
Farside Goes VLA until Now or Wednesday
Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-05 15:30:00)

[Storyteller]

Prodding Storyteller

JERK!

[Storyteller]

I don't think I've ever voted gamma this game.

~Fixed!

[Storyteller]

Looking for a replacement for BBT.

[Storyteller]

untrod tripod replaces bluebloodedtoffee effective immediately.

I'll do upkeep when I get back home tomorrow.

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 2.05

With 8 alive it's 5 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(1):

hiplop

Toogeloo(0):
Frozone(1):

Gammagooey

Gammagooey(2):

Frozone, shos

Kmd4390(0):
Unipod Tripod(1):

Toogeloo

hiplop(3):

Kmd4390, farside22, Unipod Tripod

Not voting (0):

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-05 15:30:00)

[Storyteller]

Looking for a replacement for Frozone

Can do a deadline extension if needed.

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 2.05

With 8 alive it's 5 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(1):

hiplop

Toogeloo(0):
Frozone(0):
Gammagooey(2):

Frozone, shos

Kmd4390(0):
Unipod Tripod(0):

hiplop(5):

Kmd4390, farside22, Unipod Tripod, Gammagooey, Toogeloo

Not voting (0):

A Lynch has been Reached

Flip will come in about 4 hours or so, Apologies.

[Storyteller]

I for one cannot be bothered with this.

Well, you can say that again.

I for one cannot...

Can it! murderer.

What? Preposterous!

Ve have evidence.

What evidence?

You clearly stated you vere in one place when in fact you vere in another.

I was mistaken, but what does that entail?

That you are the murderer.

No it doesn't.

Yes it does.

No it DOESN'T

YES It...

Gentlemen, please, lets be civil.

Yes, Lets string him up before somebody else dies.

Let's just tie him up first.

*Mr. Green was tied up and dragged towards the cloak room. Suddenly the lights go out. When they return, Mr. Green is dead and nobody knows what happend.*

Well that's a surprise. I guess we should all split up again.

For all the good it did to us last time.

DEAD: Hiplop(

Mr. Green

,

Town

)

Lynched in the Drawing Room.

---

Night 2 Starts

Submit your actions and movements by Wednesday, October 7, 2015, 10:30 am UTC -4 ((expired on 2015-10-07 17:30:00)) or 24 hours after I find a replacement.

[Storyteller]

Metal Sonic replaces Frozone

[Storyteller]

DEAD: Gammagooey (

Madame Rose

,

Town

)

Found shot dead in the Kitchen.

Awww, and she was such a good person.

She read my fortune before we split.

What did it say.

That I would die.

Not particularly accurate, I would say.

I would say so indeed.

Ok, Let's get on with this.

Day 3 Begins: Deadline Thursday, October 29, 2015, 09:30 pm UCT -4

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 3.00

With 6 alive it's 4 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(0):
Toogeloo(0):
Metal Sonic(0):
Kmd4390(0):
Untrop Tripod(0):

Not voting (10): shos, farside22, Toogeloo, Metal Sonic, Kmd4390, Untrod Tripod

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-29 09:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 3.01

With 6 alive it's 4 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):

farside22(2):

Toogeloo, Kmd4390

Toogeloo(1):

farside22

Metal Sonic(0):
Kmd4390(0):
Untrop Tripod(0):

Not voting (3): shos, Metal Sonic, Untrod Tripod

Shos is VLA until the 14th.
Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-29 09:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 3.02

With 6 alive it's 4 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(1):

Toogeloo

Toogeloo(1):

shos

Metal Sonic(0):
Kmd4390(0):
Untrop Tripod(0):

No Lynch(2):

Kmd4390, Metal Sonic

Not voting (2): farside22, Untrod Tripod

Shos is VLA until the 14th.
Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-29 09:30:00)

[Storyteller]

Mod, is it possible to modify the rules to reflect this? I'd hate to get to 2:2 with the revolver a potential hypothetical killing item still in play where town could no lynch, shoot scum, and be in 3p LYLO but have the game end because of a phrasing technicality.

If say you reach 2:2 at nightfall, the game will carry on regardless of items or anything, given the nature of the game. So, technically, at this point players don't know if they are lost or not. But if day break comes with 2:2, then there really is no point in continuing. Even if theoretically possible for town to win out of this, it is rare and unfair for scum.

[Storyteller]

MOD:
Does the shot that killed Gamma count for the number of shots the gun has?

If this cannot be answered:
1. Assuming there was a vigging item, can scum kill AND use it on the same night?
2. If the scum use an X-shot item for killing, does it waste one of its shots?

Scum can only make one kill per night, regardless of where that kill comes from. And if you shoot a bullet, you get one less bullet. Common sense.

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 3.03

With 6 alive it's 4 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(2):

Toogeloo, shos

Toogeloo(0):
Metal Sonic(0):
Kmd4390(0):
Untrop Tripod(0):

No Lynch(2):

Metal Sonic, farside22

Not voting (2): Kmd4390, Untrod Tripod

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-10-29 09:30:00)

[Storyteller]

VOTE COUNT 3.04

With 6 alive it's 4 votes to Lynch.

Voting for:

shos(0):
farside22(4):

Toogeloo, shos, Kmd4390, Metal Sonic

Toogeloo(0):
Metal Sonic(0):
Kmd4390(0):
Untrop Tripod(0):

No Lynch(1):

farside22

Not voting (1): Untrod Tripod

A lynch has been reached.

[Storyteller]

Too sleepy for flavor.

DEAD: Farside22(

Monsieur Brunette

,

Town

)

<insert image here>

Lynched in the Carriage house.

