Cool, 15 pages over the weekend. This is going to be one of those games. Anyways, reading through the thread and making comments on things as I go.
...okay, the first 7 and a half pages of this thread are pretty much useless.
Post
189 - miller claim, awesome. For everyone else in this game:
the miller should never make it to lylo. A miller is usually a Day 2 lynch or a vig shot.
I only say this because I just won a game where my scumbuddy
claimed miller in his first post of the game. It was a calculated plan that worked for us quite brilliantly and allowed us to escape with a perfect scum win.
Post
265 - Lannister votes for Wheme, calling him newbscum
one post later. From my experience with Wheme, this appears to be pretty par for the course for his play and he appears to be a pretty easy lynchbait target for scum. Keeping an eye on this one for now.
Post
289 - Edo comes in with a seemingly baseless vote on Elena, and the only thing I can see that looks like reasoning comes later:
In post 294, Edosurist wrote: In post 252, Elena Fisher wrote:Let's lynch the scum who is sitting back with something to drink watching you have at it, (It's Wheme btw) Why do people tr me again? Not that I mind please keep doing it
This was voteworthy. Wheme took a stance, which makes that statement false. I have no issues with the last two sentences.
Wheme took a stance? All he said was that
Drealm was relaxed as scum. He certainly hadn't really done a whole lot at that point. Elena's comment that Wheme was sitting back wasn't inaccurate.
Sharing townreads is horrible, and I have never been able to fathom why people do it. Unless it's you feel a back and forth is a tvt situation, there is no good reason for outing that you think someone is town outside of lylo.
In post 331, Toogeloo wrote:There's a difference between what you did, stating in jest that you are scum, and then what Dunnstral did in being very serious about claiming not to be town, and then changing their mind on that declaration later. If Dunnstral is Survivor for example, it means he's not always going to have Town's best interests at heart, and we also likely won't get much content from him. Using drealmerz argument on your declaration, he could also be a Traitor looking for his friends to pick him up. It's one thing to jest about being scum, people do it a lot. But Dunnstral flat out claimed not to be town, and then when called on it, retconned his claim. That isn't something that should just be hand waved away.
This is actually pretty good reasoning.
In post 350, Tywin Lannister wrote:People that think I'm scum here, especially those that have seen my town and scum games, are either purposely giving a wrong read for obviously non-town reasons, or they're just not good at reads in general. I won't be lynched regardless, because I'm town, have a role town won't lynch, and am usually always proven right with my early reads as town. The only way scum legitimately get rid of me is pushing for a D1 lynch on me, because after my reads flip, I become practically unlynchible. A few of the players here know this.
LAMIST?
I have to say, for a 15 page thread not much has happened here. I'm probably least happy with alban, because his Post
345 indicates that he read the thread and was dissatisfied with the gameplay thus far, but the only thing he does is state that two players are scummy "for tone and stuff" without citing any reasoning, and then leave without even casting a vote?
VOTE: alban
It's not a perfect read, but it's a start.
The Clown is Town. The Clown also uses "they" pronouns. Don't be a dick about it?
I know it's weird given the username, but "horrorperson" just doesn't have the same ring to it.
