Mini 543 - Election Day - Game Over!

[farside22]

Congrats to Skruffs. I want Fonz to write many times over and over. Farside is not always scum. Did you really just have to keep ignoring every scummy comment Skruffs made.
I hate that I was right with Qman/ Skruffs scum and that Fonz just didnt' want to listen.

[farside22]

I wanted to add.
Rishi I really enjoyed the game. I think the fact that the scum hit a power role first N0 really hurt the town. I think that there wasn't votes did cause a bit of delay in the game. Overall an interesting idea.

[hasdgfas]

I still don't understand why I was lynched, to be honest. Anyone want to explain that to me?

I would agree that not voting in thread kinda killed the game later. I don't have too much else to say since I was dead pretty much the whole time. Good job Skruffs, even though your inactivity made me squirm.

[Rishi]

Choices:

Night 0

Mafia kills Spider Jerusalem.
Spider Jerusalem sends no kill.
Akonas investigates QuickBen (later Mgm)

Election 1

Shanba forces Rigel to vote for hasdgfas. (Rigel was already voting for hasdgfas.)

Night 1

Mafia kills Rigel.
Akonas investigates farside22.

Election 2

Shanba forces Holy to vote for opie. (Holy was voting for Mgm.)

Night 2

Mafia kills Akonas.
Akonas investigates Holy.

Election 3

Shanba forces farside22 to vote for Holy. (farside22 was voting for Skruffs.)

Night 3

Mafia kills Shanba.

Night 4

Mafia kills Mgm.

[Rishi]

The game was almost cracked open on Night 2. Qman wasn't sure if he could target the person with immunity with his kill. He basically said that, if he could kill Akonas, he would. If not, he would kill Shanba.

If Akonas lived that night, he could have claimed cop and been able to clear Mgm, farside22 and Holy. It would have almost guaranteed victory for town.

Why Akonas didn't use his immunity votes to point out his innocent investigations (except for Day 1), I'll never know. If he cleared farside22 before dying, the last couple days of this game would have been altered dramatically.

[Skruffs]

Wow, I survived just by being alive at the final polls???
>.> That's interesting.

I had a really, really hard time 'interacting' the final tday because I had to make fonz suspicious by towninizing farside22... I couldn't switch on her because it would have made me look suspicious, so I had to kind of ignore fonz.

Everything I attributed to fonz was actually the exact same situation me and QMan were in the night beforel we could have won by voting farside22 but if all the other players were voting him it would have completely outed me as a liar.

[Qman]

The game was almost cracked open on Night 2. Qman wasn't sure if he could target the person with immunity with his kill. He basically said that, if he could kill Akonas, he would. If not, he would kill Shanba.

If Akonas lived that night, he could have claimed cop and been able to clear Mgm, farside22 and Holy. It would have almost guaranteed victory for town.

Why Akonas didn't use his immunity votes to point out his innocent investigations (except for Day 1), I'll never know. If he cleared farside22 before dying, the last couple days of this game would have been altered dramatically.

Agreed. I was virtually certain Akonas was the cop at the end of day 2, it really woulda sucked if he wasn't nkable.

I really had figured out that shanba was the pol. I was kinda iffy on killing him, as i thought it'd get me lynched, as it did.

I figured I was toast once Shanba turned up Pol, and after driving to Holy mislynch so I tried even harder to tie myself to Farside in non-obvious ways, something I'd been trying to do all game.

[Qman]

Wow, I survived just by being alive at the final polls???
>.> That's interesting.

I had a really, really hard time 'interacting' the final tday because I had to make fonz suspicious by towninizing farside22... I couldn't switch on her because it would have made me look suspicious, so I had to kind of ignore fonz.

Everything I attributed to fonz was actually the exact same situation me and QMan were in the night beforel we could have won by voting farside22 but if all the other players were voting him it would have completely outed me as a liar.

Think Survivor.

When you are immune, the other two people can only vote for each other. Ergo your vote is the deciding vote. No matter who you voted for, it would result in a win. Once you got immunity town was toast.

[Holy]

I still don't understand why I was lynched, to be honest. Anyone want to explain that to me?

Villager's thirst for blood~, I suppose.. :p


Too bad, no one

(in)

sane enough for agreeing with scummy-me to take skruffs down except farside. And it was stolen for my head too, lol.

[Holy]

Think Survivor.