---

Night 3 Starts

Submit your actions and movements by Wednesday, October 21, 2015, 12:15 am UTC -4 ((expired on 2015-10-21 00:15:00)).

[Storyteller]

*Everyone Hears a loud bang. Everyone runs straight for the source of the scream in the Library.*

Is it a good idea to go towards the gun being fired?

It's not like we have a choice.

*They arrive and find Sargent Gray, white as a ghost.*

I think I've been shot. I must be dead.

No, Look, the bullet hit the wall here.

Uff.

So, is everyone here?

I can't seem to find Miss Scarlet.

Ah, well, I see. Well, then let's go to the Trophy Room, For I have solved this case.

*Sure enough, Everyone goes to the Trophy Room and Miss Scarlet is dead.*

Strangled, by the looks of it.

What do you know?

Let's see. The murderer Grabbed the rope, killed Mr. Boddy with it. Colonel Mustard Shoots the gun to the ceiling. When we split again, he grabs the wrench and Wallops Profesor Plum in the head with it. His accomplished had grabbed the gun and used it to shoot Rose.

But Miss Scarlet was quite far?

Yes indeed. The accomplice scurried to the Carriage Room, and could easily kill her from there.

So, Who are the murderers.

Clearly, the most suspected is Sargent Grey, who escaped death by a hair when Mrs White shot him and missed. Probably standing too far or something. And he was in fact near the kitchen, but then couldn't find a weapon so he relied on his accomplice... Miss Peach, to handle the next Kills. She cleverly told everyone that she was dumb enough to have dropped the gun when in fact she kept it on her purse. Everyone believed her southern accent and so went after Monsieur Brunette. She grabbed the rope and manage to sneak behind Miss Scarlet and kill her with the rope.

And how would you know all this?

Well, isn't it obvious? I invited you all here and I specifically told these two thugs to eliminate everyone. Clearly, this worked for the best here. I mean, best for me, of course. Now, my friends let's end this and go celebrate.

DEAD: Untrod Tripod(

Miss Scarlet

,

Town

)

Found strangled in the Trophy Room.

---

Game Over Mafia Wins. Consisting Of Toogeloo and Metal Sonic.

[Storyteller]

So, I hope everyone enjoyed the game. I sorta wanted the game to go on, but the gun missed the target and mafia did make the right choices in the end. I think Mafia played very well and Toogeloo did some serious strategics there.
Here is the Lobby

And here is the scum chat.

I went a ahead and ran the numbers for the next round just to satisfy KMD.

KMD Dagger CY
Shos Nothing B
Toog Nothing CY
MS Leadpipe B

I want to ask Mafia here, what actions would they have picked, to see if they can pinpoint the correct strategy in this situation.

But at most Town would have extended their life for a bit.

The 2v2 or 1v1 rule was set in place early, mostly because if you reach that position and you have a gun or something that will legitimately make a win for town, it would have been an auto win for town since they could then probably piece together who scum is in the end. I find it unlikely and a bit unfair if the opportunity presents itself.

[Storyteller]

I SAID SHOOT MSSSSS

but holy fuck toog great play! :0
Can we haz night actions?

Thanks everyone!

He did, but he was too far away and miss the shot. Did not hit the 40% chance.

[Storyteller]

I'm going to Parse the night actions, but not tonight.

I've basically posted the important actions in the Flavor. Anything not there, it's because it failed or was inconsequential.

Your poison didn't really make anyone drop FYI.

Two people dropped items because they didn't say to hold night 0. Kinda my bad cause I was certain that it was pretty clear in the rules, which they weren't. I must have copied the rules from an earlier game, before I changed that wording. So hence I changed it for night 1 and onward.

[Storyteller]

Haha kmd why did you shoot me eventually? I was a 40% chance~


Toog also evaded your shot by using the teleport so this game came down to a dice roll

That was the best shot he could have done. Toog had lied about his position and was actually next to him, but he didn't know that. Although Toog teleporting would have given him the same 40% chance of dying.

[Storyteller]

thanks for the game guille!

Glad you liked it. <3

[Storyteller]

BTW PM, you did really well day 1. You made Scum change their pacing and put the game on track for different strategies than last game.

[Storyteller]

I went a ahead and ran the numbers for the next round just to satisfy KMD.

KMD Dagger CY
Shos Nothing B
Toog Nothing CY
MS Leadpipe B

I want to ask Mafia here, what actions would they have picked, to see if they can pinpoint the correct strategy in this situation.

I would have likely used our power to summon an item and MS and I would have just pushed No Lynch. Then He would kill Shos with the Lead Pipe I would assume.

I'd use the lead pipe on Shos and Kill KMD with whatever item you conjure up. That guaranties that regardless of any item that they have, you'd still win. The lead pipe would block Shos if he had the dagger or gun.

[Storyteller]

Wrench beats Leadpipe.

[Storyteller]

There were only two differences in the game.

One is the additional "Give me a Weapon" Power, which scum did not use this game.

The other was that all mafia rules were public.

You could think that the last change was a disadvantage to scum, but given that the previous game was still there, meant that it was already public, and it forced scum to not play it too safe.

I thought of publicizing the items too, but it was fun seeing how everyone assumed things without checking the previous game much.

If I remember correctly, last game had scum messing up their locations and or making genuine mistakes. Pretty much what happened to town this game.

I am still trying to balance the game a bit more every time. I think it is quite balanced already. The flight power, as you call it, is there to allow scum to kill anybody in the game. Using it twice in one night spends it but it is safe as you won't be discovered outside of your claimed room. If you use it once you can use it again later, but there is a risk of getting discovered either by candlestick or messing up the lies.