Mini 1907: Oddrole Mafia IV (Game over)

[TheBrie]

Though Creature has a hiding action. So if Snarky is scum, and we no lynch, we'll be in exactly the same place.
And if I was scum, I could still kill Snarky.

[TheBrie]

A50 and Snarky does look like a terrible partnership. I've found this one thing.

@Brie:

I don't think podo would have stick out his neck that far to defend his buddy, lest SS got lynched on the spot (and he sure did look like the lynch at the time). podo said he had "mechanical" reason. I took that to be a Tracker/Follower/Watcher who saw SS visit someone who didn't die. However, Java is now crumbing Tracker/Watcher, and SS said he doesn't have a visiting ability, so podo might have been a Vanilla Cop (thus the uncertainty).

If Almost had thought Snarky was Tracker/Watcher, why wasn't Snarky one of the N1 kills?

I'm grasping at straws here because I can find a plausible answer myself. Maybe he couldn't find a good excuse for CPRing him and Podo seemed more dangerous.

[TheBrie]

I was just thinking about the lack of kills N0. Creature said he was hiding that night which is a possible explanation. I can't think of any other options, though I suppose we could have had a doctor who became Goo. Maybe Podo protected Snarky N0 and assumed he was town since nobody died. That makes good sense.

[Creature]

Okay, I'm checking that revive.

[Creature]

What did Chickadee claim again?

[Creature]

Oh nvm, you mean't Gingham.

[Creature]

Well, that's basically it.

VOTE: Snarky

[Creature]

It's gonna be less painful if it turns out TheBrie was scum but had revive.

It's gonna be more painful if I failed to realise a detail.

[TheBrie]

Don't worry. I'm town.
And I didn't even get to examine GL"s ISO for connections to Snarky.
I do think that when Almost had both partners in his lynch pool it was due to elimination. He never tried to push anything on GL. And it did a good job of hiding Snarky as his partner.

[Creature]

That would be the first time I would win a 3p LyLo.

[SnarkySnowman]

Though Creature has a hiding action. So if Snarky is scum, and we no lynch, we'll be in exactly the same place.
And if I was scum, I could still kill Snarky.

Congrats creature, mafia or goo?

[TheBrie]

And now we wait for the Mod to arrive and sort us out.
You puzzle me by that post, Snarky. If it wasn't for the fact we know there was three Mafia and only two were killed before now, I'd worry all we had left was goo. None of the town flips look like they could be disguised scum, so I still think I've got it right.

[Creature]

Oh nice, now I have to deduce who's trolling...

[eagerSnake]

VC 4.04 (FINAL)

SnarkySnowman (2) [LYNCHED]: TheBrie, Creature

Not Voting (1): SnarkySnowman

With 3 alive, it takes 2 to lynch.

Day 4 deadline was in (expired on 2017-06-22 20:37:01).

[eagerSnake]

SnarkySnowman has been lynched!
He was a

Recruiter (mafia)

!

Living players (2): TheBrie, Creature

Spoiler: SnarkySnowman - Recruiter (mafia)

[quote]You are a

Recruiter (mafia)

!

You have a one-shot ability to recruit a town player into the mafia, turning them into a Mafioso. You may continue to use the recruit until it is successful. This counts as the mafia kill the nights you use it. If you die, the recruited player also dies.

Actions:

recruit [player] (1 use)

: Recruits another town player into the mafia as a Mafioso. Counts as the mafiakill the nights used. You may continue to use the recruit until it is successful.

mafiakill [player]

: Kills another player. Only one mafia can use mafiakill each night. A doctor can prevent the kill, and some roles are immune.

You win when you have majority and there are no other killers.

[/quote][/spoiler]

[eagerSnake]

A win condition cannot be achieved.

It's a draw!

The "winners" are the members of the Black Goo (cult) and the Town!

Will update later.

[Creature]

Do I count this as win or draw?

[Rautherdir]

I'd treat it as a win. It's not a true draw since mafia aren't able to win anymore under any circumstance, but town can still win if you had self-voted the following day, and goo could have won if Brie had self-voted both of the following days.
Those are the only valid win-conditions left and since each requires the other team to surrender it's a draw.

[GinghamDog]

What a roller coaster.

[Creature]

The reviver literally (and indirectly) won us the game.

[GinghamDog]

Podo's "clear" on Snarky really threw a huge monkey wrench into the whole game.

[Creature]

Good thing I didn't notice that clear.

[Rautherdir]

Yeah I don't think anyone considered the lack of kills night 0 to be the fact that the mafia had other actions they used.

[podoboq]

So explanation. I mupped Snarky night zero. I either did nothing, cop checked, protected, or killed her.

I know she didn't die, and I know I didn't cop check her, so either nothing happened or I protected her.

Me protecting her explained a lack of night kill, so until another explanation came out, I thought it was best to assume the decent possibility that Snarky was the night kill target. Also, if I died at night (which I expected would happen), then my role would reveal and everything would be explained.


I targeted Massive on the second night, and turned into goo before I flipped, concealing my role and the information therein.

[Almost50]

Well, this game once more proved how poor we all are at Town play. I still can't believe Snarky nor only escaped the lynch on D1, but made it all the way to LyLo. It's amazing how TOWN defends Scum all the time (and God knows I've been guilty of that more than my fair share)