When you are immune, the other two people can only vote for each other. Ergo your vote is the deciding vote. No matter who you voted for, it would result in a win. Once you got immunity town was toast.

Erhm!

Immunity Skruff

Hmm. I did negate the random immunity rule, but I guess intentional immunity is still okay.

[Qman]

Think Survivor.

When you are immune, the other two people can only vote for each other. Ergo your vote is the deciding vote. No matter who you voted for, it would result in a win. Once you got immunity town was toast.

Erhm!

Immunity Skruff

Hmm. I did negate the random immunity rule, but I guess intentional immunity is still okay.

No idea what you are saying there.

[Holy]

^Never mind...
I thought the Immunity-rule was disabled last round. But it seems I'm wrong, the random immunity rule was the one that disabled.

[The Fonz]

Hmmm. The problem here was, I found Skruffs' case so absurd, so illogical, so likely to make him look really bad, that I couldn't see scum pushing it to try to gain an advantage- and his stubbornness in sticking to it made me think him town. Meanwhile, farside was swinging back and forth like a palm tree in a hurricane...

[Rishi]

Wow, I survived just by being alive at the final polls???
>.> That's interesting.

I had a really, really hard time 'interacting' the final tday because I had to make fonz suspicious by towninizing farside22... I couldn't switch on her because it would have made me look suspicious, so I had to kind of ignore fonz.

Everything I attributed to fonz was actually the exact same situation me and QMan were in the night beforel we could have won by voting farside22 but if all the other players were voting him it would have completely outed me as a liar.

Think Survivor.

When you are immune, the other two people can only vote for each other. Ergo your vote is the deciding vote. No matter who you voted for, it would result in a win. Once you got immunity town was toast.

Exactly. I saw no point going through the voting phase again. The Fonz and farside could only vote for each other. Skruffs would vote for one of them, get them lynched and then night kill the other.

Since victory was inevitable, there was no point playing things out.

Yeah, I thought Shanba was pretty obviously the politician too. I think you made a good call by killing him, though, Qman. If he stayed alive in a lynch or lose situation (and had a good read on the game), then he could have been extremely powerful.

[Skruffs]

QMan and me wasn't really sure who to kill the first night I Replaced in... I wound up sending in a kill on Shanba just because he always winds up getting ridiculously suspicious of me the closer to endgame we get in these kind of games.


I don' tthink it was mentioned that he was a likely power role. >.> It was either "Well MGM is probably cleared" and "Shanba's been razzing on me lately", or something like that.

[farside22]

I was frustrated the last day that no one was talking. I knew Skruffs was scum and felt no matter what I said Fonz wasn't going to listen. I tried to point out how he was scummy and it was like talking to someone with deaf ears. Oh well. I tried hard to prove I was right. I can't believe Fonz thinks I'm really that dumb.

[Rishi]

I was frustrated the last day that no one was talking. I knew Skruffs was scum and felt no matter what I said Fonz wasn't going to listen. I tried to point out how he was scummy and it was like talking to someone with deaf ears. Oh well. I tried hard to prove I was right. I can't believe Fonz thinks I'm really that dumb.

You had a good read on this game, though. I think, as early as Day 3, you had Qman and Skruffs pegged as the final two scum.

Skruffs did have the huge advantage that Ibby and Gorgon both gave very little information. He came in with almost a fresh start.

[Qman]

QMan and me wasn't really sure who to kill the first night I Replaced in... I wound up sending in a kill on Shanba just because he always winds up getting ridiculously suspicious of me the closer to endgame we get in these kind of games.


I don' tthink it was mentioned that he was a likely power role. >.> It was either "Well MGM is probably cleared" and "Shanba's been razzing on me lately", or something like that.

If i saved my night PM's I'd pull it up, but I think i mentioned it. Maybe i'm just misremembering the heavy innuendo i placed that he was the pol in thread though.

[The Fonz]

I was frustrated the last day that no one was talking. I knew Skruffs was scum and felt no matter what I said Fonz wasn't going to listen. I tried to point out how he was scummy and it was like talking to someone with deaf ears. Oh well. I tried hard to prove I was right. I can't believe Fonz thinks I'm really that dumb.

It's because Farside,

YOUR ARGUMENTS WEREN'T VERY GOOD.

[Skruffs]

That's the worst thing, when you know, but don't know how to properly explain.I have to deal with that a LOT as town.

[MeMe]

last post