Mini 1788: Killer Instinct Mafia [GAME OVER]

[SirCakez]

Leaving your vote on someone who's alignment you don't know in LyLo as town is a huge no-no. If you were going to stick around with the vote down in case of an unvote being needed then it's fine. But just plopping that vote down and leaving is <.<

EBWOP

[Toogeloo]

It is what it is. I don't sit at the computer, I play against the grain a lot, and in the end, I figured the odds weren't terrible, but I still bet wrong.

[Ranger]

Ranger you need to join a Kingmaker game and get yourself elected King every day.

Thinking about it more, it might actually make a neat theme game idea.

Players are assembled. Ranger is, mechanically, guaranteed to be in the game. She is also, mechanically, guaranteed to be the de facto King. Players can vote to override her, but it takes majority+1 to do so, ergo, with 9 alive minus Ranger (who cannot die), it'd take 6 votes rather than 5; with 13 alive minus Ranger, it'd take 8 votes rather than 7; with 5 alive, 4 votes rather than 3.

Would be interesting!

[KuroiXHF]

reacting when voted is a scum tell.

who ever told you that is likely scum.

It's common knowledge. It's kind of why I should have been on Zakk more after he reacted terribly to my questioning. Zakk was incredibly scummy and I either shrugged him off for being too scummy or I thought he was immature and therefore alignment indicative.

But if you overreact, you're more likely to be scum - generally speaking, of course.

[Ranger]

*Who cannot be nightkilled, at the very least.
Lynched may or may not be given, especially given I didn't specify I'd need to be town.

[Toogeloo]

Anyways, I'm done trying to justify my actions. If you guys want, I'll accept full responsibility for the loss, no other town players contributed in any way to the loss, just me.

Now clean your conscience of the game, go sign up for something else, and get your win next time.

Congrats to the scum team, you guys played extremely well, well enough that I was literally doubting every player at some point in the game. It got you the win, and you deserve it.

[Toogeloo]

reacting when voted is a scum tell.

who ever told you that is likely scum.

It's common knowledge. It's kind of why I should have been on Zakk more after he reacted terribly to my questioning. Zakk was incredibly scummy and I either shrugged him off for being too scummy or I thought he was immature and therefore alignment indicative.

But if you overreact, you're more likely to be scum - generally speaking, of course.

This is so far from the truth, and even if it was, you should have thrown the rulebook out the window since you know the situation would have deemed it worthy. You were town, you were highly confident that I was town, which means you should have been losing your shit because I put the game at risk.

[SirCakez]

Ranger: The Game?

Poor scum team

[Ranger]

Congrats to the scum team, you guys played extremely well, well enough that I was literally doubting every player at some point in the game.

I will say this as well. It was a well-played game. Even if I could name you all (I did), I couldn't actually lynch a single one of you, frustrating as that was for me, and that means you were all playing exactly the way you needed to in order to keep the vote majority off of you.

I also mirror the praise to Skull. It was a good setup. I was more or less thinking the town had what we had strength-wise, though I think the scum's backup JK was a bit excessive. (I was not expecting an all-PR scumteam when we had this many VTs and even among our roles, half of the ones we had were passive and even the active ones came with a double-edged sword.) It wasn't scumsided, nor townsided, especially not given how things went, but I think the setup would have been better with the third as a Goon. That's basically my only commentary though. It was well-made. Flavor matched decently at least for mine (can't speak of others), balance was good, and moderation was great, giving votecounts basically every time we needed them. Can't really ask for much more than that.

[Ranger]

Ranger: The Game?
Poor scum team

If someone modded it, I'd play it. :P

[KuroiXHF]

Toog, I never blamed you for screwing us over. I mean, you certainly led us to fucking up the game, but we all could have done better.

The only thing we're arguing about is if I'm a complete screw up, and I don't think I am.

We could have done better. It doesn't mean that we did terribly.

[zakk]

You were a nightmare to the scumteam :p

<3

Still ticked we lost though.

I had a chain-combo going on you guys. One reason for you being scum after another. Most of it 100% right. And yet, through something outside of my control, my health bar suddenly plummeted to zero. ;_;

It's because we landed an

ULTRAAA COMBOOOOO, BITCH!!!!!

(I take back the bitch, obv was just for Jesse pinkmanish emphasis )

[Toogeloo]

The only thing we're arguing about is if I'm a complete screw up, and I don't think I am.

No, you're not, but I was convinced you weren't reading or something else entirely by the end. The comment about scum reads voting each other, and your complete obliviousness to the ramifications of a town voting a town in LyLo didn't do you any favors from my perspective.

[SirCakez]

Ranger: The Game?
Poor scum team

If someone modded it, I'd play it.

Inb4 multiball

[Toogeloo]

(I take back the bitch, obv was just for Jesse pinkmanish emphasis )

[KuroiXHF]

The only thing we're arguing about is if I'm a complete screw up, and I don't think I am.

No, you're not, but I was convinced you weren't reading or something else entirely by the end. The comment about scum reads voting each other, and your complete obliviousness to the ramifications of a town voting a town in LyLo didn't do you any favors from my perspective.

I disagree with you and you disagree with me. There's nothing we can do now. I don't think either of us will suddenly realize they're wrong. Let's agree to disagree, 'k? No hard feelings.

[Toogeloo]

Oh, no, I'm over it, been so for a while. I just wanted it to be clear why it played out the way it did from my side of things.

[Toogeloo]

To the scum team's credit, I was hard town reading you day 1, and they managed to make me completely doubt it by the end of the game.

[Toogeloo]

And to be honest... I think the site downtime might have contributed in a small way as well. I didn't move you down to scum until I reread the cached copy of the game. If the site hadn't gone down, I'd probably still have you as town read today.

[KuroiXHF]

VOTE: Mith

[zakk]

To the scum team's credit, I was hard town reading you day 1, and they managed to make me completely doubt it by the end of the game.

Yay!

[zakk]

VOTE: Mith

Nahhhhh

VOTE: The mouse that chewed the server wires

[Egg]

It was actually a tiger.

[Shinobi]

I'm okay with the scum qt being opened.
Thanks for hosting Skull. I thought you did a good job.
Thumbs up to my scumteam - Cakez for managing to keep it together and zakk for carrying us home at endgame.

gg

[Aneninen]

Uhhhhhhhhh I guess we played this terribly.
I wanted to analyze the game and I'd have liked those scumlists to check whether they'd match the gameplays but everything had ended before I got back. Actually it's my fault. I should have known it, after all I got lynched on Day3 with 0 posts...